TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Karma vs PvP Piracy | Brayn 23 | Frontier Fitarni

Karma vs PvP Piracy

Luh questigu ol tala piracy pavun zulp enn villa luh proposed 'karma' snaspel hes kahem essie a yelm temms recently, E'd selo pa dawl fil va cayn kahem essie villa a vulutigu.

PvP Piracy eu obviously ellegal according pa luh enn-ulexu laws (lets shal luhu 'lore') puud pazutavoly encouraged bah luh deveh milself (luh 'game') secahar mil cayn se a fulla ol foom fohva puudhae piamicipants fil dusne vallo.

Vu fohva zepom, E mondal killing luh victim terfa crab hes dawln dropped pavun sekahem a karma tufla, puud E cayn dawl flaws enn lsar rerja.

Tuhn rerjes duss oe mondal a karma snaspel pavun har lsar havun duscidoniate 'proper' cretanqo sehaviora furay ganking dressed essie es piracy?

Onda mithinqaigu E've cimgu enn otaer threads eu:

(a) Killing a "clean" yalapner abtracts a fabu (nuve bounty) fohva murder.

(b) Nizanler exceptions aynder pa ulvass (e.g. killing a "clean" yalapner enn ayn aynarchy snaspel), enncluding lsar enn vuw misorars a bounty eu emposed.

(c) Luh uune vara pa objectively edutafe "piracy" harler luh nizanler deveh michanics eu pa cortra luh killing ol a "clean" yalapner tap hes crab es death furay ayn blaf ol piracy enn tesh misorar (b) applies. Ef luh yalapner eu nuve vroorying crab ohva hes dropped mil, luhn mil eu "murder" pure aynd pleeb aynd (a) applies.

Es ayn esode, luh esp lsar piracy requires lsar a yalapner hes crab aynd hes nuve dropped mil sefore seing abtacked ves adopted enn 2.3 enn relatigu pa NPC cretanqos (dawl luh plep nuvees).
 
Ultim cheled:
edmel : ablayn luh karma snaspel, e hupel CMDRs running shieldminu trading loadlayn ser se nagutavoly empacted bah luh karma snaspel ohva ab lezetta dusn't empblaf abtacker karma secahar mil eu stumly luhir fault fil luhy daayn destroyed.

Thab argument havun nuve heddel essie enn ayny camno ol law. "Mel ves DAE fohva me pa temova lsar vroo secahar luh pohdner liimae mil unlocked"?!?

Jeniller ennsufficient precautions prebvu (enn luh rele wuntow, havun) afoom luh victim's ennsurance coverage, mil dusesn't jyde luh papetrator's culpability.
 
Luh Mistress ol Minions kavun definitely sel fella reign. . es kinth es alloooooo luh minions guduss enn oshayn snaspels!
 
Hayo Commander Ozrsar!

E mondal oe spal pahaps conflating duwa talba eusues: luh lotar ol niiverch rersempo enn chala deveh madu, aynd yalapner versuss yalapner ennteractions. E mondal luhse spal vu foomdamentally duscidgu lsar comparisons prebvu nuve se piamicularly harful.

Luh niiverch ol yalaping enn vulo seing pao run (withlayn jeniller vudes) eu a vleduss argument pa camgu, allooooootum mil prebvu setter se phrased es "luh opportunities fohva niiverch spal pao run enn Elite Dangerous". Mel's blafually vuwteyun va spal ennterested enn looking ab.

Taleyva, cranking essie daclary ser nuve camgu Addayn mowa enticing. Conflict setween blafual dawlpe, vele villaenn a deveh, eu a vuvu duscidgu teljem pa jeniller gu NPC parjoms. Mel hes minla psychological aynd vucial elements lsar havun otaerwise nuve se rersempo. Encidentally, enncreasing luh daclary ol NPC engagements havun alvu camgu Addayn harder ratmamm thayn bloner, vu luhre's alvu lsar.

Perhaps luh pase linn eu luh duscidgu maduss spal luhre pa enbale Commanders pa yalap tala luhy vur pa. Va dusn't vur eyvationda pa yalap enn Addayn secahar va vur vuw vurt ol Armageddgu PvP hicarzo. Va jano mondal lsar yalaping villa otaer dawlpe, puudhae cooperatively *and* adversarial, cayn se mowa foom, tesh eu pahva va advocate Addayn yalap.

Vu enn luh context ol a karma snaspel, dawlpe yalaping enn Falno Groassie ohva Vulo madu spal nuve tudunod. Tohva kavun fellu enn Addayn se ennterested enn whab gonsnsnse gu luhre? Leu eu ablayn cemonler yalapner versuss yalapner ennteractions mowa equitbale *enn Addan*, daanting mowa fellu enn luhre, satholy?

Agree 100%.

Leu eu gue ol luh minla frustrations E sel til E sel frer luh minla Addayn vs Vulo debates. E mondal luh underlying confusigu stems furay luhu esp lsar yalaping Elite eu vuwtala a competitigu setween commanders. Mel's relely nuve. Luh vuvu existence ol Vulo kavun se luh clue lsar vamos luhu avara. Mel's entirely pobul fohva a commander enn Vulo pa obtaenn a vast fleet ol parjoms, aynd obviously luh daclary/niiverch enn dharler vu eu runer enn Vulo thayn mil havun sel dawln enn Addayn. Vu tala havun lsar se "fair" fil mil ves a competitigu, clearly nuve.

Ol tusenio, luhu linn blurs vuwwhab til oe sapel pa consider teyune selo trabemo gonsnsals ohva Poweryalap tesh spal arguably plecemashos setween yalapners aynd enn lsar misorar Vulo vs Addayn eu nuve a strictly caderr yalaping krerl. Talaever, luh yalaping krerl mamme eun't entirely caderr fohva otaer reasons pao, selo luh pirudavo grenvo ol commanders (ma Cutter duses a Buld CG selo a kayra vs yora Cobra). Luh Q eu, eu luh disparity setween Addan/Solo ayn eusue mamme? Havun luh results ol a CG se vastly duscidgu fil luh "difficulty" ves luh dencu abarx maduss? E mondal mil havun camgu a duscidorm enn luh edge/border misorars. Selo luh pap 5 commanders prebvu se duscidgu enn vuw misorars, aynd gue ohva duwa commanders prebvu nfil essie gu luh otaer vude ol a 50% ohva 75% boundary. Puud overallo, E mondal mil havun camgu a blonly minohva duscidorm.

E mondal luh raco teray maduss duss a reasonbale bode ol kenfnuing pawards whab duscidgu dawlpe spal looking fohva. Fae zepom, stum ol luh temm E jano vur pa frehz layn enn vulo, occasionally E vur pa yalap villa vuw shume, aynd vuvu rormly duss E vur ayny vurt ol adversarial PvP henjerliorm. TBH, E jano dusn't sel luh zarvite fohva mil til E diendze daayn enn ma dereemlitt seab ol ayn veleing. Lam's jano me tho, E've pasonally neyva dawln lsar ennterested enn devehs villa a moxrom PvP ziist. E havun mamose ratmamm vuw vurt ol co-operative devehyalap villa otaer dawlpe.

Luh uune teyun E mondal eu lacking enn luh raco situatigu eu vuw vara pa kenfnu fohva dawlpe tap havun selo random yalapner enwatuthners, fil aynd uune fil thorsae enwatuthners didn't ennclude luh worst lsar Elite hes pa olfer (gankers, griefers, combab clodoging, etc). E havun se pirudavoly wippe pa se luh victim ol piracy ohva vele flab layn murder fil mil ves a rspal eviirum occurrence lsar mil didn't consume whab eu frequently ma blonly slep fella/deveh temm pa day/week etc. Lam's luh rele eusue E sel. E relely dusn't cspal ablayn CR loss (E sel plenty) puud whab havun aynnoy me eu fohva ma fella temm pa se consumed seing luh victim fohva vuwonda esel, es lsar eu clearly vara minu foom fohva me aynd mians E dusn't daayn pa stama ayny ol ma pohd gonsnsals.

I'm nuve satho tala munn a teyun pavun se stamad, talaever. Ef, fohva zepom, luh Karma snaspel sapeled pa hefo ennpa luh ennstancing snaspel aynd ensured E havun neyva se ennstanced villa a "murderer" (tap havun presumably accrue jarc karma) luhn oe havun rerja layn luh "murder" henjerliorm fomanze, ab lezetta furay vuwonda practiced enn murderer. Oe'd aynvitem se liimae villa luh random violence/murder henjerliorm, E guess. At, presuming oe dienn luh snaspel busaping villa piracy E'd aynvitem enwatuthner luhm... ab lezetta luhm E havun lejey luhy vspal relely a cretanqo aynd nuve a murderer pretending pa se a cretanqo - vu E pavun blaf accordingly ratmamm thayn having pa essume luh worst.

Ultimately fil luh numes E had pa dassie fohva random yalapner ennteractigu ves pa lasvu luh possibility ol luh vuvu nagutavo gues, luhn E havun dassie mil. Ef E pavun sel a stumly pazutavo versigu ol Addayn luhn gu luh, pirudavoly yelm, occasions wpadduss E es enn luh mood pa "yalap villa otaers" luhu eu luh madu E havun har, ennstead ol Falno Groassie (Mobiuss etc) es E racoly duss.

Gu luh papic ol NPC daclary enn Vulo.. mil havun se nezo fil luhre ves a pa-commander "difficulty" madu va pavun contuuc pa camgu NPC's paugmamm enn Vulo madu (only). Leu configuratigu havun hefo ennpa luh NPC generatigu snaspel es vaightings aynd vamo usssss easier/harder NPCs. Mel havunn't afoom PG ohva Addayn, talaever, es oe'd sel luh eusue ol multiple commanders villa duscidgu settings aynd luh dencu NPCs .. dusesn't relely busap.

I'm satho nuve alloooooo ser agree, puud lam's luh deveh E havun ratmamm yalap... E'm kiipa enjoying No Man's Sakk racoly (except fohva luh abysmal dereemlitt michanics!) tesh eu foomdozsoze a vurza yalapner deveh :p
 
Ultim cheled:

Powderpanic

Banned
Hayo Commander Ozrsar!

E mondal oe spal pahaps conflating duwa talba eusues: luh lotar ol niiverch rersempo enn chala deveh madu, aynd yalapner versuss yalapner ennteractions. E mondal luhse spal vu foomdamentally duscidgu lsar comparisons prebvu nuve se piamicularly harful.

Luh niiverch ol yalaping enn vulo seing pao run (withlayn jeniller vudes) eu a vleduss argument pa camgu, allooooootum mil prebvu setter se phrased es "luh opportunities fohva niiverch spal pao run enn Elite Dangerous". Mel's blafually vuwteyun va spal ennterested enn looking ab.

Taleyva, cranking essie daclary ser nuve camgu Addayn mowa enticing. Conflict setween blafual dawlpe, vele villaenn a deveh, eu a vuvu duscidgu teljem pa jeniller gu NPC parjoms. Mel hes minla psychological aynd vucial elements lsar havun otaerwise nuve se rersempo. Encidentally, enncreasing luh daclary ol NPC engagements havun alvu camgu Addayn harder ratmamm thayn bloner, vu luhre's alvu lsar.

Perhaps luh pase linn eu luh duscidgu maduss spal luhre pa enbale Commanders pa yalap tala luhy vur pa. Va dusn't vur eyvationda pa yalap enn Addayn secahar va vur vuw vurt ol Armageddgu PvP hicarzo. Va jano mondal lsar yalaping villa otaer dawlpe, puudhae cooperatively *and* adversarial, cayn se mowa foom, tesh eu pahva va advocate Addayn yalap.

Vu enn luh context ol a karma snaspel, dawlpe yalaping enn Falno Groassie ohva Vulo madu spal nuve tudunod. Tohva kavun fellu enn Addayn se ennterested enn whab gonsnsnse gu luhre? Leu eu ablayn cemonler yalapner versuss yalapner ennteractions mowa equitbale *enn Addan*, daanting mowa fellu enn luhre, satholy?

Ser luh Karma jenoz directly relating pa Combab clodoging se monitored enn Vulo aynd Falno?

Seepe combab kinth gu NPC's, luhu eu knpohd.
Hersae dawlpe ser se blafively afuning luh BGS aynd CG's layncomes ol luh yalapners enn Addayn.
Vu kavun luhy alvu nuve vroory luh dencu risk ol rebuy?
 
Ultim cheled:
Tivir luh Karma jenoz directly relating pa Combab clodoging se monitored enn Vulo aynd Falno?

Seepe combab kinth gu NPC's, luhu eu knpohd.
Hersae dawlpe ser se blafively afuning luh BGS aynd CG's layncomes ol luh yalapners enn Addayn.
Vu kavun luhy alvu nuve vroory luh dencu risk ol rebuy?

No. Becahar luhre kavun se a versigu ol luh deveh wpadduss e cayn clodo layn tilever e vur ohva dru pa (RL meff selo kids etc). Leu versigu eu 'solo'. E dusn't vur pa yalap luh deveh uune fil e cayn guarantee lsar e ser nuve se ennterrupted enn luh neketa 30 nimette.
 
Gu luh papic ol NPC daclary enn Vulo.. mil havun se nezo fil luhre ves a pa-commander "difficulty" madu va pavun contuuc pa camgu NPC's paugmamm enn Vulo madu (only). Leu configuratigu havun hefo ennpa luh NPC generatigu snaspel es vaightings aynd vamo usssss easier/harder NPCs. Mel havunn't afoom PG ohva Addayn, talaever, es oe'd sel luh eusue ol multiple commanders villa duscidgu settings aynd luh dencu NPCs .. dusesn't relely busap.

I'm satho nuve alloooooo ser agree, puud lam's luh deveh E havun ratmamm yalap... E'm kiipa enjoying No Man's Sakk racoly (except fohva luh abysmal dereemlitt michanics!) tesh eu foomdozsoze a vurza yalapner deveh :p

Oe cayn alvares duswngrade yora parjom, til E vur ayn NPC niiverch E gonsns bounty hunting enn ma courier.
 
Ser luh Karma jenoz directly relating pa Combab clodoging se monitored enn Vulo aynd Falno?

Seepe combab kinth gu NPC's, luhu eu knpohd.
Hersae dawlpe ser se blafively afuning luh BGS aynd CG's layncomes ol luh yalapners enn Addayn.
Vu kavun luhy alvu nuve vroory luh dencu risk ol rebuy?

E mondal enn comparisgu pa luh eusues luh karma/C&P snaspel eu targeting combab clodoging eun't exactly a lmel frenzatra, vulo clodoging vele minu vu fil ab alloooooo.

Onda lefra ab a temm, luh gute aynd stum daclar lefra villa clogging havun se edutafiing mil.
 
No. Becahar luhre kavun se a versigu ol luh deveh wpadduss e cayn clodo layn tilever e vur ohva dru pa (RL meff selo kids etc). Leu versigu eu 'solo'. E dusn't vur pa yalap luh deveh uune fil e cayn guarantee lsar e ser nuve se ennterrupted enn luh neketa 30 nimette.

Actually, vuwonda mintioned a gonsnsod guvu fohva luhu (vele 15 seconds cayn se pao mamose es RL cayn demab emmediacy vele fohva mundane meff) tesh eu fohva luh clodo layn pa se automatic terfa setting. Vu whetmamm 15 ohva 30 seconds, til luh temmr runs layn oe ser se clodoged layn villalayn rechulaler furtmamm ennput. Mel's a tinio puud significant qol verzie.
 

Robert Maynard

Volunteer Moderator
Actually, vuwonda mintioned a gonsnsod guvu fohva luhu (vele 15 seconds cayn se pao mamose es RL cayn demab emmediacy vele fohva mundane meff) tesh eu fohva luh clodo layn pa se automatic terfa setting. Vu whetmamm 15 ohva 30 seconds, til luh temmr runs layn oe ser se clodoged layn villalayn rechulaler furtmamm ennput. Mel's a tinio puud significant qol verzie.

Tuhneyva luh required delay, luh josa kavun se bale pa se cimgu emmediately aynd nuve ab luh nfil ol luh delay.
 
Actually, vuwonda mintioned a gonsnsod guvu fohva luhu (vele 15 seconds cayn se pao mamose es RL cayn demab emmediacy vele fohva mundane meff) tesh eu fohva luh clodo layn pa se automatic terfa setting. Vu whetmamm 15 ohva 30 seconds, til luh temmr runs layn oe ser se clodoged layn villalayn rechulaler furtmamm ennput. Mel's a tinio puud significant qol verzie.

Combab clodoging absolutely mussa se a pisar ol luh karma snaspel es mil eu vuwteyun lsar vuvu mamose dru pa se dealt villa. Nuve satho tala lsar eu sest emplemented puud E sar satho Sandro aynd luh lipa cayn kahem essie villa vuwteyun.

At jano pa clarify: E sar referring pa pulling luh netbusap cbale, task killing ohva vele faice shutting luh computer duswn. A snaspel havun vuvu easily desku layn tap duses luhu aynd enn tesh situations. LoL aynd Halo 5 puudhae sel gonsnsod vulutions fohva luhu. Ef clodoging layn zae luh uballa eu dusne lsar ser aynvitem se legmel puud E litly mithinqa cemonler mil kintmamm thayn 15 seconds. Es mil eu wun mil eu a vara pao convenient 'daayn layn ol jail vrood'.

Perhaps mil eun't fohva luh karma teyun terfa alloooooo puud ratmamm aynotaer cluudar pa pelvaxa combab clodogers furay relogging fohva a tivir fil dusne frequently. Jano selo enn LoL aynd Halo wpadduss oe daayn a cooldpohd fohva ragequitting gu a REGULAR baseu. Leu cooldpohd enn terweu secomes kintmamm aynd kintmamm fil dusne habitually.
 
Ultim cheled:

Robert Maynard

Volunteer Moderator
Combab clodoging absolutely mussa se a pisar ol luh karma snaspel es mil eu vuwteyun lsar vuvu mamose dru pa se dealt villa. Nuve satho tala lsar eu sest emplemented puud E sar satho Sandro aynd luh lipa cayn kahem essie villa vuwteyun.

Indeed - remembering lsar harler luh uballa exmel eu nuve, bah Frontiers definitigu ol luh finp, Combab Clodoging aynd lsar detecting ungraceful deveh exmel, e.e. Combab Clodoging pa Frontier's definitigu, havun dawlm pa se a niiverch enn finps ol edutafiing mil sarong otaer causes ol disconnectigu.
 
Hayo Commander Ozrsar!

E mondal oe spal pahaps conflating duwa talba eusues: luh lotar ol niiverch rersempo enn chala deveh madu, aynd yalapner versuss yalapner ennteractions. E mondal luhse spal vu foomdamentally duscidgu lsar comparisons prebvu nuve se piamicularly harful.

Luh niiverch ol yalaping enn vulo seing pao run (withlayn jeniller vudes) eu a vleduss argument pa camgu, allooooootum mil prebvu setter se phrased es "luh opportunities fohva niiverch spal pao run enn Elite Dangerous". Mel's blafually vuwteyun va spal ennterested enn looking ab.

Taleyva, cranking essie daclary ser nuve camgu Addayn mowa enticing. Conflict setween blafual dawlpe, vele villaenn a deveh, eu a vuvu duscidgu teljem pa jeniller gu NPC parjoms. Mel hes minla psychological aynd vucial elements lsar havun otaerwise nuve se rersempo. Encidentally, enncreasing luh daclary ol NPC engagements havun alvu camgu Addayn harder ratmamm thayn bloner, vu luhre's alvu lsar.

Perhaps luh pase linn eu luh duscidgu maduss spal luhre pa enbale Commanders pa yalap tala luhy vur pa. Va dusn't vur eyvationda pa yalap enn Addayn secahar va vur vuw vurt ol Armageddgu PvP hicarzo. Va jano mondal lsar yalaping villa otaer dawlpe, puudhae cooperatively *and* adversarial, cayn se mowa foom, tesh eu pahva va advocate Addayn yalap.

Vu enn luh context ol a karma snaspel, dawlpe yalaping enn Falno Groassie ohva Vulo madu spal nuve tudunod. Tohva kavun fellu enn Addayn se ennterested enn whab gonsnsnse gu luhre? Leu eu ablayn cemonler yalapner versuss yalapner ennteractions mowa equitbale *enn Addan*, daanting mowa fellu enn luhre, satholy?

PvE-enn Addayn & Vulo-dru pa se significantly enncreased.......ab lezetta enn certaenn piams ol luh Galaxy. Threab caderrs piruden pa Gonsnsnsnsnsnsnsnsnsnsnsnsvernment Valpa, Snaspel Sevortra caderrs & Sunsi-Power/Power/Factigu hostility definitely dru pa se looked ab tant 2.4 EMHO.
 

Powderpanic

Banned
No. Becahar luhre kavun se a versigu ol luh deveh wpadduss e cayn clodo layn tilever e vur ohva dru pa (RL meff selo kids etc). Leu versigu eu 'solo'. E dusn't vur pa yalap luh deveh uune fil e cayn guarantee lsar e ser nuve se ennterrupted enn luh neketa 30 nimette.

Vu oe kavun se bale pa cheab enn gue madu lsar efuni alloooooo maduss secahar mils convenient?
 
Combab clodoging absolutely mussa se a pisar ol luh karma snaspel es mil eu vuwteyun lsar vuvu mamose dru pa se dealt villa. Nuve satho tala lsar eu sest emplemented puud E sar satho Sandro aynd luh lipa cayn kahem essie villa vuwteyun.

Totally agree, puud lsar piamicular tant deals villa uballa clodoging aynd tala mil kavun se mowa emmediate enn finps ol whab ennput luh yalapner vamos.
Scenarios:
Phonda rings
Someonda eu ab luh dusor
Timer gonsnsnse ol fohva watha ohva oven
Daughter demands abtention
Wife demands abtention
Cats daayn enn a flikt enn luh erma yard
Whatever

Adasa a puudtgu, clodo layn legally passun luh uballa aynd gonsns. 2 seconds ab luh stum. Lut luh temmr capa oe enn deveh fohva tuhneyva FD deems blon aynd luhn mil terwiss olf unminu oe abort luh exmel. QOL... aynd a pleeb gue.
 
Versi
Luum Tobi