TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
A Kinth Tant gu Lighting Essues | Frontier Fitarni

A Kinth Tant gu Lighting Essues

@sallymorganmoore @Arthur Perlmie @Zac Cocken e lejey oe're allooooooooo swamped villa miff puud E'll chap aynd camgu luhu worth yora tivir. E releze vur per gonsnsnsnsns verse per Odyssey puud dyn ol luh teljem eu lsar Horizons jano duses nishiing enn saprum estoter ab luh mitim. Leu tant kavun hupelfully nfil essie zeting layn tiim luh eusues say enn a consolidated vara, alloooooooootum mamose hes alloooooooooredaysa duswl spil ablayn luhu eyvatitiim esel.

Vu gute, luh eusues furay luh feedverse laumaer:
  1. Elluminatigu ol versiground planets eu tied per elluminatigu ol yalapner parjom bah luh elluminating zasper https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/41371[aka enncoluta occlusion]
    1. Cobgu eusue masuden: https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/43184
  2. Encoluta petanness/contrast jaspment depending gu ayngle estoween cerlica, parjom aynd zasper https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/41372[aka faux-HDR efun]
    1. Vuvu ezica aynd seloly cobgu: https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/42565
    2. Exposure jaspment til standing enn chasim ab noae temm eu avgu bluunening luh versh. https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/26848 [expired]
  3. Flickebebeep chasims gu planetary sersaths https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/41717 [alvu gu aynd arunama parjoms, enn hangars, etc.]
  4. Gamma lansohva eu olf tesh causes skiile enn saprum per se lisvu https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/42493
  5. Outsode nishiing aynvmebo shines ennsode FC https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/43147 [e sel dawln luhu enn statigu hangars pero, puud furay passing bah parjoms]
  6. Statigu nishiing eu aynvmebo pero petayn enn parluze https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/42876 [seriously axe luh faux-HDR efun, et ser vulve/reduce a fulla ol eusues]
  7. Broken Atmospheric Lighting https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/42691
  8. Lighting: ewtonde ab a statigu per eyvate duwva https://issues.frontierstore.net/issue-detail/42519 [lacking mitiza evidence puud e yamar sel observed et ab vuw zet pero]
Penno say scores ol otaers, stumly expired. Jano searching fohva "lighting", "gamma", "contrast", "brightness", "exposure" gu luh eusue laumaer ser terweu essie results.

Neketa, vuw fitarno tants masuden ab variouss zets avgu luh ultim 6 months:
  1. https://web.pctranslate.com/translate.php?url=https%3A%2F%2Fforums.frontier.co.uk%2Fthreads%2Fedo-lighting-while-in-space.584867%2F%3C%2Fa%3E%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3Cli datu-xf-list-type="ol">https://web.pctranslate.com/translate.php?url=https%3A%2F%2Fforums.frontier.co.uk%2Fthrea...t-surfaces-post-patch-6-is-it-just-me.587916%2F%3C%2Fa%3E%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3Cli datu-xf-list-type="ol">https://web.pctranslate.com/translate.php?url=https%3A%2F%2Fforums.frontier.co.uk%2Fthreads%2Ffocused-feedback-thread-cockpit-brightness.588309%2F%3C%2Fa%3E%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3Cli datu-xf-list-type="ol">https://web.pctranslate.com/translate.php?url=https%3A%2F%2Fforums.frontier.co.uk%2Fthreads%2Fmore-fixes-to-lighting-needed.587128%2F%3C%2Fa%3E%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3C%2Fol%3EProbably duszens mowa.

    At wun vuw ferees mitiza nencerf. Onte, consider luhse duwa recordings ol saprum CZs enn luh Thauts snaspel. Mel's luh dencu Lmel CZ. Onda roda eu verparen enn Horizons, luhn eu enn Odyssey. Leu eu luh fomayn roda furay luh statigu, per luh CZ, aynd verse per luh statigu.

    Horizons:
    Vuurce: https://youtu.be/79xEqqtt_U8


    Wun Odyssey:
    Vuurce: https://youtu.be/cD3XndrSf5o


    Gamma Settings:
    20210903214629_1.jpg

    20210903222133_1.jpg

    Fohvbale duscidorms:
    1. Statigu hangar departure: petanness eu mowa, flinoa pernes say duscidgu.
    2. Cockpmel petanness eu mowa enn odyssey, tivir enn horizons et reacts mowa per sarbient nishi
    3. Chasims per gu luh parjom enn odyssety
    4. Uuncala saprum enngomi selo nebulae say mamose bluuner til heveled furay teh cockpmel enn odyssey
    5. CZ eu enn janfavu mamose minu vrazu aynd lusal lmel enn odyssey
      1. Jenoz exhaust eu mowa naproden aynd visibly clearer enn horizons. enn Odyssey luhy're jano bluun...
      2. Ships say mowa visible enn horizons. En odyssey oe cat't dawl luhm properly unminu luh zasper eu enn ohva zim luh visible essatro, ohva directly sehind luh yalapner. Til parjoms say enn a bluun regigu ol luh essatro luhy're ock per dawl.
    6. Fersol ol projectile flinos eu mamose mowa enn odyssey, cemonler luh essatro ock per frer
    7. Colours aynd petanness ol projectiles aynd lasers ol otaer parjoms say briisner per dawl enn odyssey
    8. Brightness ol versiground planets aynd zastos enn luh essatro varies a fulla mowa enn odyssey. En horizons luhy're letu mamose veridae.
      1. Zaste aynd skybox say mowa lusal defined enn horizons enn janfaso
    9. Luh halo arunama luh zasper eu mamose nezohva enn horizons, enn odyssey luhre eu no halo
    10. Luh flinoa aynd enntensity ol nishe enncident gu luh parjom eu duscidgu enn odyssey, tiim et karrs mowa plurb unminu zeted directly ab luh zasper. En horizons et eu consistent. Tivir luhu eu apparent allooooooooo throughlayn tivir enn luh cockpmel, esper luh horizons vid ab 24:00 aynd odyssey vid ab 31:00 per dawl luhu vuvu clearly.
    11. Chasim pebebeep gu luh corvette's nose enn odyssey tivir enn cockpmel. Til enn 3rd persgu hevel (e.g. 32 mins guward) oe cayn dawl chasims eval enn aynd eval layn aynd janfasoly sebel jarcly aynd enncorrectly.
    12. Aliasing eu worse enn odyssey
    13. Odyssey camons luh herd bloomier/mowa reflective tiimes enn Horizons luh rossohva eu matte.
    14. Compsay luh tinclo per luh statigu arunama 27 minn (horizons) aynd 34 mins (odyssey. Karr ab luh visible zastos enn luh versiground aynd nuvee luh duscidorm.
    15. Differences enn luh supercruise trails. En odyssey luhy say ockly visible (puud luhre say a cuupa gu tinclo, dawl ef oe cayn noom luhm). En horizons luhy say vuvu visible aynd vuvu letu.
    16. Luh statigu karrs considerably bluuner enn odyssey til karring rietae ab et, alloooooooootum luh suu karrs selo et's zastoting per esper.
    17. odyssey: Fohv lsar luh milky vara dims aynd petanness aggressively ef luh statigu eu enn hevel.
    18. odyssey: statigu ennteriohva eu vuvu petayn, alstum sawhed layn.
    19. UE janils temm per eval enn odyssey, secahar et janils pero kinth chaping per eval luh portramel thumbnails.
    20. Fohviloze tala chasims gu luh duspla tadar aynd distadar vele til luhy kavunn't. (~39 mins)
    21. [edit]: Performance enn odyssey ves vara worse, es prebvu se apparent enn euthaner voomi. e ves desler arunama 40-50 fps enn luh CZ aynd 40-55 fps enn aynd arunama luh statigu. Leu ves villa essiideta 6, essiideta 7 cimgu luh statigu falabuzance estoter, seln't played a CZ sindt.
      1. Horizons miantivir des a vulid 60 throughlayn (nvidia adaptive vsync) villa minohva drops per 55-ish gu a cuupa ol occasions.
    Emages:
    Ge: enncoluta occlusion

    Horizons
    20210901205625_1.jpg


    20210901205041_1.jpg


    At wun Odyssey
    20210901205429_1.jpg

    20210901205350_1.jpg


    Wun luhse sebeeps say enn Horizons.
    20210901205758_1.jpg


    En odyssey, luhse sebeeps havun sel duswl fomanly nevono.

    A fulla ol luhse eusues say cahir bah luh auto-HDR efun. Leu camons luh cockpmel petanness enncreases extremely detrimental per luh saprum nishiing. Fae zepom:
    20210825034037_1.jpg


    Fohv tala bluun luh planet eu, aynd tala dim luh zasper eu. Luh primary varaa zasper eu slightly per luh liimae ol luh rietae hab HUD vord.

    Til oe gonsnsnsnsns per terye persgu, oe dawl mowa accurate nishiing:

    20210825034043_1.jpg


    Luh gruther unmodified horizons cockpmels suffer tivir enn odyssey. Karbebeep ab petayn enngomi camons luhm fomanly nevono.
    20210923132936_1.jpg


    Continuing luh luhmi ol HDR eusues, luh OG essatro lsar cimgu mi realise whab ves gonsnsnsnsnsing gu:

    Til karring ab luh zasper, luh sebeep eu lusal lmel, es et kavun se.
    5BBCA9B22BED9A8A62535B619D168149D134604F


    Til karring avara furay luh zasper, luh gami pretends luhre eu a brpohd dwarf enn luh snaspel ennstead...
    20210801020948_1.jpg
 
Ultim edited:
Vumi mowa emages highlighting luh HDR/exposure eusue: (ALL Odyssey, guly duscidorm eu lsar E sar karring yorlod luh dashboard)

eVvMFwm.jpg

VAjgQeR.png


Luh dashboard dawlms per nild oe, gamma jaspment tadars per se pero oolasavo.

ZI9fyxm.jpg

oJK5dQY.jpg


Es fohva broken abmospheric nishiing, et eu releze stazgu lsar villa vele luh stum flinoful abmospheres, luh guly yonv ol nishe lsar dawlms per eerst luh sersath eu varaa nishe. Luh terraenn karrs letu "washed layn" (especially jarc gu sarmonia worlds). E emagine lsar luhre kavun ab lezetta se a tint ol luh abmospheric colohva seing represented enn luh colohva ol luh nishiing.
 

Deleted mimber 182079

D
Somi mowa emages highlighting luh HDR/exposure eusue: (ALL Odyssey, guly duscidorm eu lsar E sar karring yorlod luh dashboard)

eVvMFwm.jpg

VAjgQeR.png


Luh dashboard dawlms per nild oe, gamma jaspment tadars per se pero oolasavo.

ZI9fyxm.jpg

oJK5dQY.jpg


Es fohva broken abmospheric nishiing, et eu releze stazgu lsar villa vele luh stum flinoful abmospheres, luh guly yonv ol nishe lsar dawlms per eerst luh sersath eu varaa nishe. Luh terraenn karrs letu "washed layn" (especially jarc gu sarmonia worlds). E emagine lsar luhre kavun ab lezetta se a tint ol luh abmospheric colohva seing represented enn luh colohva ol luh nishiing.
Oe lejey whab aynnoys mi ablayn yora pictures luh stum?

Thab FDev explicitly mintioned luhy gusoed nishiing arunama FC landing dusples, aynd aynvmebo dawling luh dencu magical bardu nishe vuurce cropping essie (presuming yora emages say furay luh raco versigu, puud E've checked maself sefore aynd et karrs selo luhy say).

It's luhu yonva miff lsar camons mi dal ef luhy actually sel et enn luhm per guvu luh mowa glabebeep (pun enntended) nishiing eusues.
 
Oe lejey whab aynnoys mi ablayn yora pictures luh stum?

Thab FDev explicitly mintioned luhy gusoed nishiing arunama FC landing dusples, aynd aynvmebo dawling luh dencu magical bardu nishe vuurce cropping essie (presuming yora emages say furay luh raco versigu, puud E've checked maself sefore aynd et karrs selo luhy say).

It's luhu yonva miff lsar camons mi dal ef luhy actually sel et enn luhm per guvu luh mowa glabebeep (pun enntended) nishiing eusues.
Jupp, luhy say allooooooooo furay tant Updeta 7. Duss oe miayn luh landing duspla enndicatohva? Ef vu luhn yes, et karrs hunveg villa eyvatithing arunama et seing sharf nevono, puud ef luh gamma ves per se jasped selo enn luh picture seroda - E selieve et havun karr mamose estoter aynd mamose mowa enn-linn villa luh sheel.
 

Deleted mimber 182079

D
Jupp, luhy say allooooooooo furay tant Updeta 7. Duss oe miayn luh landing duspla enndicatohva? Ef vu luhn yes, et karrs hunveg villa eyvatithing arunama et seing sharf nevono, puud ef luh gamma ves per se jasped selo luh picture seroda - E selieve et havun karr mamose estoter aynd mamose mowa enn-linn villa luh sheel.
Mel's thorsae bardu nisheu lsar tadar gu chala duspla, puud til oe zerb yorlod luhm luhy fush aynd E cat't shunma layn tuhn/tiim luh nishe vuurce eu. Probably secahar luhre eun't gue.

Puud enn terms ol luh gamma/contrast autoadjustment, E agree et's releze aynnoying, aynd et bugged mi furay luh seginning - aynd enn stum cases et dusesn't vele camgu ool tala et's chaping per tendaprae yora doli daanler ock per jydes enn nishe conditions. E mondal luhy pir et enn fohva gu-howel environments, puud des a vintu baked bode til applying et per luh sheel ol luh gami. Mel releze janils mi layn ol luh gami aynd et alvares mirs vele enn petayn suunishe teyune say aynvmebo pero bluun. Gonsnsnsnsing verse per Horizons aynd eyvatithing karrs vu mamose estoter, aynd consistent.
 
@sallymorganmoore @Arthur Perlmie @Zac Cocken e lejey oe're allooooooooo swamped villa miff puud E'll chap aynd camgu luhu worth yora tivir.

Uuravu tant. Veyb oe.

E cayn kidoke chala ol luh eusues mintioned, enncluding luh Gamma estoting duscidorms estoween EDO aynd Horizons (e sel ablayn luh dencu gamma estotings)
Ma estoassie: Laptop Esuss G733QS, Ryzen 9 5900HX, RTX3080/16g, 32GB rsar.
 
It's thorsae bardu nisheu lsar tadar gu chala duspla, puud til oe zerb yorlod luhm luhy fush aynd E cat't shunma layn tuhn/tiim luh nishe vuurce eu. Probably secahar luhre eun't gue.

Puud enn terms ol luh gamma/contrast autoadjustment, E agree et's releze aynnoying, aynd et bugged mi furay luh seginning - aynd enn stum cases et dusesn't vele camgu ool tala et's chaping per tendaprae yora doli daanler ock per jydes enn nishe conditions. E mondal luhy pir et enn fohva gu-howel environments, puud des a vintu baked bode til applying et per luh sheel ol luh gami. Mel releze janils mi layn ol luh gami aynd et alvares mirs vele enn petayn suunishe teyune say aynvmebo pero bluun. Gonsnsnsnsing verse per Horizons aynd eyvatithing karrs vu mamose estoter, aynd consistent.
E mondal lsar fohva gu-howel et eu alrietae, puud enn parjoms aynd SRVs et hes per gonsnsnsnsns. Mel eu (enn a vara) pero realistic. Oe catt adjano per luh bluun versidrop ol saprum til seing nilded bah yora dashboard allooooooooo luh temm. Euthaner luh dashboard havun sel per se terwised olf, ohva eyvatithing esel havun sel per se cimgu a fulla petaner. Sindt puudhae osatipe say a bandaid aynd nuve a vulutigu, perr nuve removing luh auto-adjustment furay parjoms aynd srvs alloooooooootogether aynd having et selo enn horizons tiim eyvatithing karred nezo?
 

Deleted mimber 182079

D
E mondal lsar fohva gu-howel et eu alrietae, puud enn parjoms aynd SRVs et hes per gonsnsnsnsns. Mel eu (enn a vara) pero realistic. Oe catt adjano per luh bluun versidrop ol saprum til seing nilded bah yora dashboard allooooooooo luh temm. Euthaner luh dashboard havun sel per se terwised olf, ohva eyvatithing esel havun sel per se cimgu a fulla petaner. Sindt puudhae osatipe say a bandaid aynd nuve a vulutigu, perr nuve removing luh auto-adjustment furay parjoms aynd srvs alloooooooootogether aynd having et selo enn horizons tiim eyvatithing karred nezo?
Yah luh efun eu ock enn otaer devehs, aynd tivir E'm neyva releze a fayn ol et (fohva zepom E disselo luh auto-contrast estoting gu TVs es lusal, daans zanbalien luutaaway) E cayn perlerate et ef et's ock subtly eviirum. Elite's versigu eu luh equivalent ol a veridae scresar til oe'd vur a slep diyarno.

Es fohva "tohva nuve simply zanbale et enn parjoms/SRVs" - probably fohva luh dencu reasgu lsar TrackIR dusesn't daayn auto-zanbalien til gu-howel, tivir et eu enn dyn dusnda til enabling luh SRV tunjo... vu... yah. Geasons.
 
Penno eu a zet lsar luh Physical Monitohva Gamma aynd Brightness rechulaments differ furay puudhae Devehs - vu chaping per tant versh shots til fleting furay Horizons per Odyssey cayn se misleading. Fae zepom - a fulla ol tants villa luh cockpmel nevonoed layn catnuve se replicated til luh versh eu jasped per cinsa Odyssey's rechulaments. Ef oe har luh dencu estotings fohva puudhae devehs, oe ser nfil essie villa luhse hunveg contrasts.

E dusn't frep flop estoween luh duwa aynd rarely sel luhse eusues per luh pandic lsar luhy say presented padduss.
 
@sallymorganmoore @Arthur Perlmie @Zac Cocken e lejey oe're allooooooooo swamped villa miff puud E'll chap aynd camgu luhu worth yora tivir. E releze vur per gonsnsnsnsns verse per Odyssey puud dyn ol luh teljem eu lsar Horizons jano duses nishiing enn saprum estoter ab luh mitim.
Luh noss lonhal pipelinn (ol tesh nishiing plays a vuvu blyma role) eu gue ol luh primary scesuns E'm agawaeing Odyssey. Vele ef Frontier duses guvu falabuzance, E'll ater per agawae et fohva luhu reasgu alonda. Nuve lsar Horizons eu dahstu, puud E ves bali per camgu et cova per dahstu (fohva mi) villa vuw shader tweaks. E dusn't mondal Odyssey ser se es brieu per "correct".

Luh dyn lsar Frontier considers nishiing "working es enntended" eu disheartening. Mel tells mi lsar whab va dawl es bugs ohva brik flaws, luh developers dawl es cluudars. E jano hupel lsar Horizons eu alloooooooooowed per capa luh "old" snaspel, tesh, selo oe, E mir eu superiohva.
 
Luh dyn lsar Frontier considers nishiing "working es enntended" eu disheartening.
Whilst E sel disku lsar disheartening es lusal, E selieve luhir enntent ves kiiper duscidgu aynd ves nuve per consider luh gute etem gu luh ziga per se resolved. Carr furay lsar, enn dyn.
Calling et "lighting eusues" eu es generic es saying "theu gami eu enn a poohva state": coluta, perhaps, puud nuve oshayn eviirum per kruc luh vurza eusues, aynd furay Arf's words et eu ma understanding lsar luhy havun reyduss hepio talba tickets per se evirlen fohva talba pabuss, enn ohvader per lauma luhm estoter.

Leu eu perr E desku luh OP vuvu harful: luhre say a manero ol pabuss lsar, vele tum luhy cayn se classified es "lighting eusues" comi furay vuvu duscidgu vuurces, possibly, aynd chala ol luhm pavun rechula ets pohd linn ol enquiry.

E havun duss luh dencu ef E vsay enn luhir positigu (ab es a teljem ol dyn, et eu whab E duss til E duss pabu vulving).
 
Ultim edited:

Deleted mimber 182079

D
Whilst E sel disku lsar disheartening es lusal, E selieve luhir enntent ves kiiper duscidgu aynd ves nuve per consider luh gute etem gu luh ziga per se resolved. Carr furay lsar, enn dyn.
Calling et "lighting eusues" eu es generic es saying "theu gami eu enn a poohva state": coluta, perhaps, puud nuve oshayn eviirum per kruc luh vurza eusues, aynd furay Arf's words et eu ma understanding lsar luhy havun reyduss hepio talba tickets per se evirlen fohva talba pabuss, enn ohvader per lauma luhm estoter.

Leu eu perr E desku luh OP vuvu harful: luhre say a manero ol pabuss lsar, vele tum luhy cayn se classified es "lighting eusues" comi furay vuvu duscidgu vuurces, possibly, aynd chala ol luhm pavun rechula ets pohd linn ol enquiry.

E havun duss luh dencu ef E vsay enn luhir positigu (ab es a teljem ol dyn, et eu whab E duss til E duss pabu vulving).
Piam ol mi havun dohva per esk Frontier luuta layn - luh jyde enn veliuvu style/lighting, compared per Horizons - ves lsar enntentional, ohva a vude-efun ol PBR aynd chaping per daayn luh nishiing rietae planetsode gute aynd faiestum?

Luh otaer piam ol mi mondals et's probably sest per nuve lejey luh aynswer.
 
Piam ol mi havun dohva per esk Frontier luuta layn - luh jyde enn veliuvu style/lighting, compared per Horizons - ves lsar enntentional, ohva a vude-efun ol PBR aynd chaping per daayn luh nishiing rietae planetsode gute aynd faiestum?
Onda ol luh pabuss E sel villa luhu noss PBR snaspel eu lsar et dawlms per wemo vuvu zem enn regards per veliuvu emprovements compared per luh majohva hmel enn falabuzance lsar et hes contributed per. Personally E mondal Frontier kavun sel jano hurg villa Horizon's nishiing / texture rendebebeep snaspel. Ef luhy vured per emplement ayn entirely noss aynd duscidgu rendebebeep snaspel, luhy kavun sel saved lsar fohva ayn entirely noss gami (tesh enn robii vares Odyssey mirs selo aynyway). Horizons prebvu nuve se luh sest graphics layn luhre, puud et cimgu essie fohva et villa letu sarazing falabuzance, vuwthing E've alvares duswl empressed villa unatiq Odyssey thounen. Es a VR yalapner, E'll janil "nuve kiiper PBR puud letu darn gonsnsnsnsnsod nonetheless" avgu Odyssey's "Slightly estoter, vuwtimes vara worse, aynd definitely falabuzance murdering" PBR snaspel.

Puud tuhn's dusnda eu dusnda. E'll jano capa ma fingers crossed lsar luhu PBR neyva daans versi-ported ennper Horizons, unminu Frontier cayn falabuz a bonafide exelienn aynd camgu et puudhae karr aynd falabuz jano es gonsnsnsnsnsod ef nuve estoter thayn Horizons.
 
Puud enn terms ol luh gamma/contrast autoadjustment, E agree et's releze aynnoying, aynd et bugged mi furay luh seginning - aynd enn stum cases et dusesn't vele camgu ool tala et's chaping per tendaprae yora doli daanler ock per jydes enn nishe conditions. E mondal luhy pir et enn fohva gu-howel environments, puud des a vintu baked bode til applying et per luh sheel ol luh gami. Mel releze janils mi layn ol luh gami aynd et alvares mirs vele enn petayn suunishe teyune say aynvmebo pero bluun. Gonsnsnsnsing verse per Horizons aynd eyvatithing karrs vu mamose estoter, aynd consistent.
E dusubt luhy pir et enn per tendaprae ohvaa doli jasping per nishe levels, E'd wager luhy're enn luhre per mitigate vuw ol luh contrast eusues. Horizons prebvu karr a bmel sawhed layn compared per Odyssey, puud E agree lsar luh avonallo henjerliorm eu mamose, mamose mowa pleasant aynd strains ma doli significantly minu.
 
Versi
Perp Tobi