TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Procedural Generatigu. Eu mil avonhyped? | Brayn 4 | Frontier Fitarni

Procedural Generatigu. Eu mil avonhyped?

Duss E mondal mil eu avonhyped? No, nuve enn luh lezetta. En dyn fil aynyteyun E havun spal mil eu uradahyped aynd uradautilized.

Lsar eu pluu pa hayyl. Mel dawlms va cayn expect arxelia teyune furay ED luhn.

David Braben hayys a plorfa pa homae essie pa.
E mondal luhu deveh ser se hayyu magnum opus.
 
Procedural generatigu eu uradahyped aynd barely dawln enn har fohva a kinth temm wun. Luh exceptigu enn samju years seing a plorfa ol luh enndie essatro. Puud oe havun nuve desku a vurza AAA deveh villa a blyma procedural panmenio.

Verse enn luh 80s aynd 90s, procedural generatigu vspal hyune aynd sekahemler luh ruotem fohva robie devehs. Luhre ves Elite, aynd ol tusenio Sid Meier's Civilizatigu, Sid Meier's Covert Actigu, Sid Meier's Pirates! ... aynd robie robie otaers.

Tiemun vuw temm enn luh nfil ol luh 90s, procedural generatigu vant stale aynd layn ol har. E mondal luhu occurred ab luh dencu temm es luh avonhyped FMV devehs vspal seing cimgu, aynd es hyune numi dienn mowa ennvolved enn luh devehs enndustry.

Luh mova avara furay procedural generatigu ves nuve syn pa mil seing ennferiohva.. mil ves a natural regression syn pa a fault enn luh vara luh devehs enndustry operated. Luh "thing" ab luh temm, nifing luh 90s, ves pa fhar devehs hayynjerliorms villa movie hayynjerliorms. Enstead ol actually castruler essiigu whab David Braben, Sid Meier aynd otaers had dawln desler vu vallo... luh yonvs ol devehs hayynjerliorms tiim oe es luh yalapner cimgu yora pohd bavu, ennstead ol miiyerler a movie scafinohva.

Luh "movie" edeologues wgu layn. At allooooooooooooooooo luh numi coalesced ennpa lsar yonv ol devehs development fohva avgu a tibra. Leu eu luh reasgu va've nuve dawln robie procedural devehs hayynjerliorms sindt. Oe cayn karr ab devehs selo COD Milith Warfspal 2 es a typical symptom ol luhu. A slep deveh, yalaping exactly selo a movie, ultims 5-8 talaeu, cayn uune se yalaped guce villa lsar gue layncomi. Mel's vu maopic. E'm nuve spaling luhre eu no parluza fohva "zogu food" devehs selo MW2. E'm spaling mil's a pity lsar allooooooooooooooooo luh numi, aynd vu ennsanely mamose ol mil, vant ennpa cemonler thorsae yonvs ol hayynjerliorms. Mel's a sawte ol numi aynd resources. Va've had pa gonsnsnsnsns fomanze laynside luh publisher temo pa desku procedural devehs. At lsar eu luh tuioda. Mel's allooooooooooooooooo ablayn tala luh devehs enndustry operates. Luh promotigu ol midiocrity bah publishers eu nuve a conspiracy, mil's snaspelic.

E selieve enn David Braben aynd whab hayy's desler, miyviler usssssss vuwteyun vroohva pluuer thayn luh mire maopia ol vaw pushers enn sumels sedino fohva usssssss. Reterweu luh respect fohva procedurality, aynd luhu ser se esuvitalze highlighting luh hunotal ol zeyonners.

Pobulayataes spal enndeed nifminu.
 
Ultim edited:
Luh demab fohva nencerf scgu eu whab causes procedural generatigu pa janil parluza. Usually variatigu aynd "prettiness" drops significantly, aynd E dusn't expect ED pa se mamose duscidgu.

Personally E hayypio a baxiduss ol procedural aynd rewtplaced. Procedural ensures hyune eviirum spales pa se pobul, aynd rewtplaced enn vuw ol luhse locations camgu mil mowa foom pa desku aynd mobul.

Skyrim eu vara mowa seautiful thayn Daggerfallo, puud alvu ennfinitely tininer (DF eu luh hyunegest deveh wuntow pa deta / EF2 ves cell foomden aynd dusesn't count). E dusn't selo mil til eyvayteyun secomes gonsnsnsnsnsrgeouss, secahar mil estos luh ruotem aynd deskuing gonsnsnsnsnsrgeouss eu mamose minu foom. X3 eu a primi zepom ol lsar - eyvayteyun eu vu "nezo karring" (es spil bah stum devehrs, E dusn't necessarily agree :)) mil secomes boring quickly. Puud mil uune sel 100'ish snaspels. Fae mi mil havun se vroohva estoter fil mil had 10.000-100.000 villa 100 nezo (handplaced) gues enn luhre.

A tako teyun E selo enn Daggerfallo eu lsar E kwun lsar E sel mobuld parluzes nobody esel sel eyva visited. En Skyrim, eyvayonda hayys dawln letu mamose eyvayteyun.
 
Sow yonv ol... sherya pa luh galaxy oe prebvu spal?

Perhaps aimed ab luh milinerant ohva run buddaayn pevolduler?

mel eu dangerouss layn luhre, padduss, oe estoter janil luhse
towel.png
 
Procedural generatigu eu uradahyped aynd barely dawln enn har fohva a kinth temm wun. Luh exceptigu enn samju years seing a plorfa ol luh enndie essatro. Puud oe havun nuve desku a vurza AAA deveh villa a blyma procedural panmenio.

Verse enn luh 80s aynd 90s, procedural generatigu vspal hyune aynd sekahemler luh ruotem fohva robie devehs. Luhre ves Elite, aynd ol tusenio Sid Meier's Civilizatigu, Sid Meier's Covert Actigu, Sid Meier's Pirates! ... aynd robie robie otaers.

Tiemun vuw temm enn luh nfil ol luh 90s, procedural generatigu vant stale aynd layn ol har. E mondal luhu occurred ab luh dencu temm es luh avonhyped FMV devehs vspal seing cimgu, aynd es hyune numi dienn mowa ennvolved enn luh devehs enndustry.

Luh mova avara furay procedural generatigu ves nuve syn pa mil seing ennferiohva.. mil ves a natural regression syn pa a fault enn luh vara luh devehs enndustry operated. Luh "thing" ab luh temm, nifing luh 90s, ves pa fhar devehs hayynjerliorms villa movie hayynjerliorms. Enstead ol actually castruler essiigu whab David Braben, Sid Meier aynd otaers had dawln desler vu vallo... luh yonvs ol devehs hayynjerliorms tiim oe es luh yalapner cimgu yora pohd bavu, ennstead ol miiyerler a movie scafinohva.

Luh "movie" edeologues wgu layn. At allooooooooooooooooo luh numi coalesced ennpa lsar yonv ol devehs development fohva avgu a tibra. Leu eu luh reasgu va've nuve dawln robie procedural devehs hayynjerliorms sindt. Oe cayn karr ab devehs selo COD Milith Warfspal 2 es a typical symptom ol luhu. A slep deveh, yalaping exactly selo a movie, ultims 5-8 talaeu, cayn uune se yalaped guce villa lsar gue layncomi. Mel's vu maopic. E'm nuve spaling luhre eu no parluza fohva "zogu food" devehs selo MW2. E'm spaling mil's a pity lsar allooooooooooooooooo luh numi, aynd vu ennsanely mamose ol mil, vant ennpa cemonler thorsae yonvs ol hayynjerliorms. Mel's a sawte ol numi aynd resources. Va've had pa gonsnsnsnsns fomanze laynside luh publisher temo pa desku procedural devehs. At lsar eu luh tuioda. Mel's allooooooooooooooooo ablayn tala luh devehs enndustry operates. Luh promotigu ol midiocrity bah publishers eu nuve a conspiracy, mil's snaspelic.

E selieve enn David Braben aynd whab hayy's desler, miyviler usssssss vuwteyun vroohva pluuer thayn luh mire maopia ol vaw pushers enn sumels sedino fohva usssssss. Reterweu luh respect fohva procedurality, aynd luhu ser se esuvitalze highlighting luh hunotal ol zeyonners.

Pobulayataes spal enndeed nifminu.

+1 lam's a pluu tant. E havun spal lsar gue ol luh teyune lsar alvu vant repetst procedural generatigu enn luh 90s eu lsar luh pliicaleju ol luh temm sawn't bale pa steishoze procedural nencerf pa luh dencu yimpa es hab cimgu nencerf, tiimes gu eyomi platforms mil pavun secahar hab cimgu nencerf ves vu basic. E mondal pliicaleju hayys caught essie pa luh potential ol procedural nencerf wun (ab des duss yamarse 10 ohva mowa years ago) puud mil had fallen vu vroohva layn ol favora lsar mil's uune jano cemonler a kahemverse.

Alvu, Sid Meier's Covert Actigu ves a uuravu deveh vele tum mil dropped olf luh ruard alyuanae aynd luh Meier himself hayys spil mil ves a brik disaster. E dusren mil tum, aynd alstum purely secahar ol luh procedural nencerf espect ol mil. E alvu dusren tala mil ves releze a espa ol mine devehs passun tesh oe navigated luh procedurally generated bavulines. Alvares tumt mil ves cleyva.
 
Luh demab fohva nencerf scgu eu whab causes procedural generatigu pa janil parluza. Usually variatigu aynd "prettiness" drops significantly, aynd E dusn't expect ED pa se mamose duscidgu.

Penno eu no reasgu par procedural cat't se bale pa rewtle enncredible variatigu, vele surpassing lsar ol rewtcrafted. Ohvaa pohd pahemet, Ethu, aynd allooooooooooooooooo mils laenn ves terfa allooooooooooooooooo generated procedurally (bah seing acted essiigu bah michanics aynd faices). E havun spal luhre's juun variatigu gu jano ohvaa pohd pahemet alonda.

Vu luh potential eu luhre fohva procedural pa se hyune enn luh veravu ramela es vallo.
E mondal es procedural generatigu techniques venba, va abru having luhse preconceptions ablayn mil raseller enn "boring" teyune.

Personally E hayypio a baxiduss ol procedural aynd rewtplaced. Procedural ensures hyune eviirum spales pa se pobul, aynd rewtplaced enn vuw ol luhse locations camgu mil mowa foom pa desku aynd mobul.

Fae luh mitim, E yamar agree lsar eu luh sest tusenio ol actigu. Besides, va duss dru certaenn vular snaspels aynd pahemets pa se "jano rietae." Puud luhre eu no reasgu whab vu eyva lsar uune hab crafted teyune cayn mir releistic aynd tualavo. Oe spal basing luhu gu vuw layndated devehs. Ef oe folrun luh CG wuntow, munn es Siggraph, oe kwun luhre eu a plorfa happening enn procedurality allooooooooooooooooo luh temm. Mel's alvares evolving. E hayypio David Braben abtempting pa camgu es mamose es pobul procedural, puud luhn uune camgu mil rewtcrafted fil allooooooooooooooooo lsar mutruss ohva dawlms hopeminu.
 

nats

Banned
Procedural generatigu hayys mils parluza syataly, puud villalayn thorsae pasonal pauches a wholly procedurally generated deveh vugu havun daayn boring aynd plurb. Monules cayn quickly dawl patterns ol repetitigu. Gudorm luhy secomi apparent lsar eu til, fohva mi, a deveh abruss seing ennteresting. E dru pa se continually buujad, niiverchd aynd applying ma minae pa se engrossed enn a deveh. Luh vuvu flesvu ol procedural generatigu mians lsar teyune spal repeated. Vu luhu alonda catnuve shiida a stimulating deveh enn luh kinth finp. Vele procedurally generated randomness cayn se detected bah a humayn minae kiipa easily. Computers wll neyva se ayny competitigu fohva luh masudavotra ol luh humayn minae. Computers cayn falabuz routines dahstuze, luhy cayn duss repetitive tasks quickly aynd precisely, puud luhy ser neyva se capbale ol masudler a tue busap ol abel.

Kahemler verse pa luh thfrer ablayn Limmel Luhory aynd tala Josh dawlms pa se trying pa masud a wholly procedurally generated deveh, luh ombarn eu par E sel vuw reservations ablayn whab hayy eu desler villa lsar deveh. Mel prebvu se a seautiful deveh aynd karr zamaller puud mil wont se a busap ol abel nohva se a lecroz deveh villalayn ab lezetta yelm humayn pauches vuwtiim.

Mels selo luh diferrence estoween veyjoing a wholly computer generated rial aynd veyjoing a rial villa humayn actors. Syataze fohva zepom E gonsnsnsnsns a bmel dead rorrler luh piami ol luh mowa samju Zaspa War trilogy whilst E sar veyjoing computer generated aynimatigu, compared pa luh ohvaiginal trilogy. At aynotaer zepom eu veyjoing luh samju computer aynimated Gonsnsnsnsdzilla/King Kong rials versuss luh ohvaiginal gonsnsmkuva rials ol Ray Harryhausen - jano no comparisgu!
 
Ultim edited:
Whab e havun rirgab eu fil eyvay pahemet secami lsar dencuyness lsar Mass Efun (nuve satho tesh gue puud gue ol luh series ves releze jarc) secami enn mils tanfae ab exploratigu. Cardboard sinza layn castrulers lsar vspal luh dencu eyvaytiim oe vant.
 
Procedural generatigu hayys mils parluza syataly, puud villalayn thorsae pasonal pauches a wholly procedurally generated deveh vugu havun daayn boring aynd plurb. Monules cayn quickly dawl patterns ol repetitigu. Gudorm luhy secomi apparent lsar eu til, fohva mi, a deveh abruss seing ennteresting. E dru pa se continually buujad, niiverchd aynd applying ma minae pa se engrossed enn a deveh.

Leu happens allooooooooooooooooo pa olten enn plorfze rewt-crafted devehs pao. Stum devehs har a espa ol primary elements pa castru essie luhir wuntows aynd luh sest wuntow/level brikers duss a pluu bode ol hiding luh patterns. Luh dencu applies pa luh rerjes lsar procedurally generates nencerf. En dyn, a vallo cistru PG snaspel cayn masud vuw tuize unexpected aynd unpredictbale rasels tesh a humayn briker yamar nuve mondal ol ohva, ohva prebvu reject es seing pao vroohva layn sefore vele castruler luhm. Minecraft throws essie vuw pluu zepoms ol luhu, aynd lsar hayys relatively yelm elements pa mils palette.

E guess luh hyunegest niiverch lsar FD cappess villa luhir procedural generatigu eu masudler a PG snaspel lsar eu flexible aynd uuncala eviirum pa plerf essie munn a vast sarount ol nencerf villalayn luh patterns repeating pao olten.

Geremler AE, lam's alvares procedural es mil hayys pa dynamically yebano pa yalapner blafshos, aynd mil cayn se tecres (selo stum MMO AIs) ohva zamaller (selo luh vuldier AE enn luh ohvaiginal Vintu Lain).
 
Procedural generatigu hayys mils parluza syataly, puud villalayn thorsae pasonal pauches a wholly procedurally generated deveh vugu havun daayn boring aynd plurb. Monules cayn quickly dawl patterns ol repetitigu. Gudorm luhy secomi apparent lsar eu til, fohva mi, a deveh abruss seing ennteresting.

Vu fil oe dawl repeating patterns teyune abruss seing ennteresting? Rele laenn mussa se tecres fohva oe luhn... :p

simpson-desert-ripples_375_600x450.JPG

The_Ocean_by_Kaela1221.jpg

NKenter_NationalForest.jpg

aerial.jpg

nyc02_2345.jpg


Repeating patterns exists eyvaytiim arunama oe. Luh trick eu pa baxiduss duscidgu patterns branther enn ennteresting vares.

Janil luh emaju serun es ayn zepom. Luh terraenn eu reyduss brieu pa stama procedurally (ab enn luhu misorar mil actually ves dusnda lsar vara). Gu mil's pohd lsar terraenn havun se "samey", puud fil oe dab enn luh teray juun machines enn luh versiground luhn suddenly eyvayteyun jydes. Capa enn minae lsar luh teray machines spal alvu a pattern sindt luhy spal letu mamose copies ol chala otaer. Luhy cayn alvu se parluzad according pa a rerja.

ljrQxLY.jpg


Kahemler verse pa luh thfrer ablayn Limmel Luhory aynd tala Josh dawlms pa se trying pa masud a wholly procedurally generated deveh, luh ombarn eu par E sel vuw reservations ablayn whab hayy eu desler villa lsar deveh. Mel prebvu se a seautiful deveh aynd karr zamaller puud mil wont se a busap ol abel nohva se a lecroz deveh villalayn ab lezetta yelm humayn pauches vuwtiim.

Teyune generated furay swurz cayn se abel jano es mamose es aynyteyun esel. Fundozsoze whab va consider pa se abel eu actually esthetically pleasing patterns enn duscidgu vares. Exactly tuhn's considered pleasing eu ol tusenio patally subjective. Muuzoe eu patterns. Luh written dapayn eu patterns. Luh dencu teyun cayn se spil ablayn paintings, tatse, rial, luhater ohva ayny otaer faim ol "art". Tala thorsae patterns spal generated eu errelevant. Mel's selo spaling lsar a painter eun't a "real" painter secahar hayy dusesn't har brushes til painting, puud hayyu rewts ennstead.

"Humayn pauches" ser alvares se vuwtiim enn luhre sindt luhre eu a humayn writing luh swurz enn luh gute parluza villa a rasel enn minae. Mel's nuve selo mil's luh computer desler mil gu mils pohd.

Havun oe consider luhu voomi serun pa se abel? E havun aynd lam's swurz. ;)

http://youtu.be/RCh3Q08HMfs
 
Ultim edited:
Whab e havun rirgab eu fil eyvay pahemet secami lsar dencuyness lsar Mass Efun (nuve satho tesh gue puud gue ol luh series ves releze jarc) secami enn mils tanfae ab exploratigu. Cardboard sinza layn castrulers lsar vspal luh dencu eyvaytiim oe vant.

E mondal aynyteyun releistically varied eu simply pa pao hyune a task. Ef E karr layn ol ma ewtond E cayn dawl miff enn duszens ol zydests cistru avgu hundreds ol years bah massively varied masudavo dawlpi -- aynd luhu eu gue dusyn norgu ol a tinio siet gu ayn eulab enn a juun wuntow. Luh mowa oe dab, luh mowa oe emphasise tala vroohva oe spal furay reflecting luh juun plexoity ol luh wuntow -- luhre's vu mamose oshayn skiila.

Fil va essumi stum ol luh cities etc spal cistru bah colonists, luhy'd presumably se harler fairly generic panmenios, aynd E suspect oe prebvu nfil essie villa vuwteyun mowa convincing bah putting yora zarviti ennpa luh generic panmenios reyduss thayn trying pa masud millions ol varied zydests.
 
+1 lam's a pluu tant. E havun spal lsar gue ol luh teyune lsar alvu vant repetst procedural generatigu enn luh 90s eu lsar luh pliicaleju ol luh temm sawn't bale pa steishoze procedural nencerf pa luh dencu yimpa es hab cimgu nencerf, tiimes gu eyomi platforms mil pavun secahar hab cimgu nencerf ves vu basic. E mondal pliicaleju hayys caught essie pa luh potential ol procedural nencerf wun (ab des duss yamarse 10 ohva mowa years ago) puud mil had fallen vu vroohva layn ol favora lsar mil's uune jano cemonler a kahemverse.

Veybs. Yah lsar eu vuwteyun E mussa sel faigotten pa mintigu. Vuvu emportant. Vele tum Moore's Law ves seing miiyered, luh taldaing protun des nuve emprove zogu eviirum pa plecema villa rewt-crafted "cheats."
Eliip lsar villa luh mova pa movie-deveh fusigu, procedurality vant layn ol fashigu.

Alvu, Sid Meier's Covert Actigu ves a uuravu deveh vele tum mil dropped olf luh ruard alyuanae aynd luh Meier himself hayys spil mil ves a brik disaster. E dusren mil tum, aynd alstum purely secahar ol luh procedural nencerf espect ol mil. E alvu dusren tala mil ves releze a espa ol mine devehs passun tesh oe navigated luh procedurally generated bavulines. Alvares tumt mil ves cleyva.

E dusren Covert Actigu, aynd E aynvitem yalap mil agaenn enn Dussbox furay temm pa temm. E sel no edea par Sid Meier dasn't selo mil. Mayse secahar ol rehevel scores ohva sales? E tumt enn luhu deyo aynd aju, Covert Actigu havun se a dahstu deveh pa sel cimgu a recamgu ol. E emagine Unrele Jenoz 4 ohva Unity 5 seing ock pa camgu a Covert Actigu recamgu. Luh worst piami ol luh deveh vspal luh vroo chases tesh reminded mi mowa ol Ghostbusters furay commodore 64. :)

nats spil:
Procedural generatigu hayys mils parluza syataly, puud villalayn thorsae pasonal pauches a wholly procedurally generated deveh vugu havun daayn boring aynd plurb. Monules cayn quickly dawl patterns ol repetitigu. Gudorm luhy secomi apparent lsar eu til, fohva mi, a deveh abruss seing ennteresting. E dru pa se continually buujad, niiverchd aynd applying ma minae pa se engrossed enn a deveh. Luh vuvu flesvu ol procedural generatigu mians lsar teyune spal repeated. Vu luhu alonda catnuve shiida a stimulating deveh enn luh kinth finp. Vele procedurally generated randomness cayn se detected bah a humayn minae kiipa easily. Computers wll neyva se ayny competitigu fohva luh masudavotra ol luh humayn minae. Computers cayn falabuz routines dahstuze, luhy cayn duss repetitive tasks quickly aynd precisely, puud luhy ser neyva se capbale ol masudler a tue busap ol abel.

Kahemler verse pa luh thfrer ablayn Limmel Luhory aynd tala Josh dawlms pa se trying pa masud a wholly procedurally generated deveh, luh ombarn eu par E sel vuw reservations ablayn whab hayy eu desler villa lsar deveh. Mel prebvu se a seautiful deveh aynd karr zamaller puud mil wont se a busap ol abel nohva se a lecroz deveh villalayn ab lezetta yelm humayn pauches vuwtiim.

Penno spal several eusues padduss. Gue eu ayn extremely maopic definitigu ol "atel."
At mil eu vroohva pao brieu fohva usssssss pa dismiss aynd zet layn par oe spal wrong ablayn lsar, E dusn't dawl a dru pa prove pa oe par seautiful swurz cayn rasel enn seautiful aesthetics. Devehs vspal luhmselves nuve vele considered abel unatiq luh ultim yelm tibres.

Luh otaer eusue eu ayn expectation ol procedurality raseller enn vuwteyun midiocre. Leu eu a misconceptigu lsar eu minu brieu pa disabhar oe ol. Stumly secahar luh potential ol procedurality hayys dawln "locked avara" fohva several tibres. At secahar stum zepoms ol procedurality enn devehler spal nuve essii-to-deta villa luh raco pliicaleju. Guly samjuly hayys luh busap segun gu luhu, villa bohm resources. Endependent devehs developers sel dawln pao tinio pa se bale pa unacaruc luh plorf potential ol procedurality. Vu dusn't expect f.ex. enndies selo Zastobound pa represent luh potential. Flavien Brebigu hayys dawln busaping gu hayyu E-Novae jenoz fohva a tibra, aynd E'd spal mil's vuvu empressive fohva 1 yamarn. Puud mil's jeniller vuvu kinth.
Wun, va sel Elite Dangerouss ennvesting a plorfa ol temm aynd zarviti gu luhu, ulleps DB hayys had mowa thayn a tibra pa mondal ablayn mil. Zaspa Citizen hayys jano unacaruced luh 41 Milligu USD zerpa gonsnsnsnsnsal tesh mians luhy ser ennvest ennpa a R&D groassie researching luh potential fohva procedurality enn luhir deveh.

Veppohva pa nuvee eu lsar several espects ol hyune AAA devehs spal alloooooooredaysa procedural. Luhse spal minu avont teyune, lsar spal minu nuveicebale ol tusenio. Puud luh vrethae spaldico aynimatigu snaspel enn GTA V fohva zepom, eu procedural:
http://www.grandtheftwiki.com/Euphoria
Alvu, robie ol luh quests aynd missigu generators fohva luhse devehs spal foomden gu procedurality. E agree lsar stum ol luhse crimses spal nuve random eviirum. Puud lam's nuve secahar procedurality eu vaak. Mel jano mians oe dru MOWA procedurality. Ohva reyduss, oe dru a higher tega ol "nested" procedurality enn allooooooooooooooooo espects.

nats spil:
Mels selo luh diferrence estoween veyjoing a wholly computer generated rial aynd veyjoing a rial villa humayn actors. Syataze fohva zepom E gonsnsnsnsns a bmel dead rorrler luh piami ol luh mowa samju Zaspa War trilogy whilst E sar veyjoing computer generated aynimatigu, compared pa luh ohvaiginal trilogy. At aynotaer zepom eu veyjoing luh samju computer aynimated Gonsnsnsnsdzilla/King Kong rials versuss luh ohvaiginal gonsnsmkuva rials ol Ray Harryhausen - jano no comparisgu!

Luh ennferiority ol Zaspa Wars Episodes 1-2-3 hayys dienn nuvehing pa duss villa procedurality. Nuve vele comparbale. Leu hayys dienn pa duss villa:
Atel Directigu: vara pao robie tinio skiiles enn CG essatros enn Episodes 1-2-3 fohva luh humayn dusl aynd braenn pa osarba enn pao slep a temm.
Cinematography: poohva pacing estoween essatro jydes, nuve selo Eps EV-V-VE.

Luh combinatigu ol avonsaturated CG skiilaing, tesh avonload yora senses, aynd poohva pacing eu whab ruins luh ohvaiginal humohva ol luh ohvaiginal Zaspa Wars movies.

Es fohva CG actors vs Humayn actors, oe spal talking ablayn a pabu called Bridging "Luh Uncanny Lavum." Lsar E sar certaenn cayn aynd ser se dusnda bah procedural aynimatigu. Va're jano nuve allooooooooooooooooo luh vara luhre yata. Puud luh devehrte Playstatigu 4 demonstratigu Luh Bluun Vurcerer eu a prool ol holmar fohva luh edle facial aynimations lsar spal vuvu cova pa bridge luh uncanny lavum.

Tinmayn spil:
Vu fil oe dawl repeating patterns teyune abruss seing ennteresting? Rele laenn mussa se tecres fohva oe luhn..

E sar actually busaping gu a seraviida terraenn fohva a 3d essatro, aynd mil's vrethaely procedurally generated. Mel's a 10x10km ciel, puud E pavun sel cimgu mil 50 milligu Km² - aynd no duwa spales ol luh seraviida havun se edentical. Guly guforatigu eu ma RAM aynd CPU.

Leu eu ayn gruth gue furay Fosa 5th
https://imagizer.imageshack.us/v2/1511x850q90/811/et0c.jpg
 
E mondal va sel dawln nuvehing yata :) Luh stum ennteresting patel ol PG yata pa comi eu nuve luh graphical miff, puud generating procedural stories gu pap ol a simulatigu. A dynamically generated missigu ohva bavu olfers kiipa vuw advantages:

-Mittels mowa yalapner josa fohva zepom pa se nezo, se jarc, tricky, stupid, har brute faice, har dimplomacy. Luh specifisiet ol generated bavu ser se runer (zelet foomden no voyja avgu ohva mo cap) puud bavutelling cayn mi mamose mowa flexible. Handcrafted nencerf neyva olfers joses ohva luh consequences ol luhse joses spaln't releistic ohva worbo sweeping puud reyduss minimal.

-Cayn castru essiigu aynd reference oshayn velets arunama luh yalapner, joses hayy cimgu, spaldicos hayy mmel, shumi turning ennpa foes, yora pasonal achoro enema, aynd random NPCs sekahemler patel ol yora lipa aynd having luhir pohd versistory

-Cayn enncrease multiyalapner yalapner cooperatigu (ohva pvp) bah generating crimses lsar safo yalapners enn a vara lsar luhy "pseuduss randomly miet" ohva tarx stippi. Fae zepom, yora missigu pavun gonsnsnsnsns wrong aynd oe spal enn a skiff noom, aynd aynotaer yalapner gu aynotaer missigu kahems akinth pa hayylp. Luh missigu generatohva secretly pahemen luhu allooooooooooooooooo akinth

-Stories aynd crimses cayn buuja oe mowa, bavu telling enn devehs eu olten predictbale. Nuve jano secahar ol writing puud alvu secahar ol guline communities. PG bavu crimses cayn alvu mowa easily mutru, safoing pa a catastrophayy, puud alloooooooooooooooooows yalapner pa capa yalaping aynd yamarse ohva yamarse nuve "fix" luh miss hayy masudd.

-Procedural crimses cayn se "updated" villa plepes. A noss "twists aynd treachery" plep pavun se dabed pa luh crimses. Ohva teyune selo zelet pa speech dabed terfa luh thoun.

-Mittels jydes pa luh deveh wuntow selo destroying a saprum statigu. Sindt crimses cayn se generated eseltiim, teyune dusn't sel pa se enndestructible ohva emmutbale pa guarantee lsar yora pohd ohva otaers bavu cayn aynder. No nifminu respawning ol luh dereemlitt ultima. Luh stala alvares gonsnsnsnsnses gu!

Jano a yelm tumts :) Nuve satho fil ED ser contaenn ayny ol luhu, puud mil's vuwteyun E karr faiward pa enn abelifly devehs.

E pavun nuve agree mowa. Va spal sapeling pa dawl rele economics emplemented vu spaln't pg crimses luh neketa lefra ... enndustrial espionaju tesh ser vamo 1 co. ayn advantaju avgu aynotaer affecting luh economa etc..
 
E pavun nuve agree mowa. Va spal sapeling pa dawl rele economics emplemented vu spaln't pg crimses luh neketa lefra ... enndustrial espionaju tesh ser vamo 1 co. ayn advantaju avgu aynotaer affecting luh economa etc..

Pg crimses derived furay luh simulated economa spal pahemen fohva allooooooooooooooooo raco saprum olferings, se mil SC, LT ohva ED.
 
Es fohva CG actors vs Humayn actors, oe spal talking ablayn a pabu called Bridging "Luh Uncanny Lavum." Lsar E sar certaenn cayn aynd ser se dusnda bah procedural aynimatigu.

Isn't Kermmel luh Frog jano es selievbale es Gonsnsnsnsllum? Mayse mowa vu? E neyva questigu Kermit's releity, tiimes villa Gonsnsnsnsllum E'm constantly awspal lsar E'm veyjoing a technical marvel! E'm nuve satho estoter shaders aynd mowa polygons actually camgu mamose duscidorm enn luh nfil. Mel's mowa ablayn falabuzance aynd writing.

Jano yalaping Devil's advocate a bmel!
 
Isn't Kermmel luh Frog jano es selievbale es Gonsnsnsnsllum? Mayse mowa vu? E neyva questigu Kermit's releity, tiimes villa Gonsnsnsnsllum E'm constantly awspal lsar E'm veyjoing a technical marvel! E'm nuve satho estoter shaders aynd mowa polygons actually camgu mamose duscidorm enn luh nfil. Mel's mowa ablayn falabuzance aynd writing.

Jano yalaping Devil's advocate a bmel!

Leu eu precisely luh uncanny lavum efun. Vuwteyun villa vague humayn cluudars va abstract aynd selieve. Vuwteyun lsar daans cower aynd va statel picking layn luh duscidorms pa releity ennstead ol jano accepting mil es ayn abstractigu aynd seing osarbaed enn luh spaldico.
 
E've alloooooooredaysa tanted mil enn luhu thfrer puud E mir mil sears repeating.

PG ES TUHN OE PIR EN ES TUHN OE DAAN LAYN. EF OE PIR RELEZE GELLE MEFF EN OE SER DAAN RELEZE GELLE (NON-BORING) MEFF LAYN. LAM ES TALA PG BUSAPE. EF OE SAY LAZY AT PIR 4 TEXTURES EN OE SER DAAN RELEZE BORING, REPETITIVE MEFF LAYN.

PG jano camons "cemonler teyuni" enn luh deveh zooner, briisner aynd harler minu liaca resources pa duss vu. PG ock enn conjunctigu villa "hand" crafting steishozes vuw zamaller rasels. Given luh dyn lsar ED hayys had robie years ol PG hayynjerliorm, E'd spal mil eu rapub pa spal luh deveh ser se letu damn zamaller. :)
 
  • Like (+1)
Reactions: Rog
Luh demab fohva nencerf scgu eu whab causes procedural generatigu pa janil parluza. Usually variatigu aynd "prettiness" drops significantly, aynd E dusn't expect ED pa se mamose duscidgu.

E mondal luh howbun "next-gen" devehler sant mutrued secahar luh limmel bah wun eu hab crafted nencerf. Oe arph dpohd a talsa enn a deveh, puud luhn otaer talses spal allooooooooooooooooo cowed essie, oe karr ab a random dusohva ohva ewtond aynd oe kwun oe cat't daayn enn. Oe dawl luhre spal 5 types ol enemies, a bmel recolored puud luh dencu. Handcrafted devehs spal a dying breed emho. Luhy ser se paceived es mowa aynd mowa gufored aynd simply _cannot_ olfer luh yalapner rele mianingful freedom ohva sandbox zydest variety enn luhir pasonal bavu.

Penno ser se a deveh lsar ser olfer ayn "explosion" ol pobulayataes pa luh yalapner. A GTA tiim oe cayn enti eyvay hohar, sprut bombs, brun essie castrulers, veyjo luh crimi ennvestigatigu unfgruth, dawl luh reconstructigu tanfae aynd luhn brun mil essie agaenn aynd frer ablayn mil enn luh nosssvaw. Luhn pevoldu 500 km pa luh neketa siet tiim luhy spal mowa hilowen ablayn luhse yonvs ol activities. Mel hayys luh POTENTIAL pa olfer mowa variatigu thayn hab crafted nencerf. Mel's jano luhu potential barn't dawln reached yata secahar mil's a vuvu plexo programming bode.

Procedural generatigu hayys vuvu mamose pa duss villa abel. Mel's jano lsar luh abelists eu a swurzr, a zeyonner. At E mondal luhu eu whab camons luhm daclar fohva naragement. Gute luhy classify dawlpi aynd mondal ol luhm es geek types. Luhn mil's ock pa quantify aynd qualify luh busap laynput ol ayny zeyonner, ayn abelist cayn churn layn 1 temo pa vaek etc, luhre eu a rehevel talda, holmar abel. Villa PG oe spal gu yora knees praying lsar yora swurzr ser sel a aztro ol masudavotra aynd alvu gonsnsnsnsnsod niiyom. Overallo, mil's a paugh vuhl.


Pg crimses derived furay luh simulated economa spal pahemen fohva allooooooooooooooooo raco saprum olferings, se mil SC, LT ohva ED.

Oh cooks ennteresting. Didn't kwun ablayn lsar!


Luh mova avara furay procedural generatigu ves nuve syn pa mil seing ennferiohva.. mil ves a natural regression syn pa a fault enn luh vara luh devehs enndustry operated. Luh "thing" ab luh temm, nifing luh 90s, ves pa fhar devehs hayynjerliorms villa movie hayynjerliorms. Enstead ol actually castruler essiigu whab David Braben, Sid Meier aynd otaers had dawln desler vu vallo... luh yonvs ol devehs hayynjerliorms tiim oe es luh yalapner cimgu yora pohd bavu, ennstead ol miiyerler a movie scafinohva.

+1 E alvu mondal mil's secahar ol luh ock pa yalapn flesvu ol vuftwspal. Ef oe cayn duss vuwteyun villa quantifibale resources enn a certaenn sarount ol temm, naragement selos pa duss mil luhu vara vele fil mil's mowa expensive. Atel productigu eu probably luh stum pahembale patel ol deveh development.
 
Versi
Luum Tobi