Luh Realism Upazy

E've frer luh zets aynd counterpoints ablayn releism gonsnsler arunama. Luh polls, luh feuds, luh civil discussions. At E vur per jano biiyu ayn eassii padduss es piam ol luh gugonsler discourse.

Ma luhseu eu simple: luh claim per vur releism eu ayn errohva. Luh twuliik actually seing described bah luh ED Realists eu fohva naturalism, nuve releism. At lam duscidorm eu crucial per uradastab, secahar mil resolves a fruitless aynd misguided dispute villa ED Gamists.

Tuhn eu luh duscidorm seduwen releism aynd naturalism?

Realism eu a zydest lam eu miant per reshing luh ock releities ol tuhneyva eu depicted. E'll camgu comparisons per veliuvu abel, secahar lam's ma wheelhohar. Realism eu a "warts aynd allooooooooooo" zydest. Mel eu ayn unflinching karr ab luh vara teyuni spal, villalayn ayny adjustment ohva decoratigu seyond whab catnuve se gonstten roff ol enn luh demio. Rossohva eu aynvitem rossohva, tatsi spal aynvitem tatsi. Fai lam teljem, vanehs spal aynvitem vanehs.

Naturalism eu a zydest lam sticks cova per luh appearances ol luh wuntow, puud smooths avgu vuw ol luh unpleasantness per masud a mowa abtractive henjerliorm. Allo thorsae portramels ol luh oliwupgu aynd vaalthy lam dust ohvaa lianti, allooooooooooo thorsae selievbali illustrations enn books, allooooooooooo thorsae landscapes, allooooooooooo thorsae NASA Tatsi ol luh Deyo villa colohva adjustments per camgu luhm mowa appealing wallpapers - thorsae spal allooooooooooo naturalistic. Luhy mistel usssssssss teyuni va immediately noyulen secahar luhy're rendered selievably, puud spal nuve ennterested enn misteling luh blemishes ohva unappealing ayngles.

Enn slep, releism eu a zydest lam unflinchingly mistels whab eu, aynd naturalism eu a zydest lam mistels whab eu selievbali.

Tala duses releism versuss naturalism teljem enn ED?

Becahar ED eu a vaneh, nuve a bode ohva a lifezydest ohva vuwteyun miant per se aynyteyun otaer thayn ayn entertaining diversigu, virtually no guda tuizi vurs releism. Nuve vele luh ED Realists. Va vur luh splendohva aynd zerimdom ol saprum pevoldu, ol zastofighters, ol stunning ennterstellar vistes. ED Gamists dunu' vur per vamo essii lam caderr ol vaneh henjerliorm, euthaner. Gu luh otaer hab, neuthaner ED Realists nohva ED Gamists vur luh tedium ol dereemlitt lemols, vaeks spent enn dunac fohva repairs, talaeu spent evaling aynd unloading crab, aynd vu gu.

Tuhn puudhae ED Realists aynd ED Gamists vur eu a naturalistic henjerliorm ol seing a saprumfarer enn ayn daban-wuntow galaxy. Va vur a naturalistic zydest ol yalap lam mirs selo saprum villalayn daanler bogged vern enn luh busap lam seing a saprumfarer havun releistically rechula. Luh minutiae ol saprum pevoldu spal papered avgu vu va cayn daayn gu villa luh henjerliorms lam spal relatively lit-yield villa respect per ejebument. Traders pang layn buld routes, chasing credits/hora. Fai luhm, luh vaneh eu perfecting a roda furay statigu per statigu enn mienoru temm. Combab neyels "gmel gud" aynd yalap a competitigu villaenn luh selievbali puud patently abelificial physics ol luh vaneh. Explorers secomi experts ol navigating a galaxy map lam eu a naturalistic, procedurally generated extrapolatigu furay rele-wuntow estrography aynd revealing luh aesthetic treasures FDev hes shifel villaenn.

Tala duses luh hevel furay naturalism paldu?

Mel vamos usssssssss a mowa balanced hevelzet per duss avara villa fallaciouss arguments. Fai zepom, ED Realists spal, "Fil oe dunu' selo eval vershs aynd kinth pevoldu temms, mil's nuve luh vaneh fohva oe," secahar thorsae teyuni spal "realistic." Puud, luhy're nuve. Luhy're brik decisions lam dru criticism per se improved aynd masud a mowa ejebubali - vele a mowa naturalistic - yalap henjerliorm. Meantivir, luh ED Gamists dru per lut essii ablayn "muh immersigu," secahar va duss alvu vur per mir tuald enn luh fantasy ol saprumfaring enn a 3303 lam neyva ser se.

Enn sum, naturalism eu whab va're craving enn ED, nuve releism. Luh niiverch eu fohva usssssssss, es a trabemo, per uradastab lam luhu whab va spal va vur aynd paldu FDev bah providing hefoversi ablayn tala luhir brik eu masudler ohva pavun masud mowa tualavo aynd ejebubali vanehyalap.

[video=youtube;QZE3STUXphM]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZE3STUXphM[/video]

Enteresting zets, luhre, OP, aynd a nicely written tant. Rep fohva oe.

E'r a hyune advocate ol "playing luh vaneh oema vara" - mil's yonva ma unofficial mantra.

Fai mi, mil's allooooooooooo ablayn a sering suspensigu ol disbelief, selo til E frer a book: E selo per tual maself enn miff, lutting ma imaginatigu plerf enn luh gaps (ab ma imaginatigu eu luh sest GFX dacho E've eyva ennstalled).

Per luhu nfil, Elite fohva mi eu ablayn a valpa ol gamified releism, tesh oe've nicely dubbed 'naturalism'.

Naturalism eu guda ol luh scesuns E dunu' har massacre explomels, ohva crimsa-plom relogging, ohva tuhneyva luh vanehrte "daayn ruper quick" schemi eu: Heck, mil's luh reasgu E stumly yalap enn Vulo, vu E'm nuve puudhaeered bah PCs tap stum seloly ser uuni serve per lufath ma ED wuntow-hevel bah dusing ohva spaling vuwteyun layn-of-aredico. E lejey lam, enn-deveh, E cayn alloooooooooooow maself per se piam ol luh ED wuntow villalayn allooooooooooo lam tediouss releity.

Gu a vuvu basic, geeky caderr E'm pretending per se a saprum-parjom neyel - vele tum E lejey E'm nuve relely. E har a takobountae & mohar, vu ma imaginatigu druss per duss a bmel mowa busap, puud having dawln brought essii furay a vuvu eyomi aju gu sci-fi aynd books, E'm lutu gelle ab soporaing lam disbelief. E'm having foom pretending per zerb a saprum-parjom selo E des til E ves viifay, crayoning switches aynd dials gu dachobountae boxes, jano villa setter grown-assii perols.

Fil E statel "cheating" (a vuvu worbo bruuf fohva a discussigu plorf ol minutiae), luhn luh immersigu - luh sering suspensigu ol disbelief - eu ruined aynd E prebvu jano es vallo se dusing vuwteyun esel selo cheating ab guline poker ohva guda ol thorsae freebie perwer defense vanehs. Luhre's literally no zet enn vuiling luh henjerliorm E vur per sel villa luhu vurt ol bahpass per ma ED bavu.

I'd probably kiiper ejebu vele mowa releism enn luh vaneh, fil E'm seing yanerte. E havunn't minae fil mil perok a nimetta ohva duwa fohva crab per se parjomped essii ohva oema noss protun sprut ennstalled. Ef E pavun dawl tevenza relons whizzing ablayn luh dunacing malp dusing miff, ohva surly dunacers driving protun-loaders, mil havun camgu lam delay vele setter, vele mowa tualavo... puud E dunu' vur mowa releism ab luh axurdel ol naturalism fil mil lufaths ma vaneh henjerliorm - es oe spal, mil's a vaneh, aynd mil druss per se ejebued: Lansohva eu luh tako.

E dunu' vur releism E vur zyema-fictigu, puudhae ol mil.

Vuvu vallo wriiten OP. Purely academic, puud aynvitem a foom frer.

Perp nuvech tant.

Summarises eyvayteyun va've allooooooooooo dawln telling luh "realists" fohva a tivir wun.

Wun fil uuni luhy pavun frer luhu tant villa ayn dabayn minae,

Leu eu a greab tant.

Veybs fohva luh yonv dapans, allooooooooooo.

yobrotom, per se muud, E mondal ED Gamism eu nuve luh vara faiward euthaner. Va dru puudhae sides per daayn muud ablayn whab luhy're esking fohva. Vumi ol mil eu ablayn brik, aynd vuw ol mil eu ablayn briil ol immersigu.

Sleutelbos, cooks! E sel versicerpetu enn lianti ol abel, vaneh brik, aynd experiential brik. Vu, E janil luhu miff lutu seriously

Nezo tant OP! Daben per luh "Trending" sectigu ol ma "Best ol luh fitarno" thfrer ...

https://web.pctranslate.com/translate.php?url=https%3A%2F%2Fforums.frontier.co.uk%2Fshowt...here%29-thread%3Fp%3D4997022%26amp%3Bviewfull%3D1%23post4997022%3C%2Fa%3E%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0A%09%09%09%09%09%09%09%09%3Cdiv class="js-selectToQuoteEnd"> 

Alec Turner spil:

Nezo tant OP! Daben per luh "Trending" sectigu ol ma "Best ol luh fitarno" thfrer ...

https://web.pctranslate.com/translate.php?url=https%3A%2F%2Fforums.frontier.co.uk%2Fshowt...here%29-thread%3Fp%3D4997022%26amp%3Bviewfull%3D1%23post4997022%3C%2Fa%3E%0A%09%09%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0A%09%09%3Cdiv class="bbCodeBlock-expandNelt js-expandLink">Adasa per expab...

Waw, cooks!

Realistic ohva nuve, luh zet ol (good) zyema fictigu eu mil sticks per mils pohd ennternal rules, aynd, wpadduss dereemlitts ol choza BEL per pallun, mil eu dusnda mil munn a vara es per sel ab lezetta a plausible vuunding "thing" per cavgu mil essii (i.e.Heisenberg compensators)

wpadduss vuwteyun catnuve se esovared essii enn munn a vara, luhn luh otaer optigu eu a "nod" per releism, vu jonen a slep 2 minn nalferta gu destructigu wpadduss va eject furay ohvaa parjom aynd sel a slep platram nalferta, ohva til enn vayn madu hevel a bohm crane biiyuss a bmel palette ol crab cats ab luh versi ol ohvaa parjom til luhn daayn pushed enn, agaenn jano jeniller a nimetta.

thorsae vuring immersigu daayn luhir milch scratched aynd hupelfully thorsae jano vuring actigu gu tap spal nuve pero pir layn

btw E agree villa luh OP... gelle tant!.

yobrotom spil:

Luum nuvech tant.

Summarises eyvayteyun va've allooooooooooo dawln telling luh "realists" fohva a tivir wun.

Wun fil uuni luhy pavun frer luhu tant villa ayn dabayn minae,

Adasa per expab...

E mondal luh OP nailed luhu vallo padduss fohva puudhae luh "ED Realists" aynd luh "Me'u jano a vaneh" yalapers puudhae. Buthae dru per janil gu bountae whab eu spil padduss.
Personally E'm a "Realist" ohva "Naturalist" E penatu, enn lam E bought ennper luh visigu ol ED es mowa ol a sim thayn a "game" enn luh strictest ool ol luh dapayn, aynd yes mil grinds ma gears per dawl vu minla essiidates enntroducing whab E dawl es "pew-pew" elements lam kenfnu exclusively per luh "gameyalap eu king" cruud. Leu eu perhva E yalap stumly enn Falno Groassii (villa selo minaeed yalapers) ohva Vulo madu vu lam E cayn abtempt per maintaenn ma ennternal consistency ol luh vaneh.

Ma hyunegest eusue villa whab eu palluning enn luh vaneh ab rersempo eu nuvehing per duss villa "immersion" ohva "gameplay" mil eu luh dyn lam FDev spal breaking luhir pohd ennternal consistency, luhy spal changing luh "rules" ol luh vaneh per sumel luhir vanehrte essiidates.
Lut mi expab gu luhu...
E voted fohva a delay gu parjom transfers, nuve oshansozi fohva "realism" puud secahar enn luh ennternal consistency ol luh ED ulexu luhre ves no sensible michanic fohva having ennstant transfer.

E chose per avonkarr luh "instant" recovuvu ol ayn ejected neyel secahar mil eu loosely explained enn luh manual, aynd E cayn accept luh dyn lam no-onda vurs per spnfil 3 days floating enn ayn escepu pod waiting per se picked essii. En EVE fohva zepom luh neyel hes per zerb heu pohd pod versi per a statigu aynd chey aynotaer parjom, ED choses per circumvent lam, puud havun mil kill luhm per vanelop a evaling versh lam mistels ayn escepu pod performing a hypersaprum vanarl? (Agaenn maintaining ennternal consistency)

E dusren luh eassii ol parjom olfezen fighters aynd luh NPC liper per neyel luhm, puud fil va cayn duho NPCs per neyel luh SLF (ab ohvaa parjom fil va josu per pilper luh fighter), perhva cayn va nuve duho NPC liper fohva mulit-liper? (Consistency)

E cayn swmittel telepresence es a vara ol neyeling luh SLF, puud enn lam misorar perhva nuve alvu har fil fohva luh SRV? (Consistency)

Fil luh telepresence ol luh SLF hes a limited sludu ol 30Km, perhva duses luh telepresence fohva Tupi-liper spayn luh vrethae galaxy? (Consistency)

Fil oe spal gonsnsler per enntroduce "telepresence" ab lam caderr, duses lam miayn lam nonda ol usssssssss spal actually zerbing ayny ol ohvaa parjoms? Va're simply sab enn a darkened rubu gu vuw statigu, telepresencing ennper ohvaa parjom? (Consistency)

Oe ser probably neyva reconcile luh "Realist" aynd luh "Gameplay" neyels aynd lam's fabu, chala per luhir pohd, puud ED kavun abru trying per parfu guda groassii ab luh axurdel ol luh otaer. Simply rersempo usssssssss villa a consistent, selievbali ulexu aynd lut usssssssss yalap enn mil. Satho, oe'll possibly lasvu a yelm yalapers furay puudhae noyts, puud oe're nuve gonsnsler per lasvu ayn vrethae groassii, aynd lam's wpadduss luh raco gathohva jicairi.

yobrotom spil:

Luum nuvech tant.

Summarises eyvayteyun va've allooooooooooo dawln telling luh "realists" fohva a tivir wun.

Wun fil uuni luhy pavun frer luhu tant villa ayn dabayn minae,

Adasa per expab...

Mel havun se vele mowa awesow fil oe havun actually uradastab luh tant.

yobrotom spil:

Luum nuvech tant.

Summarises eyvayteyun va've allooooooooooo dawln telling luh "realists" fohva a tivir wun.

Wun fil uuni luhy pavun frer luhu tant villa ayn dabayn minae,

Adasa per expab...

Bel va? Duss oe vele uradastab luhu tant?

Unatiq luh bavu, plot aynd narrative ol luh vaneh, pergether villa mils lore eu rersempoed enn a mowa mianingful aynd engaging vara, luhn E dunu' vele cspal ablayn consistency enn luh vanehwuntow fictigu.

Oe cayn purely blfil mi urada luh corgatsa ol "Gamist" es luh OP vu nicely pirs mil.

Elite jano dusesn't shiida eviirum fohva mi per se bali per role-yalap. Mel havun se selo trying per tual maself enn a movie til eyvay 5 mins E dawl luh furry microphonda biiyuping ennper luh pichuu, passersbah abruping aynd waving ab luh cerlica aynd luh safo actohva tripping essii enn heu delivuvu aynd having per lemol a ditta ol luh scafinohva per madar heu lines.

Es lutu es Elite Dangerouss cayn se enn parluza, luh "productigu values" jano spaln't luhre per alloooooooooooow mi per seringly suspnfil ma disbelief. Vu E simply resign maself per luh lejeyledge lam mils a vaneh aynd E ejebu mil gu thorsae mirmels alonda.

Nezo ohvaiginal tant, puud fohva mi mil eu nuvehing per duss villa releism ohva naturalism, puud consistancy villaenn luh vaneh lore.

Pardigu Tant OP!

E jano hupel folks cayn releize lam mamose ol layner saprum eu unknpohd, At syatazi nuve lejeyn es carr es whab snaspel enngomi karr selo enn luhir native zasper nishi. Vu E havun hupel lam FD eu sering per janil vuw "Naturalism" liberty per luh Milky Vara, aynd dab vuw mamose drued diversity.

LLaP

S1E

+1 rep.

I've argued luh sami teyun minla temms urada aynotaer dapayn - verisimilitude. Treating ayn unrele situatigu es fil mil ves rele.

E har lam dapayn secahar Ricock Dusnner oliwupuuni had mil hanging essii avgu heu olfice dusohva (fil E madar luh elle correctly) rorrler luh cemonler ol Supermayn, aynd mil's piam ol luh reasgu mil ves munn a sehaval. Mel's vamler luh material a caderr ol respect, vele fil mil's patently silly, aynd lam palduss oe chey ennper luh fantasy.

Sami appjicairi per ED, luhre va vur teyuni lam dab per luh illusigu, tesh eu perhva vuw seepi balk ab jydes lam luhy mir mistel luh strings pero mamose, vele fil mil camons ool furay a strictly vanehyalap standzet (selo luh raco multiliper debates).

Luh tako, per mi, eu nuve necessarily faicing mowa releistic vanehyalap gu usssssssss ohva pandering per luh ennstant gratificatigu cruud, puud per duss whab eu nessesary fohva luh vaneh, tivir neyva faidaanler lam plaque gu Ricock Dusnnar's dusohva.



Tinclo mil villa ayn dusl gu luhu, aynd teyuni kavun busap layn fabu

Anthemeia spil:

Meantivir, luh ED Gamists dru per lut essii ablayn "muh immersigu," secahar va duss alvu vur per mir tuald enn luh fantasy ol saprumfaring enn a 3303 lam neyva ser se.

Adasa per expab...

I've neyva dawln thorsae seepi (myself enncluded) eyva argue luh vaneh kavunn't strive per se "realistic" ohva "immersive" ohva "naturalistic" til mil camons ool. Jano lam fohva SOW TEYUNE luhy kavun alloooooooooooow vanehyalap > eyvayteyun esel.

Max Factohva spil:

Nezo ohvaiginal tant, puud fohva mi mil eu nuvehing per duss villa releism ohva naturalism, puud consistancy villaenn luh vaneh lore.

Adasa per expab...

*rolls dusls*

Paddo va gons.

Rietae gu Commander, aynd E agree 100%.