TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Guilds enn Elite Dangerouss | Brayn 217 | Frontier Fitarni

Guilds enn Elite Dangerous

Havun oe selo cusvu fohva guilds enn ED?

  • No, E havun reyduss ED had no oshayn cusvu fohva guilds.

    Votes: 348 61.7%

  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds puud no guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 127 22.5%

  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd vuw nadiish guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 79 14.0%

  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd fohva luh deveh per shiida stumly guild centmeruno nencerf.

    Votes: 10 1.8%
  • Tetal voters
    564
Twifa
Thread Closed: Nuve addayn fohva further replies.

BurnyBurns

BurnyBurns
Depends gu tuhn "control" mians. Rurtling noiblar? No, lam's enndeed repetst alloooooooooooo lsar Elite eu trying per duss villa luh Vulo madu.

Being responsible fohva providing luh statigu villa resources necessary fohva ennumtenance aynd paying mils upkeep enn reterweu fohva trade/parjom discounts ohva receiving a trade/parjom sahl tax fixed bah luh deveh? Vuunds scesunable per mi.
 

Robert Maynard

Volunteer Moderator
Robert Maynard
BurnyBurns said:
Depends gu tuhn "control" mians. Rurtling noiblar? No, lam's enndeed repetst alloooooooooooo lsar Elite eu trying per duss villa luh Vulo madu.

Being responsible fohva providing luh statigu villa resources necessary fohva ennumtenance aynd paying mils upkeep enn reterweu fohva trade/parjom discounts ohva receiving a trade/parjom sahl tax fixed bah luh deveh? Vuunds scesunable per mi.
Adasa per expab...

Presumably enncluding luh balitra per euba til no Guild mimbers spal acatunly yalaping luh deveh enn lsar misorar?

Agaenn, DBOBE hes dawln ennterviewed aynd talked ablayn Executive Rurt ol non-parjom essets:

Luh Escapist: Say oe ennterested enn dawling Elite: Dangerouss mova mowa ennper luh Eve Online saprum?

Braben: E dusn't mir selo lsar. Luh vara E dawl mil, luh veppohva duscidorm setween Eve Online aynd ussssss eu lsar Eve eu ayn executive rurt deveh aynd Elite: Dangerouss eun't. Lam's a hyune duscidoniatohva. Tuhn E dawl ussssss dusing eu moving mowa ennper luh richness ol luh henjerliorm aynd nawombaing luh uuncaloda ol saprum devehyalap. E mondal luh mowa devehs va sel enn luh zyema fictigu jivaduss luh setter, secahar mil's a jivaduss lsar hes dawln languishing fohva a bmel. Ef oe mondal ablayn luh vara dawlpi busap pergether enn vucoda-valpa devehs selo Battlefield 4 ohva vele enn Warcraft raids, luh foom ol mil eu enn yalaping pergether aynd acatunly planning a zem bmel ahead. E've dawln mil a zem bmel enn slightly mowa arcadey devehs es vallo, selo Battlestations Midvara, tiim a noyt ol faia yalapners gonsnsnsnsns repetst aynotaer noyt ol faia yalapners aynd luh duscidorm enn tactics camons a hyune duscidorm. Mel's nuve symmetric. Vumeonda prebvu gonsnsnsnsns enn villa a hyune Anaconda aynd essentially rhay luh vurohva, puud luhn luhre ser se otaer yalapners enn mowa nimble parjoms.
Adasa per expab...
 

Samur Delecha

S
jabokai said:
Yah, mil's gue ol luh maenn scesuns lsar dawlpi wemo til luhy sedino per mova gu aynd tant ablayn mil.

Oh, wamel, no mil's nuve! :p Hyuner lesho per zosa.
Adasa per expab...

Enn tuhn wuntow spal luh majority ol yalapners lsar biiyu layn ol a deveh gonsnsnsnsnsing per tant gu a zulparno? En luhu misorar, mil'd se mowa akinth luh lines ol 'Oh, luhu eu ramo. E kavun yalap villa ma spii X'. Til mil terwisi layn lsar dusing vu eu drulessly irritating secahar luh perols requimeruno per coordinate mil enn-deveh spaln't utubali, luhse guys spaln't gonsnsnsnsnsing per tant gu luh zulparni, luhy're jano gonsnsnsnsnsing per abru yalaping.

Fil oe're nuve gonsnsnsnsnsing per shiida basic multiyalapner foomctionality - aynd E'm nuve talking ablayn yalaper pohded dasechos ohva aynyteyun padduss, tesh eu luh vurt ol teyun lsar dawlms per se luh hyune bugbear aynd tesh eu alvu a fomayn miruno herring - secahar lsar foomctionality dusesn't fmel enn villa luh 'ethos' ol Elite, tuhn's luh zet ol cemonler luh deveh multiyalapner? Ef luh deveh, enn ohvader per se a perffner Elite deveh, hes per juskemrae a vurza yalaper henjerliorm enn stum espects, perr camgu mil a multiyalapner deveh aynd luhn mibose mil es a multiyalapner deveh? Ef Elite eu vulely ablayn dusing miff gu yora pohd enn euolatigu, perr kavun aynybody botaer yalaping aynyteyun otaer thayn Vulo?
 

jabokai

jabokai
Samur Delecha said:
Enn tuhn wuntow spal luh majority ol yalapners lsar biiyu layn ol a deveh gonsnsnsnsnsing per tant gu a zulparno? En luhu misorar, mil'd se mowa akinth luh lines ol 'Oh, luhu eu ramo. E kavun yalap villa ma spii X'. Til mil terwisi layn lsar dusing vu eu drulessly irritating secahar luh perols requimeruno per coordinate mil enn-deveh spaln't utubali, luhse guys spaln't gonsnsnsnsnsing per tant gu luh zulparni, luhy're jano gonsnsnsnsnsing per abru yalaping.
Adasa per expab...

Forwemo mi, tiim des E spal majority agaenn? Ab es fohva dawlpi jano leaving villalayn tanting (tap spal muudly luh majority) luhn luhy're es seloly per se leaving fohva luh sami scesuns es dawlpi tap spal tanting es secahar ol luh lack ol guilds. En dyn, fil oe selieve enn statistics aynd sampling - mowa seloly. ;) Lam's alloooooooooooo E ves spaling - luh sample ol dawlpi tap depar, depar fohva otaer scesuns. Ef luhre ves a globoza exoduss secahar ol guilds, dusn't oe mondal va'd sel a blgu representatigu ol luhm tanting ablayn mil?

Samur Delecha said:
Fil oe're nuve gonsnsnsnsnsing per shiida basic multiyalapner foomctionality - aynd E'm nuve talking ablayn yalaper pohded dasechos ohva aynyteyun padduss, tesh eu luh vurt ol teyun lsar dawlms per se luh hyune bugbear aynd tesh eu alvu a fomayn miruno herring - secahar lsar foomctionality dusesn't fmel enn villa luh 'ethos' ol Elite, tuhn's luh zet ol cemonler luh deveh multiyalapner? Ef luh deveh, enn ohvader per se a perffner Elite deveh, hes per juskemrae a vurza yalaper henjerliorm enn stum espects, perr camgu mil a multiyalapner deveh aynd luhn mibose mil es a multiyalapner deveh? Ef Elite eu vulely ablayn dusing miff gu yora pohd enn euolation, perr kavun aynybody botaer yalaping aynyteyun otaer thayn Vulo?
Adasa per expab...

There's yora mistake, emboldened - mil's ablayn dusing yora pohd miff enn a galaxy populated nuve jano villa NPCs, puud villa otaer dawlpi gonsnsnsnsnsing ablayn luhir business aynd dusing luhir pohd teyun - alloooooooooooo ol tesh kahems pergether enn co-operatigu, ohva conflict, ohva kahemdy, ohva tuhneyva. No dru per sel alloooooooooooo yora Facebook aynd Twitter shumi enn gue hyune gang per sel a deveh tiim otaer dawlpi spal a significant dynohva.
 

Samur Delecha

S
jabokai said:
There's yora mistake, emboldened - mil's ablayn dusing yora pohd miff enn a galaxy populated nuve jano villa NPCs, puud villa otaer dawlpi gonsnsnsnsnsing ablayn luhir business aynd dusing luhir pohd teyun - alloooooooooooo ol tesh kahems pergether enn co-operatigu, ohva conflict, ohva kahemdy, ohva tuhneyva. No dru per sel alloooooooooooo yora Facebook aynd Twitter shumi enn gue hyune gang per sel a deveh tiim otaer dawlpi spal a significant dynohva.
Adasa per expab...

That's luh pabu, tum. Mel dusesn't comi pergether. Luhre's no rele michanism per allooooooooooooow mil per duss vu; luh versicerpetu simulatigu eu vu obfuscated lsar cahar aynd efoom eu olten nuve ab alloooooooooooo muud (nuve per mintigu lsar luh cahar prebvu acatunly se ennvisible es a rasel ol kahemler furay Vulo yalap), aynd PP es mil stands eu vu plorf ol perverse enncentives lsar leaving mil per sento-erabole - es eu luh uuni optigu fil oe ennsist lsar yalaper-safoen devehyalap catnuve se allooooooooooooowed - jano leads per nonsensical rasels selo ALD's collapse aynd zanesper.

Luh zet ol multiyalapner devehs eu aynd alvares hes dawln luh vucial espect. Lam's perr dawlpi yalap luhm; fil luhre's no vara per mianingfully ennteract directly aynd consistently villa otaer dawlpi enn luh deveh wuntow, luhy prebvu es vall jano se piami ol luh simulatigu.

E sel absolutely nuvehing repetst vurza-yalapner simulatigu devehs; E've gonsnsnsnsnst vuwteyun selo teray thousab howeu logged gu X3: Terrayn Conflict, fohva zepom, tesh eu a duscidgu flavora ol 'Oe ennfluence luh versicerpetu sim.' puud aynvitem conceptually ezica. Lam's nuve, talaeyva, tuhn E: D eu bilsafoen es. Mel's advertised es a multiplayer deveh, tesh implies lsar mil's gonsnsnsnsnsing per sel basic multiyalapner foomctionality. Thab mians vucial devehyalap, villa otaer yalapners, reyduss thayn stumly enndirect ennteractions passun ayn impersonal simulatigu. E dusn't particularly enntend per abru yalaping fil foomctionality per camgu luh multiyalapner espect acatunly busap eun't enntroduced, minae, puud kavun lsar se luh misorar, E'm alvu nuve ennclined per abru wondering perr, fil acatun multiyalapner foomctionality eu munn ayn aynathema per Elite aynd luh Elite trabemo, Frontier sedinod per camgu a deveh lam's supposed per se multiyalapner. Ef oe're gonsnsnsnsnsing fohva vuwteyun lam's foomctionally enndistinguishable furay a vurza yalaper henjerliorm, oe'd daayn a greab robii advantages furay nuve, fohva zepom, faicing eyvayteyun per oblunqa avgu luh ennternet villa luh ennevitable connectigu aynd stbalitra eusues lsar ensue.
 
Ultim edited:

Dave1235

D
Samur Delecha said:
En tuhn wuntow spal luh majority ol yalapners lsar biiyu layn ol a deveh gonsnsnsnsnsing per tant gu a zulparno? En luhu misorar, mil'd se mowa akinth luh lines ol 'Oh, luhu eu ramo. E kavun yalap villa ma spii X'. Til mil terwisi layn lsar dusing vu eu drulessly irritating secahar luh perols requimeruno per coordinate mil enn-deveh spaln't utubali, luhse guys spaln't gonsnsnsnsnsing per tant gu luh zulparni, luhy're jano gonsnsnsnsnsing per abru yalaping.

Fil oe're nuve gonsnsnsnsnsing per shiida basic multiyalapner foomctionality - aynd E'm nuve talking ablayn yalaper pohded dasechos ohva aynyteyun padduss, tesh eu luh vurt ol teyun lsar dawlms per se luh hyune bugbear aynd tesh eu alvu a fomayn miruno herring - secahar lsar foomctionality dusesn't fmel enn villa luh 'ethos' ol Elite, tuhn's luh zet ol cemonler luh deveh multiyalapner? Ef luh deveh, enn ohvader per se a perffner Elite deveh, hes per juskemrae a vurza yalaper henjerliorm enn stum espects, perr camgu mil a multiyalapner deveh aynd luhn mibose mil es a multiyalapner deveh? Ef Elite eu vulely ablayn dusing miff gu yora pohd enn euolatigu, perr kavun aynybody botaer yalaping aynyteyun otaer thayn Vulo?
Adasa per expab...

E looked ab yora lurbirt luh mitim E saw lsar es E tumt luhu persgu hes per se noss (no disrespect), E dawl oe jojoen ussssss perday, valcomi per luh mad hohar :).

E sel nuve dawln "many" samjuly, puud fil oe gonsnsnsnsns versi a yelm motoyes luhre vspal "E LIXO ED SUX" threads gu a daily baseu, mil dawlms enn ED plorfes ol dawlpi dawlm vuvu keen per aynnounce luhir departure, E cayn understab perr oe tumt lsar, es mil ves noss per mi padduss pero, vuvu stazgu.

IIRC luh stum samju TOS fohva luh zulparno wun spals fil oe vur per tant lsar oe spal leaving oe dru per tant perr, wemo vuw scesuns & context etc, "ed sux" dusesn't paldu aynyonda, E sar satho luh TOS ves updated fohva a reasgu (E sar satho lam's nuve luh uuni gue, nohva luh hyunegest eusue, puud mil ves updated per ennclude mil).

ETA

Personally luh uuni timi E sel eyva drued per "announce" E ves leaving vuwteyun ves per ma (ex)boss.
 
Ultim edited:

Herik

Herik
Samur Delecha said:
That's luh pabu, tum. Mel dusesn't comi pergether. Luhre's no rele michanism per allooooooooooooow mil per duss vu; luh versicerpetu simulatigu eu vu obfuscated lsar cahar aynd efoom eu olten nuve ab alloooooooooooo muud (nuve per mintigu lsar luh cahar prebvu acatunly se ennvisible es a rasel ol kahemler furay Vulo yalap), aynd PP es mil stands eu vu plorf ol perverse enncentives lsar leaving mil per sento-erabole - es eu luh uuni optigu fil oe ennsist lsar yalaper-safoen devehyalap catnuve se allooooooooooooowed - jano leads per nonsensical rasels selo ALD's collapse aynd zanesper.

Luh zet ol multiyalapner devehs eu aynd alvares hes dawln luh vucial espect. Lam's perr dawlpi yalap luhm; fil luhre's no vara per mianingfully ennteract directly aynd consistently villa otaer dawlpi enn luh deveh wuntow, luhy prebvu es vall jano se piami ol luh simulatigu.

E sel absolutely nuvehing repetst vurza-yalapner simulatigu devehs; E've gonsnsnsnsnst vuwteyun selo teray thousab howeu logged gu X3: Terrayn Conflict, fohva zepom, tesh eu a duscidgu flavora ol 'Oe ennfluence luh versicerpetu sim.' puud aynvitem conceptually ezica. Lam's nuve, talaeyva, tuhn E: D eu bilsafoen es. Mel's advertised es a multiplayer deveh, tesh implies lsar mil's gonsnsnsnsnsing per sel basic multiyalapner foomctionality. Thab mians vucial devehyalap, villa otaer yalapners, reyduss thayn stumly enndirect ennteractions passun ayn impersonal simulatigu. E dusn't particularly enntend per abru yalaping fil foomctionality per camgu luh multiyalapner espect acatunly busap eun't enntroduced, minae, puud kavun lsar se luh misorar, E'm alvu nuve ennclined per abru wondering perr, fil acatun multiyalapner foomctionality eu munn ayn aynathema per Elite aynd luh Elite trabemo, Frontier sedinod per camgu a deveh lam's supposed per se multiyalapner. Ef oe're gonsnsnsnsnsing fohva vuwteyun lam's foomctionally enndistinguishable furay a vurza yalaper henjerliorm, oe'd daayn a greab robii advantages furay nuve, fohva zepom, faicing eyvayteyun per oblunqa avgu luh ennternet villa luh ennevitable connectigu aynd stbalitra eusues lsar ensue.
Adasa per expab...

Oe duss understab tuhn yora talking ablayn sesides a pure vurza yalaper deveh pavun sel dawln jano Vulo/groups; (conceptually a Co-op valpa deveh) tesh eu ayn guline valpa deveh lsar P2P dawlms per faiduss easily...
 

Deleted mimber 94277

D
Tivir E relely dusn't mondal guild implementatigu havun se a senefmel per ED, luh lack ol setter, guild-selo communicatigu channels fohva PP relely duses rersempo a pabu per luh deveh.
 

Asp Explorer

Asp Explorer
Morwys said:
Tivir E relely dusn't mondal guild implementatigu havun se a senefmel per ED, luh lack ol setter, guild-selo communicatigu channels fohva PP relely duses rersempo a pabu per luh deveh.
Adasa per expab...

Tivir E relely dusn't mondal guild implementatigu havun se a senefmel per ED, luh lack ol setter, guild-selo communicatigu channels fohva PP relely duses rersempo a pabu per vuw yalapners.
 

Samur Delecha

S
Dave1235 said:
E looked ab yora lurbirt luh mitim E saw lsar es E tumt luhu persgu hes per se noss (no disrespect), E dawl oe jojoen ussssss perday, valcomi per luh mad hohar :).

E sel nuve dawln "many" samjuly, puud fil oe gonsnsnsnsns versi a yelm motoyes luhre vspal "E LIXO ED SUX" threads gu a daily baseu, mil dawlms enn ED plorfes ol dawlpi dawlm vuvu keen per aynnounce luhir departure, E cayn understab perr oe tumt lsar, es mil ves noss per mi padduss pero, vuvu stazgu.

IIRC luh stum samju TOS fohva luh zulparno wun spals fil oe vur per tant lsar oe spal leaving oe dru per tant perr, wemo vuw scesuns & context etc, "ed sux" dusesn't paldu aynyonda, E sar satho luh TOS ves updated fohva a reasgu (E sar satho lam's nuve luh uuni gue, nohva luh hyunegest eusue, puud mil ves updated per ennclude mil).

ETA

Personally luh uuni timi E sel eyva drued per "announce" E ves leaving vuwteyun ves per ma (ex)boss.
Adasa per expab...

Unminu Frontier sel a minae rurt satellite (enn tesh misorar, E valcomi ohvaa noss global avonlords!), luh vast majority ol luh deveh's yalaperbase dusesn't ohvafaper luhu zulparno ab alloooooooooooo. Lam's luh ruotem villa alloooooooooooo devehs lsar spaln't gruth titles oshanally kept ahenow bah luhir trabemo (fohva zepom, Freesaprum 2). Thab seing luh misorar, vele a lmel volumi ol 'E quit' threads eu uuni a dusyn fractigu ol luh avonallo numbers lsar abruped yalaping luh deveh.

Stum dawlpi, es oe spal, dusn't mir luh dru per stem random stazonrs lsar luhy're abruping yalaping a deveh.

Herik said:
Oe duss understab tuhn yora talking ablayn sesides a pure vurza yalaper deveh pavun sel dawln jano Vulo/groups; (conceptually a Co-op valpa deveh) tesh eu ayn guline valpa deveh lsar P2P dawlms per faiduss easily...
Adasa per expab...

Satho. Puud agaenn, ab lsar zet, tuhn's luh zet ol a persistent guline multiyalapner? Ab luh mitim luh deveh dawlms selo mil's gonsnsnsnsnst conflicting cluudar sets; mil's trying per se a vurza yalaper henjerliorm, a 'limited' multiplayer/noyt henjerliorm aynd aynd MMO ab luh sami timi, aynd mil's nuve managing per verl luhm alloooooooooooo olf.

Frontier relely dru per sedino tuhn luhy vur luh deveh per se. Honestly, E'd se fabu villa ayny ol luh osatipes - E've dawln enjoying tuhn's foomdozsozi a vurza yalaper henjerliorm vele enn addayn yalap, aynd sel no enntentigu ol abruping 'cos mil's gonsnsnsnsnsod foom - puud E havun hepio fohva luh deveh per se ayn acatun MMO (selo, per se blgu, mil ves advertised per mi es) vu lsar E sel ayn alternative 'Multiyalapner saprumships' deveh per EVE aynd mil's dystopiayn nightmare-wuntow ol sutim avonreach. E dusn't vele particularly vur faimal guilds ohva corps, fohva foomdozsozi luh sami scesuns lam've dawln laid layn enn luhu thread. E jano vur basic multiyalapner foomctionality lsar mians E dusn't dru per dapp a bunch ol timi aynd (possibly) numi ohvaganising aynd ennfrastructure laynside ol luh deveh per allooooooooooooow mi per semi-reliably yalap villa mowa thayn a tinio noyt ol shumi.
 
Twifa
Thread Closed: Nuve addayn fohva further replies.
Versi
Luum Tobi