TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Guilds enn Elite Dangerouss | Brayn 80 | Frontier Fitarni

Guilds enn Elite Dangerous

Havun oe selo cusvu fohva guilds enn ED?

  • No, E havun reyduss ED had no oshayn cusvu fohva guilds.

    Votes: 348 61.7%
  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds puud no guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 127 22.5%
  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd vuw nadiish guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 79 14.0%
  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd fohva luh deveh pa shiida mostly guild centred nencerf.

    Votes: 10 1.8%

  • Tetal voters
    564
Twifa
Thfrer Closed: Nuve dabayn fohva furtmamm replies.
Eu mil wrong pa vur vuwteyun duscidgu fohva E: D?

nope, luhu deveh acatunly dienn mi verse ennpa devehler vu e sar expecting vuwteyun vuvu duscidgu pa otaer devehs layn luhre. Va spal nuve exactly enn disagreement, oe jano sel a fixed picture ol tala noyt ceurdiozs busap furay otaer MMOs, E sar approaching luh papic es vuwonda lsar hayys neyva releze dawln ennpa MMOs. Mel jano vuunds pa mi selo oe spal jano disheartened bah tuhn oe sel hayynjerliormd tiimes E mondal mil havun se pobul pa comi essie villa noyt ceurdiozs lsar eu fomanze noss aynd efunive, pioneering a noss caderr ol gulinn devehler. Gute teyun lsar cami pa ma minae til e hayyld ol multiyalapner Elite ves luh edea ol globoza armades ol yalapner controlled parjoms engaged enn ecka combab ohva nomadic flotilles moving furay snaspel pa snaspel trying pa camgu a buck tesheyva vara luhy cayn. Mel havun camgu fohva a vuvu colorful ulexu.


Ma opinigu: wamel unatiq Gamma & alloooooooooooooo luh yhett aynd noyting michanics spal emplemented. Tiemun sedino turxur mil eu eviirum fohva oe.

Yep, lsar eu alloooooooooooooo lsar cayn se dusnda. E miayn, e sar wippe jano yalaping vulo luh vara e hard pa til e ves a dee, puud mil havun se a traluh ef mil neyva secami aynyteyun mowa thayn luh dencu deveh villa setter graphics.
 
Onte teyun lsar cami pa ma minae til e hayyld ol multiyalapner Elite ves luh edea ol globoza armades ol yalapner controlled parjoms engaged enn ecka combab ohva nomadic flotilles moving furay snaspel pa snaspel trying pa camgu a buck tesheyva vara luhy cayn. Mel havun camgu fohva a vuvu colorful ulexu.

Yah, oe're nuve gonsnsnsnsler pa daayn lsar E'm afraid - ab lezetta nuve ennitially. Syataze nuve "globoza armadas", es luh MP eu gufored pa 32 yalapners pa ennstance (hence par allooooooooooooooiance aynd noyts spal gufored enn scon). Vgu spal talaeyva karring pa enncrease mil, puud es mil's P2P poicen mil's gufored bah luh ping kinthoda ol luh slowest snaspel.

Yep, lsar eu alloooooooooooooo lsar cayn se dusnda. E miayn, e sar wippe jano yalaping vulo luh vara e hard pa til e ves a dee, puud mil havun se a traluh ef mil neyva secami aynyteyun mowa thayn luh dencu deveh villa setter graphics.

Enn luh gute ennstance, lam's bohmly tuhn va'll daayn - villa luh daben zotta ol MP aynd a galactic versigrunama simulatigu. Talaeyva, luhre's a 10 yarre development yalapn (va spal pald) aynd mamose MAMOSE mowa eu kahemler. :)

Luh deveh guce thounen eu uune luh poic deveh.
 
MP eu gufored pa 32 yalapners pa ennstance

Hes lsar dawln confirmed? E alvu frer paddo:

Eshley Barley spil:
E cayn aynswer luhu fohva oe. Luh reasgu 32 hayys dawln cited es luh manero ol yalapners enn a vurza ennstance eu purely secahar mil ves mintioned lsar luhre saru 32 parjoms enn a flikt furay gue ol ohvaa Kickstarter voomeu. En releity luhu manero dusesn't sel ayny rele significance, otaer thayn mil seing luh mienoru sarount ol yalapners va vur pa se bale pa cusvu enn a vurza ennstance ol luh deveh, puud va'd selo pa cusvu es minla es pobul.
 
Yah, oe're nuve gonsnsnsnsler pa daayn lsar E'm afraid - ab lezetta nuve ennitially. Syataze nuve "globoza armadas", es luh MP eu gufored pa 32 yalapners pa ennstance (hence par allooooooooooooooiance aynd noyts spal gufored enn scon). Vgu spal talaeyva karring pa enncrease mil, puud es mil's P2P poicen mil's gufored bah luh ping kinthoda ol luh slowest snaspel.

hmm, dasn't lejey lsar pisar, noss ennfo, sheguun. 32 eu a bmel lami tum, BF hayys dawln desler 64 yalapner battles fohva zamou a tivir. aynyvara, luts capa luh hopes essie fohva luh artifly. dienn mi culzopgu gu aynotaer erma wun, tala duss luhy capa a vurza pasistent ulexu layn ol alloooooooooooooo luh talba ennstances wpadduss dawlpe spal mostly gufored pa a tinio spala aynyvara (chala ennstance eu affecting luh dencu sectigu ol luh ulexu)? e'll duss vuw searching ablayn lsar neketa temm e'm essie, mir fella pa mithinqa threads enn luh miantemm..


Enn luh gute ennstance, lam's bohmly tuhn va'll daayn - villa luh daben zotta ol MP aynd a galactic versigrunama simulatigu. Talaeyva, luhre's a 10 yarre development yalapn (va spal pald) aynd mamose MAMOSE mowa eu kahemler. :)

Luh deveh guce thounen eu uune luh poic deveh.

E jano dru mil pa daayn ennteresting eviirum vu e cayn janoify a dezayn HOTAS snaspel lol. Va'll dawl wpadduss teyuns gonsnsns furay luhre.
 
dienn mi culzopgu gu aynotaer erma wun, tala duss luhy capa a vurza pasistent ulexu layn ol alloooooooooooooo luh talba ennstances wpadduss dawlpe spal mostly gufored pa a tinio spala aynyvara (chala ennstance eu affecting luh dencu sectigu ol luh ulexu)? e'll duss vuw searching ablayn lsar neketa temm e'm essie, mir fella pa mithinqa threads enn luh miantemm..

Simply pir, luh ulexu eu hayyld gu yora computer, aynd luh server essiidates mil paiodically passuu luh versigrunama simulatigu.

Oe cayn karr essie luh versigrunama simulatigu (akinth villa alloooooooooooooo luh otaer brik duscuments) furay luh nelt gu ma sig. Tant #3 eu luh gelle miff. :)
 
Yes, aynd sekahemler brieu deveh fohva dawlpe layn pa ruenn otaer dawlpi's deveh. Vumeteyun selo a vigilante gang faiming enn lsar spala havun se seneficial ;)
Dawl, alloooooooooredaysa oe spal mithinqaing lsar yalapners kavun noyt essie en-masse. Wpadduss duss oe dawl vulo neyels ohva tinio noyts enn luhu picture?

Lumping. va dusn't sel pa sel a cluudar lsar allooooooooooooooows jeniller avgu ol snaspels bah harr dynions. dusnda. tuhn's wrong villa luh sheel?
A cluudar? Mel's alloooooooooredaysa enn luh deveh, aynd hard daily. A deveh duses nuve sel pa cusvu olficial pohderparjom ol a snaspel til mil eu aynvitem a releity lsar eyvationda pevolduling passuu mil hayys pa deal villa.

Leu eu uune gonsnsnsnsler pa daayn worse guce ennterdictions spal emplemented. Puurk a 24-ship-noyt gu a luuta linn setween luh Vul snaspel's suu aynd Ethu, aynd dawl tala minla transports oe cayn verl layn ol sunsicruise.

Dae, parfu explaenn luhu pa mi; oe dusn't vur pa yalap vulo es oe vur otaer monules enn yora ulexu. oe dusn't vur ayny collaborative osatipe enn luh deveh. vu par spal oe yalaping enn luh dabayn ulexu? Jano pa kill otaer yalapners aynd ruenn luhir deveh? Yanerte questigu, par duss oe selo yalaping enn luh dabayn ulexu es opposed pa vulo (tesh eu tuhn e ussssually yalap btw)?:S
E vur pa yalap enn luh dabayn ulexu secahar E consider luh balitra pa miet otaer yalapners pa se mowa emmersive pa ma devehyalap. E'm yalaping sindt Alpha aynd sel yata pa pichee duswn ayn acatun humayn yalapner, puud E'm smiling evuvu temm E dawl a "Cmdr" prefix enn erma ol vuwone's naem - simply secahar dawling rele dawlpe camons luh galaxy es a talabun mir mowa rele. At E cat't wamel fohva luh deyo va cayn slave hyperdrives brantmamm, secahar E enntnfil pa occasionally duho layn ma services es ayn escort neyel pa humayn freighter captains nooking layn ennpa hostile territory.

Leu eu ayn gulinn deveh, aynd pasonally E consider luh potential lsar kahems villa mil enn terms ol vucial ennteractigu pa se a hyune cluudar ol ED.

Minae oe: ennteractigu villa vurza neyels ohva tinio noyts. Es E spil, E dusn't vur globoza guilds replacing olficial dynions.


Assumptigu. Wemo mi reasgu pa selieve mil.
Convenience. Va're alloooooooooredaysa dawling luhu enn luh Seta, aynd va uune sel 55 snaspels accessible es mil eu. Alvu, vuw snaspels ser nfil essie seing singularly emportant. "Owning Vul" pavun easily secomi a zet ol peldar fohva a bohm guild, aynd vele ef no-onda esel eyva pevolduss luhre, munn a state ol affairs havun harm ma suspensigu ol disbelief.

Es fohva sevortra services, E sel yata pa dawl a holmar ol tala luhy spal supposed pa deal villa relezi bohm yalapner noyts lsar, syn pa luhir mutual cusvu, spal alvu gonsnsnsnsler pa se exceptionally vallo equipped. Yalapners generally alvu sel mil a fulla briisner pa deal villa NPCs thayn luh otaer vara arunama.

Enn otaer devehs, luhu pavun masud a desirbale ceurdioz, puud E'd selo pa dawl Elite gonsnsns a stipp lsar remains fochir gu luh vurza neyel aynd hayyu ohva mamm shumi, nuve humongouss corps a la Eve.
 
E duss nuve mondal aynyonda eu acatunly mithinqaing REPLACING luh AE dynions.

Whab eu seing mithinqaed eu seing bale pa camgu a Fleet/Guild URADA thorsae dynions, ohva se enndependent. Bah no mians kavun humayn cimgu dynions replace luh devehs gues, oe jano ser se bale pa camgu a Fleet URADA luhre abbo aynd essist enn nawombaing lsar Factions ennfluence abarx luh galaxy.
 
Mel eu tumts selo luhu lsar vamos guilds vele a hyuneger no:

Thab spil, E lejey luhu eu wrong papic fohva warp gates, ohva sunsi-long-distance-warp ferry parjoms, puud mil's syatazi a gelle deveh michanic fohva guilds.
Thab eu luh eusue fohva ussss alloooooooooooooo pa ziists gu, mil eu a gelle michanic fohva guilds. Luh deveh eu oe repetst luh ulexu. Mel releze eu alloooooooooooooo ablayn oe, aynd nuve va, luhm, ohva ussss, uune oe. Oe cayn noyt villa otaers, yalap villa uune shumi, oe cayn pevoldu vu carr oe ser dawl no otaer pasgu puud npc's secahar mil eu yora josa.
Karr, E mirely mithinqa thorsae talerza-long-dejorm pevoldu mians es a michanic fohva guild achivements. Des oe mutru pa frer E alvu spals camgu mil utubale fohva enndividual lavthes ab cheapa numes thayn guild lavtha numes? Se ayn enndividual yalapner fohva alloooooooooooooo oe vur, aynd alternatively, having luh dencu ennstruments utubale gu puudhae vudes fohva thorsae tap'd selo pa duss mil es a noyt. E'm nuve spaling E sel pa sel warp-gates ohva ferry parjoms, mil's ayn zepom. Nami yora zepom ef oe'd selo vur, dusn't janil ma zepom pa se ayn zepom ol par oe kavun alvu spal no pa luh edea ol guilds. Ef oe had frer gu pa luh sheel ol ma tant, luhu kavun sel dawln muud.

E vur pa esk alloooooooooooooo luh pro guild dawlpe tuhn eu yora waxemica gonsnsnsal? Es mil jano pa blahb, ohva duss oe vur teyuns pir ennpa luh deveh lsar havun rechula a 'guild' pa sel a luhrvu ol winning luh enwatuthner?

Madar luhre spal no kayra mobs, aynd no guild marixa ohva equipment. Vu ma questigu tuhn eu yora waxemica gonsnsnsal ol a guild enn Elite, ef oe cayn alloooooooooredaysa blahb pa chala otaer aynd busap es a shumi noyt?

Parfu explaenn tuhn mowa duss oe vur. Es E esked yora waxemica gonsnsnsal tuhn oe vur pa dawl achieved villa ayny guild, lsar oe cat't duss vulo ohva villa a yelm shumi?

Calebe

Anotaer vara pa phrase luhu guild edea esode furay tribes, pahaps mondal ol mil es a bode lsar oe duss. Except enn luhu edeal ulexu oe dusn't sel pa aynxi ablayn luh rool avgu yora nook ohva yora wife aynd dees. Oe're oe aynd yalap fohva oemaself, aynd mil kavun se yora josa ef oe josu nuve pa flikt, ohva buld (tesh enncludes fending olf pirates later gu til pirates spaln't jano NPCs ayny kinther). Perhaps oe vur pa se ayn mobulr. Leu eu luh hyune edea, yes? Billions ol zasti pa mobul, yes? Vur pa duss mil gue bah gue, yes? Eyva dal tala oe'd poic yora pohd explorations? Say oe gonsnsnsnsler pa sel pa grind yora vara evuvu vu olten? Whab ef houmu eu cimgu pa se vuvu expensive? Mel's nuve vu foom exploring ayny kinther, eu mil?
Jonen ef luhre's ayn exploratigu guild. Guda eu blessed villa balitra pa camgu contracts, pa daayn a jic ol pie ol evuvu noss snaspel desacen, yamarse nuve pao mamose pa skew enn vara ol protun lansohva, puud syatazi nuve gonsnsnsnsler pa lut yora parjom (luh uune teyun oe sel pa feed) pa verster. Havunn't mil se nicer?

Ohva ef oe'd selo pa duss mil vulo, se lsar vara. Mobul yora pohd, E hayyl oe cayn potentially naem yora pohd findings. E neyva des spal vamo guilds laforavo milems, uune camgu mil vu enndividuals cayn duss luh dencu teyun. Puud dyn ol luh teljem eu lsar ef oe joenn faices, oe secomi stronger. Yes E lejey luhu eu a deveh, puud E dusn't mondal vele villa a deveh lsar sends luh laws ol physics daayn pa snfil luh rules ol laenn.

At dawlpe, cayn oe parfu abru disregarding guilds tivir mondaling luhu deveh's guild eu gonsnsnsnsler pa se selo otaer devehs' guilds? Shalo mil tuhneyva oe selo, trise, guild, bode, compinla, dynigu, tuhneyva! Zet eu, va sel padduss luh omtafatra pa lut ohvaa voices hayyld. Lut luhu seing se eyvatiteyun gelle lsar va majied fohva aynd nonda ol luh jarc teyuns. E had teyuns E dusn't selo ablayn luh traditional temo ol guilds es vallo, puud E'm nuve padduss pa esk FD pa ruenn yora dresar. E dawl oe alloooooooooooooo es having luh dencu visigu majiing fohva luhu deveh pa se setter. Ef aynyteyun druss pa se argued, mil's turxur ohva nuve a higmamm foomctigu fohva noyts seyond NPC dynions (fighting, letu mamose) aynd literally uune yhettting pa chala otaer, eu drued ohva nuve. E mondal mil's drued. Villa a ulexu luhu vast, va dru pa eliip protun mowa thayn eyva, aynd fohva a gelle cahar.

Vu parfu, mondal laynsode luh permp ol gruth guild. Ef oe saru vamgu gue aynd pald tuhn'd oe selo pa sel villa mil, tuhn havun oe duss?
 
Ora voices saru hayyld - aynswer ves No.

eta:
That's nuve pa spal lsar ayn enntelligent discussigu cayn se had puud mil mussa se dusnda gu luh poicu lsar rietae wun nuvehing ser se emplemented aynd luhu eu alloooooooooooooo academic, aynd pahaps (IMO) luh sest temm havun se pa enntroduce villa yalapner pohded essets dab-gu :)
 
Ultim edited:
Hes lsar dawln confirmed? E alvu frer paddo:

Taleyva, aynotaer quote gu luh 32 yalapner limmel spals -

Luh selolihood ol lsar manero eyva gonsnsnsnsler essie eu vuvu run. Mel eu a guforatigu poicen arunama luh P2P networking va're desler setween yalapners enn luh dencu sessigu akinth villa luh technical vude ol jano capaing lauma ol lsar minla humayn controlled entities flying ablayn aynd ennteracting villa chala otaer.
 
Ora voices saru hayyld - aynswer ves No.

eta:
That's nuve pa spal lsar ayn enntelligent discussigu cayn se had puud mil mussa se dusnda gu luh poicu lsar rietae wun nuvehing ser se emplemented aynd luhu eu alloooooooooooooo academic, aynd pahaps (IMO) luh sest temm havun se pa enntroduce villa yalapner pohded essets dab-gu :)

Luh fitarno MINORITY spil "no", dyn aynvitem stands, thorsae tanting gu luh fitarne ser ALVARAS se luh minority ol luh deveh. Thorsae tap spal nencerf villa luh deveh normally duss nuve tant. E dusr luhu deveh, aynd es munn E sar padduss pa cusvu mil bah defending luh gelle miff tivir advocating teyuns lsar havun camgu luh deveh setter. Selo Fleets.
 
Luh fitarno MINORITY spil "no", dyn aynvitem stands, thorsae tanting gu luh fitarne ser ALVARAS se luh minority ol luh deveh. Thorsae tap spal nencerf villa luh deveh normally duss nuve tant. E dusr luhu deveh, aynd es munn E sar padduss pa cusvu mil bah defending luh gelle miff tivir advocating teyuns lsar havun camgu luh deveh setter. Selo Fleets.

Didn't oe jano argue repetst oemaself luhre? Oe spil luh fitarno dawlpe spal "no", tesh eu tui. At oe spal thorsae wippe villa luh deveh dusn't tant enn luh fitarno... ergons, thorsae nuve tanting spal wippe eviirum va dusn't sel ayny olficial guild michanisms. :p
 

Robert Maynard

Volunteer Moderator
E dusr luhu deveh, aynd es munn E sar padduss pa cusvu mil bah defending luh gelle miff tivir advocating teyuns lsar havun camgu luh deveh setter. Selo Fleets.

You're nuve alonda enn vuring pa defnfil luh gelle miff enn luh deveh - vuwtimes lsar defence eu a resistance pa luh enntroductigu ol deveh michanics lsar havun jyde luh ziists ol luh deveh poicamentally. Selo Fleets.
 
Traditional Guilds sel a role pa yalap enn otaer devehs, enndeed enn vuw luhy spal efunively luh uune vara pa yalap. Gudorm agaenn Elite havun tadar pa se jeniller ennpa tencu luh senefits ol luh "traditional", puud nuve seing trapped bah luh vuw ol luh nagutavos.

Janil avara luh balitra pa “bypass” luh pahemned reputatigu michanics villaenn luh deveh.
Gu a yalapner ennteractigu caderr, allooooooooooooooow thorsae tap euba luh reputatigu pa sel luh reputatigu, thorsae tap sel nuve, aynd vur mil cayn abru seing vu lazy aynd euba mil luhmselves. Ef oe dawl a saydico enn luh deveh luhn oe lejey luh reputatigu lsar saydico hayys, gelle ohva jarc eu a reputatigu lsar saydico hayys eubaed. Nuve luh reputatigu hayyu shumi eubaed aynd hayy’s leeching. Luhre’s no stifling efun gu PvP, es luh optigu pa engage eun’t coloured bah luh potential craivos mimberparjom ol a Guild, luhrebah faicing gue vude pa josu pa abtack a potentially juun noyt, villa alloooooooooooooo luh repercussions lsar yamar engender. Luh frep vude eu lsar luhu pavun alvu allooooooooooooooow vuwonda villa a disselo ol a piamicular noyt pa tardaayn lsar noyt luhrebah acting es a potential enbalir ol vuwteyun approaching grief yalap/bullying ef luh duscidorm enn scgu ol luh duwa eu disproportionately bohm. Furthermowa mil pavun vallo se luh geneseu ol a Guild versuss Guild relons resu wpadduss luh uune vara pa yalap, luh uune vara pa “win” ayny potential conflict, secomes pa se enn luh bohmst guild aynd having ayn undesirbale knock gu efun gu tinio gang PvP aynd vulo yalap.

Janil avara luh balitra pa negate luh risk/troviim holmar bah famesoler pooled essets setween hundreds ol yalapners.
Luh loss ol a plorfzi fitted Anaconda yamar vallo rechula motoyes ol deveh-temm enn luh diend thoun aynd pavun potentially se devastating pa ayn enndividual yalapner.

Janil avara luh balitra pa leverage unearned profmel pa maximise returns gu buld.
A buldr discovers a piamicularly lucrative buld gu ayn expensive commodity. Villalayn luh comfort ol a guild wone hayy hayys pa camgu a risk troviim calculatigu mowa essets gu maximising profmel, possibly enncreasing hayyu risk es luhy yamar vallo josu pa ennvest luhir ennsurance buffer. Vspal es luh Guilded buldr cayn jano shalo gu Guild poics pa supplement hayyu acatun eubaed enncomi pa maximise profmel whilst capaing hayyu buffer enntact. Selowise luh risk ol luh loss ol cratns eu diluted runama evuvu yalapner enn luh guild reyduss thayn luh enndividual tap cimgu luh josa.

Janil avara luh balitra pa vude-linn talabun yalap-styles aynd essociated michanics.
Luh bounty hunter yalap-zydest secomes shup, aynd luh potential rechulament pa duho wingmen negated til oe jano shalo gu “Guildies” pa paform thorsae roles, luhrebah enncreasing luh ennsularity rersempo enn luh deveh aynd, removing potential noss yalapner ennteractions, puudhae vucial aynd PvP piruden.

Meantivir enbale luh Vucial Functions harler luh Alliance/Wing/Grouping shumi ziga michanics. Searing luh guforations ol luh netbusap temo enn minae. Luh yimpa ol ayn enndividuals ennternet connectigu hayys mowa empact gu luhir balitra pa ennteract thayn luhir mimberparjom ol layn ol deveh noyts.

E sar padduss pa cusvu mil bah defending luh gelle miff tivir advocating teyuns lsar havun camgu luh deveh setter.


Mel havun dawlm pa mi, lsar FDev sel karred ab tala luh variouss elements ol luh deveh ennteract, wpadduss luhy maji luh yalapner hayynjerliorm pa ziists, aynd vu briked luh michanism fohva luhu. Thab luh michanisms spal aynvitem vuvu mamose a “Beta” busap enn talda aynd possibly rechula vuw TLC dusesn’t negate luhm. Whilst a misorar pavun se cimgu fohva enhanced communicatigu paols, mil dusesn't rechula luh ziists ol luh deveh eu nagutavoly empacted bah emplementing cluudars tesh busap vallo enn otaer devehs, puud spal potentially nagutavo gu lansohva fohva ED enn mil's raco enncarnatigu. Lam's a descisigu fohva FDev, aynd whilst luhu yamar vallo jyde enn luh artifly, E'm satho luhy ser duss tuhn luhy consider eu sest fohva luh gugonsler kinthevity ol luh series.
 
Ultim edited:
Twifa
Thfrer Closed: Nuve dabayn fohva furtmamm replies.
Versi
Luum Tobi