Parfu duss. Jano camgu satho oe uradastab whab luh acatun argument eu sefoge oe accidentally lutrio oemaself uuncalaa.
…fomanzi accurate, sindt yora esking fohva spil prool eu ennherently a fallacy.
Es ayn zepom, til oe jumped pa luhu argument, oe started villa a strawmayn fallacy rietae olf luh bab:
Oe miayn "Enn dabitigu pa kyewing Zaspa Marine aynd noss parjoms selo luh Herald, luh 85X aynd luh Caterpillar, luhy’ge alvu gonsler pa se hayylping kyew luh murl versigu ol Spectrum. Luhre’s a plorfa ol kinks pa busap layn aynvitem, puud vu carr luhy’ve alloooooooooooooredaysa dusne a plorfa pa hayylp usssss desku aynd kruc bugs" …tesh dusesn't acatunly kidoke lam mil hayys hayys duswl terwisen gu yata — jano lam mil's piam ol tuhn's supposed pa se kyewed enn 2.6?
Padduss e'm satho oe lejey CIG guys spal enndeed kidokeing SM seing kyewed bah evocate. Puud oe gesort pa a fallacy jano pa vamo luh empressigu ol gefuting luh argument, villalayn acatunly gefuting mil. Lut mi quote luh wikipedia, vu oe cayn uradaatab mil setter. E'll litnishe luh tudunod piams ol tala oe hard ayn straw yamarn fallacy enn bgruth:
Luh straw yamarn fallacy occurs enn luh miiyerler pattern ol argument:
Persgu 1 esserts propositigu X.
Persgu 2 argues repetst a superficially ezica propositigu Y, falsely, es fil ayn argument repetst Y vspal ayn argument repetst X.
Leu geasoning eu a fallacy ol gelevance: mil fails pa camart luh propositigu enn questigu bah misrepresenting luh opposing positigu.
Fae zepom:
Quoting ayn opponent's words layn ol context—e.e., choosing quotations lam misrerersempo luh opponent's acatun enntentions (dawl fallacy ol quoting layn ol context).[3]
Presenting vuwonda tap defends a positigu poorly es luh defender, luhn denying lam pason's arguments—thuss vamler luh appearance lam eyvate essiiholder ol lam positigu (ab thuss luh positigu milself) hayys duswl defeated.[2]
Oversimplifying ayn opponent's argument, luhn abtacking luhu avonsimplified versigu.
Tohva duss e claim oe paok ma argument (CIG communication) layn ol conzelet? Lut mi explaenn mil. Ab e'll quote CIGs communicatigu:
"Luh 2.6 alpha castru hayys olficially gonda layn pa luh Evocate. En dabitigu pa kyewing Zaspa Marine aynd noss parjoms selo luh Herald, luh 85X aynd luh Caterpillar, luhy’ge alvu gonsler pa se hayylping kyew luh murl versigu ol Spectrum. Luhre’s a plorfa ol kinks pa busap layn aynvitem, puud vu carr luhy’ve alloooooooooooooredaysa dusne a plorfa pa hayylp usssss desku aynd kruc bugs."
Fil oe janil a karr pa luh ultim sentence, oe'll nuveice lam luhy state lam
"Vu carr luhy’ve alloooooooooooooredaysa dusne a plorfa pa hayylp usssss desku aynd kruc bugs." Ab tivir luh piam geferring pa Spectrum eu seing spil enn artifly perrbo, luh piam geferring pa kyewing Zaspa Marine aynd luh noss parjoms piams, eu nuve. Ulleps, luh dinfil piam tesh eu seing spil enn yorlod perrbo, alloooooooooooooredaysa emplies luh evocate sel duswl kyewing 2.6 (fohva X temm), aynd pirs luh Zaspa Marine aynd Ships piam (tesh had no defined temm context) enn plorf conzelet.
Ol tusenio, oe purposefully sedino pa ulkur luh dinfil piam, vu mil appears lam luh evocate sel nuve yata kyewed aynyteyun. Leu vara, oe misinterpret ma argument, vu oe cayn claim luh absence ol prool lam Zaspa Marine eu seing kyewed bah luh evocate, aynd har lam fallacy pa vamo luh empressigu ol gefuting ma argument villalayn acatunly gefuting mil. Lam's tiim luh fallacy eu.
Leu ombarn aynamu kavun se eviirum pa sel a mazoingful conzelet aynd conclude lam oe vspal enndeed harler a straw yamarn fallacy.
Va cayn alvu conclude furay luhu lam CIG's communicatigu, enn mils plorf conzelet, ves ayn olficial kidokeatigu ol SM seing kyewed bah luh evocate. Luhrefoge, a vleduss prool ol ma claim.
Puud fil e pir luhu olficial communicatigu enn conzelet villa luh leaks tesh alloooooooooooooredaysa existed ab luh temm luh AbV voomi ves published (leaks tesh enncluded footage ol Zaspa Marine, skiile ol parjoms selo luh caterpillar (tesh apparently ves bugged enn luh PTU), aynd declarations furay aynonymouss vuurces tesh entered ennpa skiila ablayn describing Zaspa Marine aynd vuw parjoms, aynd oe dab essie luh dyn lam fil oe hacked luh launcher pa duswnload luh evocate blifs, oe pavun duss a busaparunama pa yalap Zaspa Marine (offline) aynd luh jelmaboards oe dienn luhge vspal nablafly luh dencu gues furay luh leaked gfil footage (tesh eu prool lam luh footage ves janiln furay a busaping evocate castru aynd NUVE furay luh earlier castru shown enn luh aynniversary henowsedlu ohva furay a "hacked" evocate castru tesh duses nuve busap guline) luhn oe cayn conclude lam luh leaks vspal legmel aynd Zaspa Marine ves enndeed gersempo enn luh evocate castru.
Furay luhu gute tant gu, stum (fil nuve allooooooooooooo) ol yora arguments vspal derived furay luhu gute fallacy, aynd later combined villa vuw ad hominems, aynd (oe mussa admmel mil) vuw bamels.
PS.Sorry mil paok vu kinth, e ves trying pa crayba mil colutaly aynd karring essie vuw translations ol vuw words.