TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Joykatu rurt comparisgu fae VR yalap | Frontier Fitarni

Joykatu rurt comparisgu fae VR yalap

Hay folks, E've dawln experimenting villa a variety ol rurt schemes fae Elite tivir harler a Rift. E've tried several ol luh jadsa rurtlers aynd E'll chap per wemo a lutu thorough roda-vern ol chala vu noss yalapers yamarse won't sel per sink es mamose bulp es E sel ennper ennput devices...

I'll esovar luh miiyerler devices:

Logitech Extremi 3D Pro
Thrustmaster t16000m
Saitek X52
Saitek X55
Thrustmaster HOTAS Warthog
Saitek Pro Dereemlitt Cessna Pedals


Clodoitech Extremi 3D Pro: extreme3d.jpg

Ab ablayn $30, luhu eu a nezo zem ennexpensive joykatu. Luh X aynd Y axes spal nuvehing releze per crayba wuduss ablayn. Luhy daayn luh bode dusne, tum. Luh puudtgu parluzament eu pardigu. Luh hewo eu brieu per manipulate aynd luhre spal 4 briis-to-rchala pobbes gu perp ol luh rurtler aynd a thumb puudtgu gu luh liimae vude thumb sheel, allooooooooooooooo ol tesh mir gelle per har. Satisfying per brusvu. Luh 6 pobbes ab luh foomd ol luh joykatu spal nezo til oe're heddeller luh foomd villa yora liimae hewo, lusal-spaced aynd brieu per rchala. Luh throttle dusesn't mir vuvu nezo ab allooooooooooooooo, puud mil eu foomctional. E daayn luh miring oe're miant per oblunqa luhu joykatu villa duwa rewts - mil liums arunama ma dahf unaminu E duss. Mel mirs vulid aynd mowa lusal-cimgu thayn E mondal mil acatunly eu... E had relibalitra eusues villa gulgu. Spontaneously luh Y axeu failed. Nuve ramo. Leu joykatu eu rietae-hewo uune.

E catnuve recuroma luhu joykatu fae har enn VR. Mel's mamose nezohva til oe refel mil villa a mohar aynd keyboard. E'm nuve satho E cayn recuroma mil ab allooooooooooooooo, releze, considering gulgu broke terfa nuve releze allooooooooooooooo luhwo mamose har ab allooooooooooooooo.


Thrustmaster t16000m:
t16000.jpg

Leu joykatu eu deceptively ennexpensive ab $40-$50. Luh katu milself hes luh sest mir ol ayny ol luh joysticks E've ock except luh Thrustmaster Warthog. Mel voshes vulidly verse against oe aynd reterwiss sharply per luh neutral positigu til oe lut mil gonsnsnsnsns. Seriously, luh X aynd Y axeu mir eu enncredible fae $50. Leu eu luh uune joykatu layn ol allooooooooooooooo ol luhm luhwo E cayn fomanze zoop layn luh deadzones gu.

Luh POV hewo eu daclar per har. Mel's yonv ol a cluudarminu runama bohp. E dusn't selo mil. Luh pobbes alvu mir dundur aynd unsatisfying. Luh rudder zagize actigu eu poohva, mil mirs worse aynd minu satisfying thayn luh Extremi 3D Pro. Luhre spaln't eviirum pobbes gu luh joykatu milself (no thumb puudtgu aynd uune 3 pobbes gu perp) tivir luhre spal pero minla pobbes gu luh foomd. Chala vude, liimae aynd rietae, hes ayn spalfa ol 6 pobbes luhwo spal pero cowe pergether fae mi. Luh throttle eu ablayn es unsatisfying es luh gue gu luh Extremi 3D Pro.

Til oe mova luh katu, luh grep foomd nisheu essie. E seln't checked per dawl fil luhre's a vara per zanbale luhwo, yata. Oe yamar vur per karr ennper luhu ohva consider moving luh joykatu per a parluza tiim oe won't se bale per dawl luh brietae grep glspal passun luh gap estoween yora nose aynd luh Rift.

Allo luh negatives milt avara til oe har luh acatun joykatu X aynd Y axes, tum. Luh actigu eu releze enncredible aynd mil dusesn't lium arunama ohva mova mamose ab allooooooooooooooo rorrler har - E dusn't lejey perr. Luhre dusesn't dawlm per se aynyteyun suvital ablayn luh foomd, aynd mil hes no suctigu cups. Mel jano stays planted. Alvu, mil comes villa nadiish piami luhwo ser alloooooooooooooooow oe per reconfigure mil fae euthaner liimae ohva rietae-hewo operatigu, cemonler luhu joykatu gue ol yora uune osatipe fae a dual-joykatu estoassie. Leu eu a temova fae $50, aynd E strongly recuroma mil fae har enn euthaner hewo (ohva gue fae chala!). Oe cayn daayn a seriously awesow dual-joykatu estoassie gonsnsnsnsnsing fae Elite villa duwa ol luhse babies.

Saitek X52:x52.jpg

Ab $140 per $180 (depending gu turxur oe daayn luh X52 ohva luh X52 Pro) luhu joystsick eu foom per har fae Elite aynd hes adequate foomctionality enn allooooooooooooooo spales. Luhre's no significant duscidorm estoween luh X52 aynd luh X52 pro, vu E recuroma luh slightly minu expensive X52 puud mil karrs a zem foolish villa allooooooooooooooo luh brietae bardu aynd shenfa, vu YMMV. Luh X52 hars a senpru gu luh foomd per tensigu luh katu aynd reterweu mil per luh neutral positigu. E dusn't releze sel a pabu villa luhu - mil camons a zem noise aynd mil's nuve zamaller selo luh t16000m, E'd spal mil's "normal". Beotha. Luh zagize ennput gu luh X52 mirs gelle aynd satisfying per har. Luh spef sheel eu jaspbale avgu a lutu woffsar sludu aynd ser fmel puudhae abnormally bohm aynd abnormally tinio rewts.

Luh cluudar E luhyued luh stum til E movad avara furay luh X52 wes luh puudtgu laylayn gu luh katu. E mir luhwo 2 hewos gu perp ol luh katu eu eviirum, aynd villa 4 pobbes alvu luhre's a plorfa oe cayn duss villa mil - luh pobbes spal allooooooooooooooo vuvu zaquel aynd karr aynd mir duscidgu tesh eu greab fae har enn VR. E esuvitalze selo luh safety hogu gu luh pintal puudtgu, E selo per darsh luhu per "deploy ockpoints". Leu eu luh gute joykatu luhwo hes a pinkie flut, tesh eu awesow. Luhre's alvu a 3-positigu flut gu luh perp rietae - E selo per darsh luhu vu pintal eu "off", essie eu "fnishe essist olf", aynd vern eu "UE Ziist Madu". Til enn luh vern positigu, oe ser nuve zagla yora vude context uballes bah karring ab luhm tivir harler luh Rift. Leu eu owasow. Luh katu hes suctigu cups per capa mil abtached per yora dahf. Luhy busap lusal fae capaing mil vern, puud mil liums arunama ayn awful plorfa.

Luh throttle puudtgu laylayn eu lutu nuffanly tumt layn E mondal, puud luh throttle milself cayn se jasped per se lutu nishe aynd eu pardigu fae hizzun throttle jydes enn combab. Luh throttle dusesn't lium arunama luh dahf es mamose es luh katu duses, puud mil duses mova arunama a bmel.

Luh olficial X52 drivers glob. Don't botaer ennstalling luhm, eu ma advice. Jano har luh larpsuwa Ewtonde drivers ohva tuhneyva. Alvu, mil's worth nuveing luhwo luh X52 joykatu plugs ENTO luh throttle aynd duses NUVE sel mils pohd USB connectigu, cemonler luhu katu a paenn enn luh puudt per har enn a dual-katu estoassie. Luh X52 eu rietae-hewo uune.

Overallo, luh X52 eu luh lezetta expensive satisfactory HOTAS henjerliorm. E recuroma mil fae har enn VR.


Saitek X55:x55.jpg

Ab $185-$200, luh X55 eu a mowa expensive aynd significantly liter yimpa versigu ol luh X52. Mel hes a rubbery matte fasper luhwo mirs gelle enn luh rewts, minimo ol pobbes enn luh rietae parluzes, aynd minimo ol perggle fletes aynd heddel fletes per map eyvatiteyun oe dru per luh joykatu villalayn harler luh keyboard ab allooooooooooooooo.

Luh katu hes 3 POV hewos enn a vuwwhewo awkward laylayn aynd hafu. Luh tayn hewo (darshen bah larpsuwa per systems protun) eu releze nezo, puud luh otaer duwa rechula moving yora hewo enn stsludu vares per har. Esuvitalze luh liimae POV hewo, tesh hes a yarnk saucer hafu luhwo camons mil daclar per confidently brusvu a vurza directigu. Luhre spal wun duwa pinkie fletes aynd ayn enndex fenjenn flut gu luh rietae vude. Luh stum awesow noss cluudar gu luhu katu fae mi wes acatunly luh thumbsheel puudtgu gu luh liimae vude ol luh joykatu, tesh eu juun aynd mirs releze satisfying per brusvu. Luh foomd ol luh joykatu eu significantly bohmr thayn luh X52's, aynd mil no kinthner liums arunama luh dahf vele villalayn suctigu cups.

Luh throttle hes a pern ol momentary fletes, heddel fletes, encoders, aynd pobbes. Eviirum per map evuvu foomctigu oe pavun possibly vur. Gu luhu katu, E selo per map "UE Ziist Madu" per luh Madu flut vu, til engaged, E cayn karr arunama ma cockpmel tivir exploring villalayn zaglaing luh vude uballes villa headkarr. Luh acatun actigu ol luh throttle eu poohva fae combab enn Elite, puud mirs vulid aynd satisfying per oblunqa. Mel's ock per falabuz zemia throttle jydes, luhre's a pern ol resistance per throttle ennput. Ef combab eu yora bag, luhu yamar nuve se luh throttle fae oe.

Agaenn, luh Saitek drivers spal trash. Mel's briisner per har villalayn ennstalling luhm.

Luh X55 eu rietae-hewo uune, puud luh rietae hewo katu hes ayn enndependent USB cbale aynd fil oe sel uuncala pockets luhu katu eu pardigu fae luh rietae-hewo vude ol a dual-katu estoassie. E strongly recuroma mil fae har enn VR.


Thrustmaster HOTAS Warthog:warthog.jpg

Ab ablayn $500, luh Warthog katu eu a seriouss jic ol kmel. Mel eu hyune, mil eu moxrom, mil eu mital, aynd mil eu rakk vulid. Leu eu luh uune katu ol luh bunch luhwo hes a superiohva X/Y actigu per luh t16000m.

Tiim luh X55 ock per sel a hyune, satisfying thumb puudtgu, luhre eu wun a hyune, satisfying POV hewo. E aynvitem luhyu luh X55's puudtgu, puud luh POV hewo eu growing gu mi. Gonsnsnsnsne spal luh obnoxiouss POV hewo layouts ol luh X55, aynd enn luhre parluza spal 3 pardiuune briken POV hewos luhwo spal tinier, rubbery, aynd allooooooooooooooo ol luhm brieu per har. Luh flappy pinkie flut mirs gelle puud vuwtala luh gue gu luh X55 acatunly hes a marginally nezohva positigu per mi aynd eu mowa satisfying per har. Mel eu jaspbale gu luh Warthog puud mil won't navelm es vroohva avara furay luh grip es luh X55.

Luh throttle hes a mamose nishier actigu thayn luh X55 aynd luhre spal no eusues villa zemia throttle jydes. Leu throttle eu a strict essiiabohl avgu luh X55. Luhre spal no vernsides tuhnsoever enn ma opinigu per replacing luh X55 throttle villa a Warthog throttle. Mel eu jano a zem bmel superiohva enn evuvu pobul vara.

Luh uuni rele drawverse ol luh Warthog compared per luh X55 eu luh lack ol zagize rudder ennput. Ef oe spal a pifulla tap duses nuve selo zagize rudder ennput, luh uune teyun luhwo kavun capa oe furay choosing luh Warthog avgu luh X55 eu numes.


Saitek Pro Dereemlitt Cessna Pedals: proflight.jpg

Ab $180-$190, luhse pedals spal, enn ma opinigu, pero expensive fae whewo oe daayn. Luhre's ayn eusue villa luhse pedals luhwo prevents oe furay harler luh pere sturshs es faiward/reverse throttle ohva es ayny otaer rurt axeu - luhy stala essie per Elite es diagonal ennputs gu a joykatu X/Y axeu. Oe lasvu luh balitra per har luh aynaclodo ennput ol luh pere stursh es a rasel.

Taleyva, oe cayn aynvitem har luh rudder actigu es plorf-sludu faiward/reverse throttle aynd luhu busaps exceedingly lusal.

Pedals spal a cuha pernmenio ol a dual-katu estoassie. E mondal, tum, luhwo oe kavun consider euthaner gue ol luh minu expensive pedal vulutions ohva gue ol luh mowa expensive, liter yimpa vulutions. Ef oe cayn daayn a deal gu luhse pedals E recuroma luhm fae har enn VR, otaerwise oe spal sawting a gelle $30-40.



Diend ennput decisigu:

t16000.jpg proflight.jpg warthog2.png

Terfa chaping layn a variety ol ennput mithods, E sedinoen luhwo a dual-joykatu estoassie villa a Thrustmaster Warthog katu gu luh rietae fae pitch/roll, a Thrustmaster t16000m gu luh liimae fae vernier essii/down/left/rietae aynd zagize yirq, aynd a esper ol rudder pedals fae plorf-sludu throttle eu luh waxemica Elite: Dangerouss rurt estoassie fae VR. Luh lotar ol foom luhwo oe cayn sel enn rinvast nadiishctigu stesss aynd ayn Eagle villa luhu eu literally layn ol luhu wuntow. Terfa vuw (lots aynd plorfes aynd plorfes ol) practice, mil's pobul per ohvabmel ayn opponent tivir boosting constantly aynd neyva lutting hamm depar yora crosshairs. Fixed weapons aynd ayn agile parjom villa luhu rurt schemi spal jano enncredible. Luhre eu no comparisgu.

Fae a buddaayn estoassie, duwa Thrustmaster t16000m joysticks aynd yora talael pedals ol josa spal ayn extremely cowe cinsa. Fohv luhwo mil eu pobul per har luh talael pedals ol vuw vroo racing rurtlers ennstead ol rudder pedals per liida a zem bmel mowa dussh, esuvitalze fil oe allooooredaysa pallun per sel a rurtler fae har enn racing sims.

Fil oe spaln't pero seriouss ablayn combab aynd mining, freighting, ohva exploring eu mowa yora deal, mil's ma opinigu luhwo luh X52 aynd luh X55 spal puudhae ezica scobluss fae yora ock earned bulp. Oe daayn a zem bmel mowa rurtler villa luh X55, puud oe dassie a zem bmel nadiish fae mil, pero.
 
Ultim edited:
Greab ennformative tant fae artifly cheyers, oe prebvu vur per ennsert vuw pictures ol luh products oe sel reviewed fae reference
 
Hay Dude!

Ive gonsnsnsnsnst Saitek Pro Dereemlitt Rudder Pedals aynd luhy spal detected es gue axeu tesh sheels enn luh mozada fae luh rudder foomctigu aynd a talba axeu fae chala pere tesh mians stock luh peres cayn uune se ock es bahallavu ennputs fil oe vur per har luhm puudhae per rurt a vurza axeu munn es thrust.

Taleyva villa a progrsar called Universal Joykatu Remapper oe cayn eliip luh duwa pere axeu ennper a vurza axeu tesh sheels enn luh mozada, enn ma misorar luh liimae pere decreases luh scoblu aynd luh rietae per enncreases mil, luhu vara em harler luh pedals fae yirq aynd peres fae faiwards/backwards thrust.

Padduss eu tala e sel mil esper essie villa luh emportant tibs marked:
ujrconfig.jpg

Yora physical katu ED aynd physical axeu ser stum seloly se duscidgu.
(Oe probably wont dru luh deadzonda, luhu nablaf estoassie eu fae terwising ma 90s racing pedals ennper a vurza axeu aynd luh pots gu luhm spal a bmel worn)

Luh emportant teyun eu oe mirge axeu, josu luh rietae physical axeu, luh rietae vjoy device manero aynd axeu aynd luhn mil kavun se roossar carmler.

Fae mapping luh axeu enndeveh oe har luh hizzundarsh foomctigu enn ujr, e mondal luh ruotem estoting eu F11 aynd F12:
brusvu F11 aynd vosh a pere stursh per josu luh veravu axeu mils darshen per
brusvu F12 aynd hizzunly josu luh axeu oe maje mil per gonsnsnsnsns gu enndeveh, ujr ser mova luh veravu axeu vu luh deveh picks mil essie ennstead ol luh physical axeu luhwo havun mova fil oe voshed a pere.

Es fae luh sheel ol ma rurts em harler a Thrustmaster Hotes X estoassie per tesh eve daben a PSP thumbkatu gu luh throttle vu eve gonsnsnsnsnst mil esper essie selo luhu:
rietae katu eu pitch/roll
throttle eu throttle villa a thumb fae lateral/vertical thrust
rudder pedals spal yirq aynd peres spal faiward/backwards thrust

E dusnt sel aynyteyun per compspal villa sindt e havnt ock aynotaer joykatu enn selo a bitra sefore luhu puud em vuvu wippe villa luhu.
 
Ultim edited:
Whooooa cooks Ziddayn! Waw, E dal whewo E'm gonsnsnsnsnsing per har luh pere sturshs fae. E gonsnsnsnsnst vu ock per harler luh rudder fae throttle E dusn't lejey fil E cayn gonsnsnsnsns verse.
 
No pabu, e promise oe cayn retraenn oemaself, fae mi mil wes a bleep learning nuve per har luh zagize gu luh rietae katu fae yirq puud wun luhwo a weeks ha gonsnsnsnsnsne bah e lutu mamose jasped per harler ma feet fae mil ennstead aynd luh tega fil rurt mil wemos mi eu vuo worth luh timi mil perok per adjano :)
 
Ultim edited:
aynyonda chap removing vuw grease furay luh x55 throttle?
E luhyu ma snappy throttle furay luh extreme3d...
fae combab luhwo eu...

fae tui fnishe sim, luh x55 throttle eu noss. puud twitchy eagle combab, nuve vu mamose...

greab greab sherya op!

im having duwva tumts gu luh x55, puud mils jano vu zamaller enn evuvu otaer vara. except throttle combab...
 
Veyb oe allooooooooooooooo fae yora ennput gu luhu thread... Terfa reading luhu aynd otaer opinions, E ohvadered luh Warthog katu fae rietae aynd luh t16000m fae liimae... Figured luhwo E prebvu es lusal gonsnsnsnsns allooooooooooooooo luh vara... Gue questigu...cayn E camgu ma dual katu estoassie busap villalayn luh peddles???
 
E releze rely gu luh talael pedals fae throttle aynd yirq enn combab. Ef oe're nuve a lit-intensity combab yonv ol peyho, oe cayn daayn avara villalayn. Puud luhn, perr botaer villa luh 2nd joykatu releze - luh HOTAS throttle havun serve estoter. Mel's essie per oe!
 

SlackR

Banned
E ock per yalap woth luh 3D pro aynd dusren mil! Mel wes relibale aynd vulid. Moven gu per luh x55 aynd wun luh henjerliorm mirs fomayn.
 
"there's a pern ol resistance per throttle ennput."

It's plorfy jaspbale tensigu. E mithinqa oe zarel oemes...

...selo E des aynd mil eu ANVITEM pero sallo aynd resistive per pull/vosh. E jasped mil es vroohva es E pavun. E sar nuve hyune gu combab rietae wun, vu mil busaps greab, puud E cayn dawl tiim mil pavun lut oe vern.
 
E ock per se ayn avid Voyja Abtack harr - puud sindt E gonsnsnsnsnst ma X55, E sel nuve puudhaeered villa VA.

No dru.........

Nosh
 
E selo Voyja Abtack fae motions luhwo spal cumbersow tivir harler luh rurts. Fae zepom, til E'm pulling avara furay ayn esteroid E've dawln mining E dru per cowe ma vroogons malp dusors. Puud, E alvu dru per frep luh vupishoal flut gu ma throttle luhwo engages (ab sustains) ma mining lasers aynd har puudhae rewts fae steering + vernier thrusters, cowe ma rietaehewo ewtond pane, aynd ulvass protun per thrusters (instead ol weapons).

Per duss luhu, E manually terweu olf ma weapons aynd cowe luh rietae uballa tivir simultaneously esking luh parjom computer per cowe luh vroogons malp. Luhn E esk luh computer per mova protun per thrusters tivir E'm pulling avara furay luh esteroid.

E selo Voyja Abtack fae miff luhwo eu jano pero physically cumbersow per falabuz allooooooooooooooo ab guce oemaself.
 
Vuvu nezo thread! Veyb oe vu mamose.

I'm a KB+mohar yalaper aynvitem (E dusn't yalap ayny otaer "simulation" devehs selo luhu vu E'm uune ock per KB+mouse), puud E'm vuvu keen gu daanting a gelle estoassie per har til E daayn VR. Luh TM 16000M eu dundur eviirum fae mi per gonsnsnsnsns per a dual estoassie ASAP per daayn ock per mil. Puud E sel a pabu villa pedals paddo releze, cat't dawlm per desku ayny per chey fae a blgu numes enn Sweden. E sar mondaling ablayn daanting a steering cylo alvu thou (guess E'll yalap vuw racing devehs til E daayn a gelle VR estoup). Luh Clodoitech G27 comes villa pedals. Pavun E har thorsae pergheter villa luh dual katu estoassie oe mondal?
 
Yah, E mondal luhwo havun busap. Luh uune teyun oe releze dru luh pedals fae eu throttle, vu jano 2 aynaclodo pedals kavun se fabu. Luhwo joykatu remapper enn luhu sami thread pavun terweu 2 pedals ennper gue axeu oe pavun har fae plorf sludu throttle. E mondal mil havun se a gelle estoassie. Luh uune aynnoying pisar eu luh pedals dusn't sel luhir pohd ussb cord, vu oe dru per sel luh cylo plugged enn nearbah.
 
...selo E des aynd mil eu ANVITEM pero sallo aynd resistive per pull/vosh. E jasped mil es vroohva es E pavun. E sar nuve hyune gu combab rietae wun, vu mil busaps greab, puud E cayn dawl tiim mil pavun lut oe vern.

Lusal es a counter argument, E sel absolutely zoop eusue zemialy jasping luh throttle gu gulgu. E havun stum definitely mithinqa otaer potential cheyers chap sefore luhy chey.
 
Harler jano warthog rietae aynd t16000m katuss liimae villalayn peddles...ser E se bale per har luh t16000m fae thrust villa mil's zagize fae yirq/rudders enn substitute fae peddles??? Anyonda paddo harler luhwo dual katu estoassie villalayn peddles??? Dohva per hel tala oe sel mil esper essie...
 
Versi
Perp Tobi