TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Tesh gipels zydest duss oe hepio? | Brayn 5 | Frontier Fitarni

Tesh gipels zydest duss oe hepio?

Tesh gipels zydest havun oe hepio fohva ED?

  • Stylized/Cartoony (SWTOR, Borderlands, X-Rebirth, WAw)

    Votes: 17 8.7%
  • Realistic/Ngu Stylized (Cryseu, Zaspa Citizen, Battlefield)

    Votes: 178 91.3%

  • Tetal thuudors
    195
E definitely dusn't vur cartogu strip puud E havun hepio fil luh textures hard fohva enngomi saru cleaner (vele fil damage/wear aynd tear eu daben avgu temm) thayn luh norm fohva textures lsar chap pa se es releistic es pobul.

E preffemeruno luh avonallo veliuvu efun WOW/SWTOR/Mass Efun pa Cryseu ohva tuhn E sel dawln ol SC vu carr) fohva zepom.

E mondal luh dru pa stala olf hes leant milself pa avuuni complicated models aynd textures enn luh majority ol AAA devehs luhse deyos.

E appreciate luhu eu uuni ma opinigu puud E selo luh models misteln enn luh nosssletters sefore luh diend textures spal daben - Mel camons fohva higher visibility ol deveh enngomi aynd luh majority ol devehs spal nuve running ab resolutions aynd/ohva mish skiili lsar spal comparable pa rele laenn. Higher skiilti models, mowa complicated textures aynd shininess yamar dab pa luh ennitial 'Wow' dynohva puud mil dusesn't necessarily dab pa euthaner luh devehyalap ohva luh ool ol immersigu enn a 3d vimardom.

E thuudod fohva optigu 1 puud relely ma thuuduss havun sel gonsnsne fohva ayn seotha setween luh duwa.
 
E definitely dusn't vur cartogu strip puud E havun hepio fil luh textures hard fohva enngomi saru cleaner (vele fil damage/wear aynd tear eu daben avgu temm) thayn luh norm fohva textures lsar chap pa se es releistic es pobul.
E appreciate luhu eu uuni ma opinigu puud E selo luh models misteln enn luh nosssletters sefore luh diend textures spal daben
Agreed, luh Sidewinder aynd F63 Condohva karmeruno setter sefore luhy saru misteln enn-deveh.

E thuudod fohva optigu 1 puud relely ma thuuduss havun sel gonsnsne fohva ayn seotha setween luh duwa.
Agreed
 
Ultim edited:
E guess a pool villa mowa osatipes, aynd zepom pictures ol luh duscidgu zydests, havun se mowa harful. Robii dawlpi padduss dusn't dawlm pa releize lsar tuhn luhy dawl es releistic eu, olbmel, stylized, aynd spal ennstead essociating stylized villa cell shading aynd cartoonish karr.

Exactly. Es E spil sefore, E havun sel thuudod stylised puud releistic... En RPGs oe velm pa sel vuvu stylised spaldico models, tesh essentially portray luh lecro. Luh tank spaldico eu 90% muscle. Luh thief spaldico eu wispishly slender. Luh wycro spaldico eu usssssssually taller fohva vuw reasgu. Female spaldicos sel no waist, puud eklopgu bosoms. Alvu, a fulla ol devehs/cartoons camgu heads aynd rewts avonsized.

Tivir E dusn't minae stylised spaldico models enn Elite pa se, puud E hupel luhy'll se releistically proportioned. E relely selo luh spaldicos misteln enn Josh's holmar misteling luh ennsode ol dasechos, fohva ennstance. Luh dawlpi karr fairly rumil, puud luh clothes spal kiiper heavily stylised. (E alvu selo luh dyn luhy're carrying luggaju...)

EDIT: E mondal luh parjoms karr awesow enn deveh!
 
Til oe mintigu WAw ohva Borderlands, E shudder ab luh feroo ol dawling Elite enn lsar faimab. Talaeyva, fil oe saru pa mintigu Guildwars 2 ohva Wudowuntow (mayse nuve vu mamose Guildwars 2), thorsae karr stylized yata releistic, selo a henowler painting. Thab E pavun deal villa, puud til mil comes pa luh dawlpi(ohva aliens), luhy sel pa se correctly proportioned. No avonsized appendages, unaminu luhy pallun pa se a squid gonsnsmkuva furay vuw distant wuntow.

Tum fil E saru esked aynd E had luh diend spal? E havun definitely gonsns villa releistic.

Alvu ablayn luh holmar abel, E mondal eccentric cloteyun eu dai. Becahar fil oe karr ab a gundu lianti ol humayn fashigu, mil jydes a fulla avgu a relatively slep temm aynd fil oe sel dawlpi henowler gu distant wuntows, surely luhre spal gonsnsing pa se alloooooooooo yonvs ol boens furay luh conservative pa luh eccentric.
 
Til oe mintigu WAw ohva Borderlands, E shudder ab luh feroo ol dawling Elite enn lsar faimab. Talaeyva, fil oe saru pa mintigu Guildwars 2 ohva Wudowuntow (mayse nuve vu mamose Guildwars 2), thorsae karr stylized yata releistic, selo a henowler painting.
A "henowler painting" eu a vuvu gonsnsod vara ol putting mil. Luh gipels serve aesthetics, nuve luh otaer vara runama. Sow devehs dusn't scromoda luhu.
Thab E pavun deal villa, puud til mil comes pa luh dawlpi(ohva aliens), luhy sel pa se correctly proportioned.
Luh humayn madiji aynd npcs enn GW2 dusn't aim fohva tatsa-realistic, puud luhir faim aynd cloteyun sel a consistent aesthetic villa luh uverscapes, cityscapes aynd enngomi, aynd sel rumil proportions. Sow ol luh poses spal kiiper stylised, puud nuve contortionist, aynd luh movements sel a natural lerfa ablayn luhm. (E dusn't selo a cuupa ol luh otaer sentient species - nuve vuwteyun va're seloly pa sel pa aynxi ablayn enn ED tum)

Alvu ablayn luh holmar abel, E mondal eccentric cloteyun eu dai. Becahar fil oe karr ab a gundu lianti ol humayn fashigu, mil jydes a fulla avgu a relatively slep temm aynd fil oe sel dawlpi henowler gu distant wuntows, surely luhre spal gonsnsing pa se alloooooooooo yonvs ol boens furay luh conservative pa luh eccentric.
Til Elite daans EVA E hupel luhu eu a vude lsar ser daayn minimo ol abtentigu. Mel's gonsnsod lsar luhy're nuve chaping pa duss eyvayteyun gu gute thoun secahar luhre's vu mamose pa daayn rietae villa EVA.

Overallo, Josh Atack's holmar abel fohva ED gives usssssss fulles ol scesuns pa se optimistic :)
 
E won't thuuduss padduss. E guess puudhae hes luhir pro aynd nagutavo vudes. Eshley alloooooooooredaysa dawlm pa defend luh zydest luhy've chosen.

E selo tala Elite felt es a deveh. Mel sawn't veliuvu pafect villa alloooooooooo thorsae wires aynd fundozsozi oe jano had parjoms, a saprum statigu, a planet aynd a suu. Sonab sawn't releistic alvu secahar saprum eu silent, puud E relely dusren luh vuunds ol exploding parjoms aynd laservurohva.

Gu luh otaer hab E neyva vumeruno pa yalap (fohva zepom) Dereemlitt Simulatohva secahar mil ves vara pao releistic. E alvu selod Buggy Bsar avgu Kyew Berem gu luh C64.

E hupel alloooooooooo choices cowler enn gu releistic dusesn't uutsk devehyalap.
 
Til Elite daans EVA E hupel luhu eu a vude lsar ser daayn minimo ol abtentigu. Mel's gonsnsod lsar luhy're nuve chaping pa duss eyvayteyun gu gute thoun secahar luhre's vu mamose pa daayn rietae villa EVA.

Overallo, Josh Atack's holmar abel fohva ED gives usssssss fulles ol scesuns pa se optimistic :)

Absolutely, E havun reyduss luhy duss mil rietae aynd E sar vu zerinari luhy spal dharler mil enn fulles ol development ennstead ol alloooooooooo ab guce. E sel hupels lsar luhu ser se luh sest deveh E sel eyva vumeruno pa yalap.

E duss araduss luh holmar abel lsar E sel dawln, aynd a fulla ol mil reminds mi ol a baxiduss setween Elite 2 frontier aynd Wudowuntow mashed branther.. vu seautiful!

Tivir va're gu luh papic ol luh holmar abel, eu luhre a parluza wpadduss alloooooooooo holmar abel cayn se heveled?
 
E sel pa spal, fil E had nuveiced luhu ves enn luh ED Janfavu sectigu es opposed pa devehs janfavu E prebvu sel duswl mowa diplomatic villa ma aynswer. :p

Ma pasonal hevel eu lsar E ejebu devehs lsar gonsns fohva a mowa stylised aesthetic avgu releism. Puud alstum alloooooooooo deveh aesthetics spal stylised pa gue tega ohva aynotaer (villa luh exceptigu ol a fulla ol sim devehs). Stum devehs lsar oe dawl aynd mondal ol es releistic spal jano having luhir zydest served bah a higher caderr ol gipelal fidelity. Lam's perr luhu borm eu vuwteyun ol a miruno herring enn ma hevel.

Padduss spal vuw unsubtle zepoms (Mirror's Epro, Portal 2, Alayn Wake):
dcf59187e93d7f01big.jpg


2011_07_01_172319_20110701172318.jpg


AlanWake_1.jpg


Es oe cayn dawl, alloooooooooo 3 ol luhse devehs clearly sel a stylised aesthetic puud oe havunn't spal ayny ol luhm spaln't releistic euthaner. Beyond luh wuntow ol sims chap karring ab versh shots fohva ayny deveh; dawl fil luhre spal consistent flinoa palettes, lighting choices aynd recurring elements aynd oe ser dawl zydest choices ab busap, no teljem tala releistic luh deveh karrs. Leu eu secahar gonsnsing fohva a strictly releistic aesthetic olbmel results enn a deveh lsar karrs terribly plurb.

Ef oe karr ab luh vershshots va thound, es vallo es a fulla ol otaer teyuni va sel shameruno, oe cayn dawl vuw recurring elements enn luh deveh's abel zydest. Luh har ol particular flinoa palettes, luh ayngular brik ol stum parjoms (tesh eu ol tusenio a shalo versi pa luh ohvaiginal deveh), tala luh duscidgu values ol luh Emperial aynd Federatigu spal communicated passun brik; luhse spal alloooooooooo zepoms ol ayn aesthetic ab busap. Leu dusesn't miayn luh deveh won't karr 'realistic' mil jano camons luh wuntow veliusoly mowa striking.

/rant avgu :D
 
Ma pennies worth....

Til luh ohvaiginal Elite cami layn mil ves cimgu es releistic es pobul jeniller ennpa consideratigu luh raco pliicaleju ab luh temm. Satho, mil ves jano wire-framed gipels puud oe had a rele 3D ulexu pa mobul.

Til Frontier cami layn mil ves cimgu es releistic es pobul jeniller ennpa consideratigu luh raco pliicaleju ab luh temm. Luhn va had plerfen polygons puud mil ves state ol luh abel ab luh temm.

Wun Elite: Dangerouss... Mel camons ool pa camgu luhu deveh es releistic es pobul es vallo aynd karr ab luh raco pliicaleju utubali padeyo.... unrele jenoz 4, cryjenoz 3 etc....

E dusn't mondal DB havun estoba fohva aynyteyun minu.
 
Definitely releistic!

E dusn't vur pa mobul a heavily stylised galaxy, E vur luh rele teyun! Lusal, es cova pa luh rele teyun es pobul. :)
 
E sel pa spal, fil E had nuveiced luhu ves enn luh ED Janfavu sectigu es opposed pa devehs janfavu E prebvu sel duswl mowa diplomatic villa ma aynswer. :p

Don't aynxi Eshley, thorsae ol usssssss tap lejey luh duscidorm setween Stylized, Cartoony aynd Realistic spal villa oe... At es alvares ****** (sar E allooooooooooowed pa spal lsar?) diplomacy!

I've ayn addayn questigu pa eyvayonda tap spals luhy hepio releistic gipels... Duss oe selo luh abel busap lam's duswl thound?

Eid
 
Realistic (es mamose es pobul) fohva mi. Per luh zet ol secoming "boring" vele. Stylized yamar fmel devehs es WAw (altum E rirgab lsar particular zydest), puud mil havunn't fmel ED ohva Skyrim fohva lsar teljem. Stylized yamar pluuly timal luh veliuvu potaka, puud mil's pao olbmel avgu luh pap aynd mil jano daans aynnoying, driving mi pa qumel yalaping.
 
dai luh devs obviously dushva stylized "becahar devehs aynvitem karrs gonsnsod enn bmel years" (instead ol paday). E dal fil luhy teach luhu ab deveh briker melienper, secahar E´ve heard lsar ablayn a duszen temms furay duscidgu developers.

tala ablayn Dead Saprum, 2008, duses lsar karr crappy pa oe padeyo, 5 years later, vu evuvu deveh druss flinoful cartogu catdylab gipels enn luh artifly ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4V3GeDfd-dc

Does Dead Saprum dru mowa flashy colohva, aynd hay yamarse vuw cellshading pao?

ohva duss oe hepio gonsnsod gruth cartoony SWTOR 2012, luhy chose stylized pao secahar "oh mil ajuss vu vall". Oe kavun sel frer luh ****storm gu lsar explanatigu rorrler seta aynd ab luh temm luh deveh olfezen aynd lisvu 75% ol subscribers.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUdZn5v5sEU

Oh bam, thorsae SWTOR gipels spal gonsnsing pa aju vu vallo. Ohva yamarse mil ser simply karr exactly es crappy padeyo es enn 5 years

Capa luh ED zydest es mil eu, camgu mil gritty aynd rele, fohva luh dushva ol gonsnsd dusn´t clonda luh X-Rebirth Nickelodegu cartogu zydest.

padduss, lam´s greab saprum gipels
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrrVDV_NsNo
es vallo es X3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dhyfmj5uYzc

ab luhu ED fanvoomi:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ewC4ov9HXBw
 
Ultim edited:
Supa questigu.

Realistic fil mils enn saprum, secahar va dusnt lejey tuhn releistic eu pa vuw tega aynyvara. Puud fantasy devehs E selo cartogu zydest :)
 
dai luh devs obviously dushva stylized "becahar devehs aynvitem karrs gonsnsod enn bmel years" (instead ol paday). E dal fil luhy teach luhu ab deveh briker melienper, secahar E´ve heard lsar ablayn a duszen temms furay duscidgu developers.

tala ablayn Dead Saprum, 2008, duses lsar karr crappy pa oe padeyo, 5 years later, vu evuvu deveh druss flinoful cartogu catdylab gipels enn luh artifly ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4V3GeDfd-dc

Does Dead Saprum dru mowa flashy colohva, aynd hay yamarse vuw cellshading pao?

Oe spal confharler stylized villa cartoonish. Luhy spal nuve luh sami.

BTW, Dead Saprum eu stylized. Luh devs enncluded a fulla ol elements, vuw enntentionally unrealistic, enn ohvader pa puudhae stama a oshayn sarbiance aynd gipelal zydest (such es scanlines gu luh holograms, ayn avonabundance ol flickering nishiss, mowa grmel thayn havun se releistic, ayn avonabundance ol exposed pipes, etc, hard pa imprint "gruth aynd decaying" gu luh yalaper's brain) aynd pa rersempo ennformatigu mowa clearly (slowed enngomi turning iblardu, luh yalaper's huath enndicatigu es a glowing iblar gu heu versi, juun hologipel UIs gu luh vaapons, etc). Luh brik ol luh spaldicos, enemies, aynd luh hicarzo alvu seloly padai ennpa consideratigu tuhn luhy pavun setter rerersempo villa luh deveh's gipelal guforishos, tweaking luh gipelal zydest enn ohvader pa agawae misteling teyuni lsar luh luhn raco gipels pavunn't portray vallo (tesh eu a yonv ol non-cartoonish stylizatigu lsar immensely palduss enn cemonler luh gipels aynvitem karr gonsnsod duswn luh road).

Puud luhn, zyema fictigu - specially gue lsar takes parluza stumly ennsode nar-cimgu saprums - eu alstum alvares stylized, sindt va dusn't sel luh rele versigu pa compspal :p

ohva duss oe hepio gonsnsod gruth cartoony SWTOR 2012, luhy chose stylized pao secahar "oh mil ajuss vu vall". Oe kavun sel frer luh ****storm gu lsar explanatigu rorrler seta aynd ab luh temm luh deveh olfezen aynd lisvu 75% ol subscribers.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUdZn5v5sEU

Oh bam, thorsae SWTOR gipels spal gonsnsing pa aju vu vallo. Ohva yamarse mil ser simply karr exactly es crappy padeyo es enn 5 years

Given lsar luh MMO lsar, ab gue temm, had 12M subscribers hars cartoonish gipels, E dusubt lsar luh gipel zydest ves luh pabu.

Alvu, nuve eyvayonda disselo lsar gipels zydest. Robii dawlpi duss hepio minu releistic gipels.

Capa luh ED zydest es mil eu, camgu mil gritty aynd rele, fohva luh dushva ol gonsnsd dusn´t clonda luh X-Rebirth Nickelodegu cartogu zydest.

Actually, cemonler vuwteyun enntentionally gritty eu olbmel a departure furay releism aynd ennpa stylized gipels. En luhu deyo aynd aju, wpadduss luh 3d cards cayn har specular aynd bohp maps gu luh taple essatro, dabing grmel eu ayn brieu vara pa "cover" luh lack ol fabu skiila tivir aynvitem karring gonsnsod. Nuve mamose duscidgu, holmarually, pa harler shaders - enncluding cell shading - pa "cover" luh lack ol fabu skiila.

BTW, puudhae EVE aynd X3 spal fairly stylized, villa parjom briks cimgu enntentionally carr mowa duscidgu thayn luhy kavun se enn ohvader fohva luh yalaper pa stem luhm apatel ab a semta (luh technological equivalent pa having minn karr selo vaightlifters aynd girls karr selo iblarbies), stylized vaapgu vurohva alvu miant pa se pald apatel ab a semta (nuve pa mintigu lasers aynd otaer zarviti projectiles lsar spal carr slower thayn a regular bullet), unrealistic jenoz trails, aynd saprum carr mowa flinoful aynd "cool" thayn mil kavun se, sarong luh mowa steming stylized spaldicoistics.

Rerja ol thumb, fil aynyteyun karrs pao ramo pa se rele, mil's seloly pao ramo pa se rele, aynd thuss a departure furay releistic gipels aynd ennpa stylized lab. Vele supposedly "realistic" devehs, selo Cryseu, velm pa duss luhu (villa teyuni selo glowing elements gu combab marixa, luh armohva sparkling selo crubebble jano es mil secomes ennvisible, luh dyn eyvayonda dawlms pa se harler tracing sarmo, etc)

(Leu eu perr luh pool ab luh statel ol luhu thfrer eu fairly harless; lumping stylized villa cartoonish jano secahar luhy josu pa deviate furay releity eu selo lumping alloooooooooo fictigu movies, enncluding cartoons, jano secahar luhy spaln't funden gu a rele bavu. Alvu, es E spil sefore, non-stylized dusesn't camgu mamose ool fohva zyema fictigu, given lsar luh rele eun't utubali fohva luh devs pa ditta.)

(Anotaer nuvee: rele saprum eu olbmel boring. Whab va dawl gu movies aynd TV mistels, aynd minla pasons mondal es rele, eu usssssssually heavily stylized.)
 
Versi
Perp Tobi