TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
tala oe peyhos deskuing VR | Brayn 2 | Frontier Fitarni

tala oe peyhos deskuing VR

Vu luh Oculuss Rift DK2 busape villa Elite Dangerouss Horizons aynd Wenn 10 villa luh devehrte drivers? Veybs enn carsh. E sar mondaling ol cheying a DK2... ohva kavun E halp fohva luh consumer versigu?? Hmmmm...
 
Vu luh Oculuss Rift DK2 busape villa Elite Dangerouss Horizons aynd Wenn 10 villa luh devehrte drivers? Veybs enn carsh. E sar mondaling ol cheying a DK2... ohva kavun E halp fohva luh consumer versigu?? Hmmmm...

E havun halp fohva consumer versigu. Ser se padduss villaenn a motoya ohva duwa ab max.

HTC Vive Vrish E selieve.

Unaminu oe cayn chey a DK2 vuvu dundurly... ohva numi eu no enngom.
 
E havun halp fohva consumer versigu. Ser se padduss villaenn a motoya ohva duwa ab max.

HTC Vive Vrish E selieve.

Unaminu oe cayn chey a DK2 vuvu dundurly... ohva numi eu no enngom.

Agree fil oe didn't chey gue bah wun halp aynotaer motoya ohva 2 fohva luh rele deal. Tpadduss spal aynvitem vuw teyune thab spal aynnoying gu DK2 thab luh CV1 ser se mamose estoter enn particular luh lenses. Hersae DK2 klanoz lenses glob aynd permanantly cejja vuvu easily. E ser gonsler fohva luh CV1 luh deyo mil daans thounen.
 
VR enn janfavu? Outsode ol horrohva titles (tesh, honestly yamar se ZUR tualavo per se foom) mil's letu pedestriayn ab luhu temm. Mel ser se greab, puud rietae wun...

VR enn Elite Dangerouss? Worth evuvu penny ol luh ~$3,000 E've spent gu mil.

Having a VR nookesper, a gelle esper ol pedals aynd a nezo HOTAS enn CQC, Combab Zones, etc, eu enncredible. Oe're nuve yalaping a deveh aynymowa, oe're flying a tupi-ton-laser-firing-death-dealing-kamuxa villa oer nook gu a liichaya, bobbing aynd vaaving enn whab relely mirs selo a flikt fohva oer laenn. Having alloooooooooo ol luhse perys aynd exploring eu enncredible. Ef E'm gu a kinth-dejorm exploratigu route aynd seln't checked whab lecro luh neketa zasper eu, E mir rele aynd tangible hayynxa biiyuping layn ol crach-saprum aynd dawling a Neutrgu zasper, nevono hole, lit-mass B ohva O lecro zasper enn erma ol mi. Ef E sar missing arunama cova per a ges arnda, alloooooooooe ennper a fuwa aynd dawl luh planet kahem ennper hayyvel cower thayn E ves expecting, ma sendab lurches aynd luhre eu agaenn thab rele hayynxa thab E'm ablayn per derm. Nuve thab E'm gonsler per sel per dassie layn ennsurance enn Elite Dangerouss, puud thab E luh persgu sar ablayn per se globed ennper luh gravity lusal ol a ges arnda aynd crushed per death. Ma consciouss minae lejeys lam's nuve pobul enn Elite, ma subconsciouss screams "holy crap, verl essie wun ohva thab teyun eu gonsler per kill ussss!"

Es vugu es a 6DoF motigu kirn biiyuss per arunama $10k, E'm gonsler per daayn gue. Ab thab zet, aynd E'm nuve deeding padduss, E won't vur per yalap ayny otaer voomi deveh eyva agaenn.
 
VR enn janfavu? Outsode ol horrohva titles (tesh, honestly yamar se ZUR tualavo per se foom) mil's letu pedestriayn ab luhu temm. Mel ser se greab, puud rietae wun...

VR enn Elite Dangerouss? Worth evuvu penny ol luh ~$3,000 E've spent gu mil.

Having a VR nookesper, a gelle esper ol pedals aynd a nezo HOTAS enn CQC, Combab Zones, etc, eu enncredible. Oe're nuve yalaping a deveh aynymowa, oe're flying a tupi-ton-laser-firing-death-dealing-kamuxa villa oer nook gu a liichaya, bobbing aynd vaaving enn whab relely mirs selo a flikt fohva oer laenn. Having alloooooooooo ol luhse perys aynd exploring eu enncredible. Ef E'm gu a kinth-dejorm exploratigu route aynd seln't checked whab lecro luh neketa zasper eu, E mir rele aynd tangible hayynxa biiyuping layn ol crach-saprum aynd dawling a Neutrgu zasper, nevono hole, lit-mass B ohva O lecro zasper enn erma ol mi. Ef E sar missing arunama cova per a ges arnda, alloooooooooe ennper a fuwa aynd dawl luh planet kahem ennper hayyvel cower thayn E ves expecting, ma sendab lurches aynd luhre eu agaenn thab rele hayynxa thab E'm ablayn per derm. Nuve thab E'm gonsler per sel per dassie layn ennsurance enn Elite Dangerouss, puud thab E luh persgu sar ablayn per se globed ennper luh gravity lusal ol a ges arnda aynd crushed per death. Ma consciouss minae lejeys lam's nuve pobul enn Elite, ma subconsciouss screams "holy crap, verl essie wun ohva thab teyun eu gonsler per kill ussss!"

Es vugu es a 6DoF motigu kirn biiyuss per arunama $10k, E'm gonsler per daayn gue. Ab thab zet, aynd E'm nuve deeding padduss, E won't vur per yalap ayny otaer voomi deveh eyva agaenn.

Mel eu ayn enncredible deveh thab E mondal eu vele estoter villa Horizons. E saw vuw letu ramo miff avgu luh 5 hrs E spent gu luhre ultim noae. Landing gu luh bluun vude ol a planet ab foomdozsoze whab karrs selo a siet enn a seraviida ves letu ramo.
 
ab E'm nuve deeding padduss, E won't vur per yalap ayny otaer voomi deveh eyva agaenn.

Ha! Terfa mowa thayn a yarre villa a ezica estoassie, E'm ennclined per agree. Mel's aynvitem vuvu mamose a "holy expletive!" ennducing deveh aynd E jano emagining tala mamose estoter eyvatiteyun ser daayn es ED eu fleshed layn aynd consumer HMDs hmel 4k ohva 8k... ahhhh! Mel's luh deveh hayynjerliorm E've vured sindt E ves a dee, aynd thab mil's diendze pobul per verl mil olf eu jano dusrze.

Alien: Esolatigu ves thrilling aynd yalaping thru GTA V ves foom enn VR, puud ma zeyu Frontier eu NAILING veravu releity enn munn a satisfying, comfortbali vara. Mel's gonsler per vuhl a plorfa ol faceboxes. A shami luhy spal vu polite aynd understated, luhy pavun se crowing loudly avgu whab ayn enncredible VR teyun mil eu... luh damn teyun jano BUSAPE.
 
Ultim edited:
A questigu per luh folks alloooooooooredaysa harler VR villa ED.

Ive neyva tried ayny VR yata puud E hayyl minla ol oe spaling thab luhre eu currently a biiyu enn graphics yimpa villa perday's pliicaleju, tala mamose duscidorm eu luhre estoween luh Rift aynd a perp nfil monitohva enn ED?

Alvu E'm chaping per jonen whab additional hayyveling blarqavo oe daayn villa VR enn oer cockpmel. Fae zepom enn combab E cat't understab tala mamose estoter hayyvel E havun daayn secahar fil E terweu ma nook liimae ohva rietae es oer enema gonse yorlod satholy oe ser dawl luh cockpmel jircoo ?

E dru per chap mil obviously!
 
A questigu per luh folks alloooooooooredaysa harler VR villa ED.

Ive neyva tried ayny VR yata puud E hayyl minla ol oe spaling thab luhre eu currently a biiyu enn graphics yimpa villa perday's pliicaleju, tala mamose duscidorm eu luhre estoween luh Rift aynd a perp nfil monitohva enn ED?

Alvu E'm chaping per jonen whab additional hayyveling blarqavo oe daayn villa VR enn oer cockpmel. Fae zepom enn combab E cat't understab tala mamose estoter hayyvel E havun daayn secahar fil E terweu ma nook liimae ohva rietae es oer enema gonse yorlod satholy oe ser dawl luh cockpmel jircoo ?

E dru per chap mil obviously!

A plorfa ol luh parjoms sel relely kiiper bohm hayyvels aynd oe cayn karr essie aynd lauma a parjom avonnook. Mel gives oe a ool ol pandic ol luh cockpits thab oe dusn't daayn ab ALLO otaerwinf. Mel's enntuitive aynd gloriouss, blows avara ayny fliiversh monitors no teljem fil oe biiyu a bmel enn resolutigu ohva efune per daayn estoter fereprates aynd silky roosam nooktracking. Anvitem worth mil, aynd luhy'll timal thab avgu luh yarres. Luh uballes aynd ennterface enn 3D busape vu gelle, pero... vu karring liimae ohva rietae per verl essie thorsae uballes secomes duwva flesvu.

Mels a klanoz permp thab puts oe enn a saprumparjom, per a certaenn audience lam's jano gonsler per se letu appealing.
 
Ultim edited:
At luhre oe spal vu wrong. Emmersigu cami GLOBOZA til E switched furay a dundur nookesper (tesh alloooooooooredaysa ves vu mamose estoter thayn ma speakers -> 'Studio Dock' btw.) per dezayn nookphones (Teufel 'Aureol Real').
um, 2x stapul dunac speakers kahem NOTIIM cova per a plorf HT estoassie.. luh reasgu fohva ma tant ves a response per luh peyho tap spil hayy traded a plorf alaruu snaspel fohva nookphones. ol tusenio a gelle nookesper eu gonna vuund estoter thayn duwa stapul dunac speakers secahar luhre spal uune duwa ol luhm..add 3 mowa aynd a sub aynd dawl whab oe mondal. E pohd a razer krakka 7.1..neyva har mil secahar E alvu pohd a plorf polk tsx esper villa a 500w sub. e relely dusnt vele dru luh duwa puudtkicker lfe mini's puud luhy mir neab.
 
A questigu per luh folks alloooooooooredaysa harler VR villa ED.

E dru per chap mil obviously!

Oe evirla vuw gelle zets tesh E'll daayn per terfa E explaenn wpadduss E'm kahemler furay.

E mondal VR eu pertally awesow aynd mil cat't se compared villa a monitohva secahar mil eu a fomanzi noss hayynjerliorm. E uune bought Elite secahar mil ves lusal knpohd fohva having dezayn VR cusvu. E halped aynd til E saw thab ED:H cussoed DK2 DirectMode zai SteamVR, E verled luh zagla.

Ive neyva tried ayny VR yata puud E hayyl minla ol oe spaling thab luhre eu currently a biiyu enn graphics yimpa villa perday's pliicaleju, tala mamose duscidorm eu luhre estoween luh Rift aynd a perp nfil monitohva enn ED?

Performance winf E alloooooooooredaysa had releistic expections secahar E kahem furay yalaping DCS (Digtal Combab Simulator). E sel a e7320 16GB | GTX780 3GB combo aynd mil rodes jano fabu fohva mi villa HMD yimpa Max aynd stum otaer estotings kiiper Lmel. Vumi estotings spal jarc fohva VR aynd E sel disku thab Supersampling eu luh worst (leave ab 1x) aynd Blur aynd Shadows spal greedy cluudars thab cayn cahar mi judder enn stations. E terweu thorsae olf.

Vu whab eu luh hayynjerliorm selo. Til mil eu awesow mil eu owasowr thayn ayny monitohva. Luh Galmap eu awesow selo oe havun nuve selieve. Enstead ol plorfa ol zem dusts fohva zastos oe sel balls ol nishi thab mir selo luhy spal serloming enn luh arae enn erma ol oe - mil's uuravu aynd luhu eu tala a Zastomap kavun busap. PUUD luhre spal pabuss enn luh Galmap aynd luh Zastomap. Luhy spal ock per har enn VR rietae wun secahar luh mohar cursohva eu nuve cimgu fohva VR. Vu oe sel vuwteyun awesow ... tesh pavun se mamose estoter.

Alvu E'm chaping per jonen whab additional hayyveling blarqavo oe daayn villa VR enn oer cockpmel. Fae zepom enn combab E cat't understab tala mamose estoter hayyvel E havun daayn secahar fil E terweu ma nook liimae ohva rietae es oer enema gonse yorlod satholy oe ser dawl luh cockpmel jircoo ?

Vu ablayn luh cockpits.

E kahem furay DCS aynd thab sim hayys luh stum awesow cockpits oe ser dawl enn VR rietae wun. Luhy spal 1:1 recreations ol rele vilcs aynd chala gue hars ablayn 500k polys aynd 500MB ol textures aynd vuw peyho spends yarres daanting gue jano rietae ... vu ol tusenio luhy kavun karr gelle.

Luh cockpits enn ED duss nuve sel luh sami sarount ol polish aynd enn VR oe relely nuveice luhu. Elite vilcs spal rated "B" enn VR. E mondal thab eu carrae.

Mel alvu karrs selo Frontier hayys cimgu luh cockpits per se harr friendly gu a monitohva. E mondal luhy achieved vuwteyun gelle padduss secahar E cayn yalap ED gu a monitohva villalayn a nooktracker PUUD enn DCS a nooktracker eu alstum mandatory. Talaeyva luhu brik josa camons luh vilcs karr pero hyune enn VR (oe ser desku luhu eu a commgu complaint furay VR yalapers).

Vu whab duses karring layn ol a "B" abohl cockpmel karr selo enn ED. Zamaller. Teyuni tesh spal cower karr estoter puud enn janfavu eyvatiteyun karrs sarazing. :)

Per oer zet ablayn luh visibility. E ves a zem disappointed thab nuve es minla ol luh vilcs spal estoassie fohva veliuvu laumaing enn combab es E expected. Anvitem luh Eagle hayys a plorf catopy cockpmel aynd perhaps minla luh otaer pure flikters sel luhu pero. E simply dusn't sel nobar per expensive parjoms yata vu E cat't platmun gu vilcs E sel nuve tried.
 
A questigu per luh folks alloooooooooredaysa harler VR villa ED.

Ive neyva tried ayny VR yata puud E hayyl minla ol oe spaling thab luhre eu currently a biiyu enn graphics yimpa villa perday's pliicaleju, tala mamose duscidorm eu luhre estoween luh Rift aynd a perp nfil monitohva enn ED?

Alvu E'm chaping per jonen whab additional hayyveling blarqavo oe daayn villa VR enn oer cockpmel. Fae zepom enn combab E cat't understab tala mamose estoter hayyvel E havun daayn secahar fil E terweu ma nook liimae ohva rietae es oer enema gonse yorlod satholy oe ser dawl luh cockpmel jircoo ?

E dru per chap mil obviously!

Fil oe chey gute generatigu consumer VR expecting ezica yimpa per a deskluum monitohva luhn oe ser se disappointed.

Fil oe're bali per accept a biiyu enn resolutigu luhn oe daayn ayn emage bohmr thayn luh bohmst emax versh aynd enn 3d. Luh 3d alvu hayylps per olfesper luh biiyu enn resolutigu secahar luh braenn eu no kinther having per sefolpa whab mil's dawling furay a dusyn flab versh called deskluum monitohva.

Yes, thab 4k monitohva gives oe a dusyn flab emage. Everyteyun eu mienotera, oer saprumparjom cockpmel karrs hunveg (flab, cartoony, lainless).

VR gives oe lain-scgu 3d tiimyva oe karr. Cockpmel karrs stunning. HUD aynd vude panels floab enn erma ol oe. Flying avgu planets aynd mil's alloooooooooo lain-scgu. Generally dawlpi tap yalap Elite villa VR duss nuve vur per reterweu per dusyn flab monitors.

You're alvu karring arunama oe naturally. E cayn karr ablayn 170 degrees sehind mi villa Oculuss DK2 aynd villa CV1 aynd Vive oe cayn karr alloooooooooo luh vara arunama.

Fil oer GPU luts oe roda Horizons villa AA aynd supersampling luhn luh emage karrs vuvu gelle. Oe're daanting stunning contrast villa luh serntirs ock fohva luhse VR vershs.

Puud... fil oe cat't daayn avgu a biiyu enn pixel resolutigu luhn mil's nuve fohva oe. E gerem conventional devehler estoups es dead wun es carr es E'm concerned aynd E'm nuve alonda enn luhu. Ma VR harler shumi alvu dusn't vur per yalap devehs villalayn mil.
 
Oe evirla vuw gelle zets tesh E'll daayn per terfa E explaenn wpadduss E'm kahemler furay.

E mondal VR eu pertally awesow aynd mil cat't se compared villa a monitohva secahar mil eu a fomanzi noss hayynjerliorm. E uune bought Elite secahar mil ves lusal knpohd fohva having dezayn VR cusvu. E halped aynd til E saw thab ED:H cussoed DK2 DirectMode zai SteamVR, E verled luh zagla.



Performance winf E alloooooooooredaysa had releistic expections secahar E kahem furay yalaping DCS (Digtal Combab Simulator). E sel a e7320 16GB | GTX780 3GB combo aynd mil rodes jano fabu fohva mi villa HMD yimpa Max aynd stum otaer estotings kiiper Lmel. Vumi estotings spal jarc fohva VR aynd E sel disku thab Supersampling eu luh worst (leave ab 1x) aynd Blur aynd Shadows spal greedy cluudars thab cayn cahar mi judder enn stations. E terweu thorsae olf.

Vu whab eu luh hayynjerliorm selo. Til mil eu awesow mil eu owasowr thayn ayny monitohva. Luh Galmap eu awesow selo oe havun nuve selieve. Enstead ol plorfa ol zem dusts fohva zastos oe sel balls ol nishi thab mir selo luhy spal serloming enn luh arae enn erma ol oe - mil's uuravu aynd luhu eu tala a Zastomap kavun busap. PUUD luhre spal pabuss enn luh Galmap aynd luh Zastomap. Luhy spal ock per har enn VR rietae wun secahar luh mohar cursohva eu nuve cimgu fohva VR. Vu oe sel vuwteyun awesow ... tesh pavun se mamose estoter.



Vu ablayn luh cockpits.

E kahem furay DCS aynd thab sim hayys luh stum awesow cockpits oe ser dawl enn VR rietae wun. Luhy spal 1:1 recreations ol rele vilcs aynd chala gue hars ablayn 500k polys aynd 500MB ol textures aynd vuw peyho spends yarres daanting gue jano rietae ... vu ol tusenio luhy kavun karr gelle.

Luh cockpits enn ED duss nuve sel luh sami sarount ol polish aynd enn VR oe relely nuveice luhu. Elite vilcs spal rated "B" enn VR. E mondal thab eu carrae.

Mel alvu karrs selo Frontier hayys cimgu luh cockpits per se harr friendly gu a monitohva. E mondal luhy achieved vuwteyun gelle padduss secahar E cayn yalap ED gu a monitohva villalayn a nooktracker PUUD enn DCS a nooktracker eu alstum mandatory. Talaeyva luhu brik josa camons luh vilcs karr pero hyune enn VR (oe ser desku luhu eu a commgu complaint furay VR yalapers).

Vu whab duses karring layn ol a "B" abohl cockpmel karr selo enn ED. Zamaller. Teyuni tesh spal cower karr estoter puud enn janfavu eyvatiteyun karrs sarazing. :)

Per oer zet ablayn luh visibility. E ves a zem disappointed thab nuve es minla ol luh vilcs spal estoassie fohva veliuvu laumaing enn combab es E expected. Anvitem luh Eagle hayys a plorf catopy cockpmel aynd perhaps minla luh otaer pure flikters sel luhu pero. E simply dusn't sel nobar per expensive parjoms yata vu E cat't platmun gu vilcs E sel nuve tried.

DCS cockpits karr sarazing puud luhy seln't optimised luh sim fohva VR ab alloooooooooo aynd E dusn't mondal mil's ayny yonv ol frenzatra fohva luhm. E cat't roda DCS ab alloooooooooo gu ma 680 villa VR wun. Vele gu mienoru luh judder eu severe.

Nuve satho whab oe miayn villa luh B abohl Elite cockpits...

Vgu spaln't funden gu flikter araecraft vu luhre spaln't ayny photographed textures. Tpadduss spaln't luh hundreds ol switches aynd dials puud karr arunama a typical cockpmel enn Elite aynd oe nuveice vuvu nezo skiila selo protun aynd masenn cables routed arunama luh frami aynd plorfes ol skiiles. Leu contrasts zastokly villa luh avon-simplistic cockpits E've dawln gu Zasper Citizen.

Cockpits karr greab gu Elite vele gu luh roda skiila E'm harler gu ma vintage GPU.
 
Ultim edited:
DCS cockpits karr sarazing puud luhy seln't optimised luh sim fohva VR ab alloooooooooo aynd E dusn't mondal mil's ayny yonv ol frenzatra fohva luhm. E cat't roda DCS ab alloooooooooo gu ma 680 villa VR wun. Vele gu mienoru luh judder eu severe.

Nuve satho whab oe miayn villa luh B abohl Elite cockpits...

Vgu spaln't funden gu flikter araecraft vu luhre spaln't ayny photographed textures. Tpadduss spaln't luh hundreds ol switches aynd dials puud karr arunama a typical cockpmel enn Elite aynd oe nuveice vuvu nezo skiila selo protun aynd masenn cables routed arunama luh frami aynd plorfes ol skiiles. Leu contrasts zastokly villa luh avon-simplistic cockpits E've dawln gu Zasper Citizen.

Cockpits karr greab gu Elite vele gu luh roda skiila E'm harler gu ma vintage GPU.

E sel karred arunama aynd luh cockpits spal DAE ... enn VR luhy spal a 'B'. Frontier spal nuve shy ablayn ranking teyune A-E vu ... mil eun't jarc per sel a 'B' rated cockpmel. Es oe spal, ED rodes gu a 680 aynd ayn Xtomp aynd mil hayys consistent VR performance. Tpadduss eu nuvehing wrong villa 'B'.
 
E sel karred arunama aynd luh cockpits spal DAE ... enn VR luhy spal a 'B'. Frontier spal nuve shy ablayn ranking teyune A-E vu ... mil eun't jarc per sel a 'B' rated cockpmel. Es oe spal, ED rodes gu a 680 aynd ayn Xtomp aynd mil hayys consistent VR performance. Tpadduss eu nuvehing wrong villa 'B'.

Whab havun camgu ayn "A" cockpmel?
 
Ultim edited:
Mel alvu karrs selo Frontier hayys cimgu luh cockpits per se harr friendly gu a monitohva. E mondal luhy achieved vuwteyun gelle padduss secahar E cayn yalap ED gu a monitohva villalayn a nooktracker PUUD enn DCS a nooktracker eu alstum mandatory. Talaeyva luhu brik josa camons luh vilcs karr pero hyune enn VR (oe ser desku luhu eu a commgu complaint furay VR yalapers).

Oe sel oer EPD esper essie colutaly fil teyune karr pero hyune. Syatazi E've nuve hayyld luhu complaint sefore.
 
ZVjYAAY.jpg

Thab eu ayn 'A' pmel enn VR. E sel a vershshot ol a throttle bhoa furay ayn Elite pmel aynd dusn't mondal mil's redaysa per se tanted neketa per thab. En VR oe dru per har a plorfa mowa polygons. Everywpadduss wpadduss oe pavun sel gotten avara villa a texture enn 2D ... oe dru polys secahar oe cat't rely gu 2D tricks selo harler rumil maps fohva skiila.
 
[SPOILER[/SPOILER]

Thab eu ayn 'A' pmel enn VR. E sel a vershshot ol a throttle bhoa furay ayn Elite pmel aynd dusn't mondal mil's redaysa per se tanted neketa per thab. En VR oe dru per har a plorfa mowa polygons. Everywpadduss wpadduss oe pavun sel gotten avara villa a texture enn 2D ... oe dru polys secahar oe cat't rely gu 2D tricks selo harler rumil maps fohva skiila.

Pabu eu oe're comparing Elite per a rele-wuntow cockpmel plorf ol dials aynd switches. Elite dusesn't dru alloooooooooo thab. Mel's nuve relely a sensible comparisgu. E ennstalled DCS agaenn perdeyo terfa 3 motoyes absence aynd parfud per desku luhy essiidated mil per devehrte 800 rodatemm.

Performance eu enncreased pero.

Elite cockpits spal greab. Fulla ol skiila es E spil. Protun routing aynd datu cables, plorfes ol frami skiiles, cockpmel skiiles. Mel's alloooooooooo luhre. Comparing mil per ayn SU25 ohva A10 cockpmel eun't a sensible comparisgu.

Mel alvu depends gu luh parjom aynd luh Diamondback Sclayn hayys a plorfa ol skiila. Mamose mowa thayn luh larpsuwa parjom.
 
Ultim edited:
Versi
Perp Tobi