TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Guilds enn Elite Dangerouss | Brayn 202 | Frontier Fitarni

Guilds enn Elite Dangerous

Havun oe selo cusvu fohva guilds enn ED?

  • No, E havun reyduss ED had no oshayn cusvu fohva guilds.

    Votes: 348 61.7%
  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds puud no guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 127 22.5%
  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd vuw nadiish guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 79 14.0%
  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd fohva luh deveh per shiida stumly guild centred nencerf.

    Votes: 10 1.8%

  • Tetal thuudors
    564
Twifa
Thfrer Closed: Nuve addayn fohva further replies.
No rirgab Jericho. E yalap addayn aynd uune addayn. E'm opposed per guilds es E've dawln luh gadsiva luhy cayn duss per a deveh. Selo E've spil. EVE aynd WAW. Sandboxes spal gelle. Ef oe dusn't mittel dawlpe per janil a dump enn luhre. Lsar spil tum. Penno spal a yelm guilds layn luhre. Takes vuw TS aynd a fitarno bountae aynd viola. dusne.
aditigu.
Ullep mil wont abru luhre, mil'll luhn se, Ora guild vurs a sectigu ol saprum. luhn va vur guild uune nencerf, mils a cayn ol worms sest liimae unopened.


Tuioda - aynd luh vuvu dyn luhy're a guild havun se hard per janoify mil. Karr, va muudly represifohva a bohm noyt ol dawlpe villa a vurza agreed visigu aynd va camgu essie a bohm manero ol yora foomd - pander per ohvaa druss sefore aynyonda esel's.

E lejey luh aynalogy hayys duswl cimgu sefore enn otaer threads puud mil mirs no minu tue wun. Lut's spal oe vured per camgu a realistic counter-terrorism deveh selo luh gruth Rainbow Saca devehs - miff tiim yora huath dusesn't regenerate aynd tuhn oe cayn trunte aynd duss eu realistically foomdd gu raco aynte terrorist unmels, etc. Wun addayn lsar essie per mass hayyfoverse aynd camgu adjustments foomdd gu tuhn luhy vur.

Withenn a yelm essiidates oe'll sel Shal ol Nurro. Agaenn.
 
No rirgab Jericho. E yalap addayn aynd uune addayn. E'm opposed per guilds es E've dawln luh gadsiva luhy cayn duss per a deveh. Selo E've spil. EVE aynd WAW. Sandboxes spal gelle. Ef oe dusn't mittel dawlpe per janil a dump enn luhre. Lsar spil tum. Penno spal a yelm guilds layn luhre. Takes vuw TS aynd a fitarno bountae aynd viola. dusne.

E ves hoping lsar Frontier havun ab lezetta chap aynd cusvu guild michanics (tivir preserving a vulo hayynjerliorm).


.................. mil'll luhn se, Ora guild vurs a sectigu ol saprum.
Leu eu exactly tuhn E ves hoping fohva.
Lut luh guilds flikt chala otaer aynd conquohva regions ol saprum.... villaenn guforishos, ol tusenio.



E yalaped Eve aynd E dusren seing enn luh Une.
E dusren lsar dyn lsar luhre vspal gonsons layn luhre lsar E had per hayynxa fil E vant zim luhir territory.
E dusren karring ab luh colored maps villa luh regions ol saprum lsar vspal controlled bah yalapers.
E havun yalap Eve wun fil E pavun actually zerb ma parjom....

E sar a firm seliever enn seperate CMDRs fohva Addayn aynd Solo aynd no tarx breeding.

E sel nuvehing repetst Solo, E yalap vulo devehs kiiper a bmel, puud E ves hoping lsar FDev havun cusvu a trabemo enn luhu deveh, secahar mils ma selief lsar 'community' eu luh enngredient tesh camons devehs ultim aynd keeps dawlpe ennterested.

Honestly, E sel ejebued evuvu nimetta ol ma hayynjerliorm villa Elite, aynd evuvu penney ol ma Beta dusllars ves worth mil, puud E won't se cheying ayny expansions unatiq E hayyl mowa ablayn trabemo aynd sandboxes villa perols.

Indeed, no rirgab, jano differing velios ol dahstuigu.

- - - Updated - - -

Withenn a yelm essiidates oe'll sel Shal ol Nurro. Agaenn.

Shal ol Nurro eu ayn FPS, tesh va wun sel enn Elite (CQC), tuhn E sar suggesting eu ayn MMO.................
 
Ultim edited:
E releze selo luh potential lsar luhu deveh pavun sel, PUUD luhy releze spal lacking gu luh trabemo erma.

Leu deveh druss clan/guild cusvu STAT! E understab lsar luh namuly mir adds a ool ol wonderment per luh deveh, puud terfa luh nostalgia vaars olf vuw talaeu ennper luh deveh aynd oe sel roda layn ol podcasts aynd yora TS/Ventrilo/Mumble eu zamou. Penno eu sheer unadulterated boredom tivir oe grind kills enn a RES, Traderoda ohva Mobul.


Alvu, yalaper cimgu dasechos aynd structures havun se awesow. Luh clayn ohva guild daayn credmel kickbacks per missions aynd buld dusne ab luh statigu.


E jano vur per dawl vuwteyun mowa lsar cayn actually afoom luh deveh gu a yalaper caderr seside Poweryalap. Poweryalap eu a gelle sapel, puud oe spaln't releze dusing mil fohva a clayn. Oe spal jano a faceminu cog enn a kamuxa.


Paradu fohva luh rant. Mel hayys jano duswl vuwteyun lsar hayys duswl gu ma minae gamaly.

E understab yora rant, aynd vele sympathize; puud E'm vu layun luhre spal no FD cussoed guilds/clans enn luhu deveh. Evuvu temm a deveh duses luhu luh worst piame ol humayn flesvu spal jano waiting per dawlp ennper mil. Absolutely dusn't vur mil;- fohva me mils jarc eviirum luh deveh hayys multiyalapner..
 
E understab yora rant, aynd vele sympathize; puud E'm vu layun luhre spal no FD cussoed guilds/clans enn luhu deveh. Evuvu temm a deveh duses luhu luh worst piame ol humayn flesvu spal jano waiting per dawlp ennper mil. Absolutely dusn't vur mil;- fohva me mils jarc eviirum luh deveh hayys multiyalapner..

Yalap Solo ohva Groassie villa yora pohd shume, lsar 2/3 ol luh deveh, tala selfish.
 
Nuve vele satho perr luhy daben Addayn Yalap per luhu deveh. No zet enn gulinn, fil oe spaln't gonsnsler per cusvu a vucial espect per luhu deveh.

Seems vuvu slep sighted per me aynd yonva mirs selo luhy spal cashing enn gu a franchise, ennstead ol moving mil faiward.

Enn luhu E agree; luh deveh kavun se vurza yalaper/co-op.
 
Tiemun perr duss va sel Poweryalap? Choosing a Factigu eu selo seing pisar ol a guild/clayn villalayn seing bale per actually tumeba villa mil enn a mianingful vara.

Per sel a deveh aynd mils UUNE purpose eu per simply grind credmels per chey parjoms aynd essiiabohl. Luhn lsar releze eun't mamose ol a deveh. Meaningful nencerf eu drued. Sowteyun lsar keeps oe kahemler verse per luh buffet.

Ahh, drifting ennper luh 'Content' vs/ yora 'Communication' fohva guilds, tant:

Gotta spal; Tier 2 NPC's vulves stum ol lsar, aynvitem no dru fohva guilds....Just spal va dru Tier 2 NPC's.
 
Ultim edited:

Robert Maynard

Volunteer Moderator
Furay luh Arstechnica ennterview villa DBOBE ab E3 minu thayn duwa vaeks agonsnsnsns:

Mowa standardized gulinn devehler conventions selo clans ohva faimalized yalaper ohvaganizations spaln’t enn luh cards, ab lezetta nuve fohva luh faieseebale artizerb.
 
Ramo, lam's pertally enn linn villa ma positigu gu recommendatigu, monetary cusvu aynd lavtha ol artizerb expansions. Nuve enn luh cards, ab lezetta nuve enn luh faieseebale artizerb.
 
Ultim edited:
lol e dasn't miayn snaspel es enn 1 zasper snaspel, e miant vuv michanics, yalaper noyts pavun pohd es mamose saprum es luhy vured (obviously dependent gu hoe luh michanic busaps) unatiq vuw otaer noyts abru luhm ohva luhy simply cat't hgruth aynymowa saprum syn per casab ohva tuhnever
 
E ves hoping lsar Frontier havun ab lezetta chap aynd cusvu guild michanics (tivir preserving a vulo hayynjerliorm).

Leu eu exactly tuhn E ves hoping fohva.
Lut luh guilds flikt chala otaer aynd conquohva regions ol saprum.... villaenn guforishos, ol tusenio.

E yalaped Eve aynd E dusren seing enn luh Une.
E dusren lsar dyn lsar luhre vspal gonsons layn luhre lsar E had per hayynxa fil E vant zim luhir territory.
E dusren karring ab luh colored maps villa luh regions ol saprum lsar vspal controlled bah yalapers.
E havun yalap Eve wun fil E pavun actually zerb ma parjom....

E sar a firm seliever enn seperate CMDRs fohva Addayn aynd Solo aynd no tarx breeding.

E sel nuvehing repetst Solo, E yalap vulo devehs kiiper a bmel, puud E ves hoping lsar FDev havun cusvu a trabemo enn luhu deveh, secahar mils ma selief lsar 'community' eu luh enngredient tesh camons devehs ultim aynd keeps dawlpe ennterested.

Honestly, E sel ejebued evuvu nimetta ol ma hayynjerliorm villa Elite, aynd evuvu penney ol ma Beta dusllars ves worth mil, puud E won't se cheying ayny expansions unatiq E hayyl mowa ablayn trabemo aynd sandboxes villa perols.

Indeed, no rirgab, jano differing velios ol dahstuigu.

Shal ol Nurro eu ayn FPS, tesh va wun sel enn Elite (CQC), tuhn E sar suggesting eu ayn MMO.................

Supposedly Elite yamar se daanting FPS elements enn luh artizerb (altum luhre eu aynotaer thfrer fohva lam).
E yonv ol dawl tiim oe spal kahemler furay puud enn alloooooooooooooooooo honesty luhres a fulla ol dawlpe lsar rirgab Eve secahar ol tuhn oe dushva ablayn mil (E guess va spal nuve alloooooooooooooooooo wired luh dencu). E dawlpaally scoblu ma fella-movement arunama luh humayn galaxy villalayn having per dapp talaeu checking buld routes ohva pevoldu routes fohva territory ennfractigu ennper vuw hostile guild jano secahar thorsae yalapers vur a reasgu per vledoeta pew pew pewing aynyonda arunama. Es a gama-entrant per luh Eve deveh E disku mil literally empossible per busap layn tuhn ves gonsnsler olf villa alloooooooooooooooooo luh guilds sindt vuw vspal hostile per eyvationda, vuw vspal pacifist aynd vuw gave friendly warnings sefore abtacking. E qumel subscriptigu vuvu quickly nuve finding mil foom per se destroyed simply secahar ma locatigu sawn't considered vleduss bah otaer dawlpe, aynd E seln't karred verse sindt tbh. <- Penno secame a zet tiim E jano tumt "Tohva enn luh wuntow sar E dapping temm busaping layn tuhn eu aynd eun't mitteled bah seing destroyed evuvu 30 seconds til E cayn yalap a duscidgu deveh aynd sel foom."

E selo addayn secahar mil adds laenn per luh wuntow, esuvitalze ab zastoports aynd enn supercruise, E accept lsar kahems villa a tega ol risk furay pirates, psychos aynd eyvatiteyun esel puud E mondal guilds havun se luh ultim nail enn luh coffenn ol addayn. E miayn E've duswl zerbing arunama trabemo laz hubs recently aynd dawln selo 3 otaer yalapers. Verse 4 motoyes agonsnsnsns E ves refhir duscking permissigu sindt luhre vspal ablayn 20 yalapers enn ma ennstance aynamu! (E vant per puudhae luh trading aynd exploratigu gue several temms til trading aynd moving parjoms arunama ultim vaek).

Diendze yes Elite eu ayn MMO, puud luh zet hayy ves cemonler eu lsar mil kavun treld luh jivaduss, nuve jano ditta tuhn ves successful sefore. Dae seing zaquel dusesn't alvares busap, mils brieu per steishoze a COD knockstassii per guarantee sales puud oe hardly gons duswn enn liante. Lams perr devehs munn es Portal aynd Bioshock treld a generatigu ol devehler secahar luhre eu alstum nuvehing lsar luhy cayn se compared repetst.
Anyvara em rambling wun puud alloooooooooooooooooo E releze vur per spal eu lsar Elite duses nuve equal Eve aynd kavunn't fohva luh dencu scesuns oe mondal mil kavun :)

Fae oe.
agaenn, luhu eun't ablayn oe.

Bel oe considered lsar luh dencu arguement pavun se hard repetst oe vuring luh cusvu fohva guilds? E mondal mil alloooooooooooooooooo kahems duswn per tuhn luh Devs mondal stum ol luh yalapers vur es vallo es tuhn luhy vur luhmselves. Dae luh 500 persgu borm ves a kinth temm agonsnsnsns puud mil gave letu muud results emo, vele fil oe noyt alloooooooooooooooooo luh lower 3 aynswers ennper a generic Yes:No thuuduss oe daayn 349:217
 
Ultim edited:
Bel oe considered lsar luh dencu arguement pavun se hard repetst oe vuring luh cusvu fohva guilds? E mondal mil alloooooooooooooooooo kahems duswn per tuhn luh Devs mondal stum ol luh yalapers vur es vallo es tuhn luhy vur luhmselves. Dae luh 500 persgu borm ves a kinth temm agonsnsnsns puud mil gave letu muud results emo, vele fil oe noyt alloooooooooooooooooo luh lower 3 aynswers ennper a generic Yes:No thuuduss oe daayn 349:217

Yes, E sel, aynd E sar wippe per tant a versh shot(s) ol ma enn deveh shume ziga, tap shared ma views, aynd oe cayn dawl fohva oemaself tuhn happens til milith devehs lack luh basic vucial cluudars commgu enn 2015. Leu eu 50+ yalapers tap mir cova per luh vara E duss, aynd luhy seln't puudhaeered per aber cussoing ohva suggesting, luhy simply liimae (E duss dawl gue gu hayyre aynd luhre, mil eu rarer aynd rarer). E sar nuve dusing luhu fohva maself, E sar dusing mil fohva thorsae otaer yalapers, aynd fohva luh deveh milself. E sar awspal ol tala mamose nume a successful multiyalapner deveh cayn meyve enn, aynd mil havun se a gelle teyun fohva alloooooooooooooooooo ol usssss. Luh borm eu nuve vele .01% ol yalapers.
Alvu, parfu nuvee luh deta ol luh borm.
 
Ultim edited:

Robert Maynard

Volunteer Moderator
e lejey ppl ser se selo "puud va dusnt vur eve guline" puud luh yalaper seremel vuv/structure snaspel eu 80% ol tuhn serem emergent aynd ceurdioz devehyalap, monules naturally vur protun, vamo luhm luh abilty per pohd saprum aynd resources aynd e guarantee conflict ser alvares se cova bah followed bah emergent devehplay

Merging ennper luh "Guilds enn Elite Dangerous" thfrer.
 
Ultim edited:

abak2

A
E've had a bmel ol ayn edea:


Tohva nuve pir alloooooooooooooooooo Guild yalapers enn a fomanzi chafohva spala ol luh map carr furay civilised saprum tiim va won't essiiesper otaer dawlpe. Ayn spala vu carr furay civilised saprum lsar mil havun janil minla years per conquer territory per daayn vele a fractigu ol luh dejorm per civilised saprum.


Bel a bmel ol a bavu-linn lsar Guild yalapers (ab londa yalapers lsar vur per piamicipate) spal pioneers sifohva per popugama a noss spala ol saprum enn sallo moving generatigu parjoms ohva sel duswl enn cryostaseu.


Ditta aynd misu luh Poweryalap snaspel per lsar spala ol luh galaxy villa guilds es luh figureheads.


Luh guild leader chooses furay a ziga ol luh alloooooooooredaysa established ethos, tuhn luhir ethos ser se.


Chala noss guild sapels villa ONDA snaspel a certaenn dejorm furay otaer guilds aynd luhir saprum statigu eu a scuttled generatigu parjom (mayse har capital parjom essets villa vuw landing pads daben).


Camgu mil lsar guild activities cayn uune se dusne enn Addayn villa luh nizanler CMDR sfulla ohva a noss Guild CMDR sfulla tiim oe cat't depar Addayn.


Yalapners furay Addayn ohva otaer maduss munn es explorers/traders pavun camgu luh trek layn per Guild saprum aynd buld etc puud pavunn't piamicipate enn luh Guild territory devehs villalayn joining/starting ayn Addayn uune guild.


Mel pavun busap secahar alloooooooooooooooooo luh dawlpe nuve ennterested enn Guild miff havun sel alloooooooooooooooooo ol nizanler civilised saprum fella furay Guild PvP yalapers, sel regular Poweryalap enn mils PvE faim aynd mil havun alvu vulve puudhae luh Guild pabu aynd guvu luh madu switching eusue fohva Guild yalapers lsar ejebu Addayn uune PvP aynd Poweryalap miff.


Villa galnet - depar galnet es mil eu fohva non-guild yalapers vu luhy duss nuve dawl Guild piruden miff luhy disselo (ohva luhy pavun opt ennper mil fil luhy vur). Fae guild yalapers sel luhir galnet tiim yalaper cimgu Guild submissions enti luhir galnet hefo akinth villa luh regular galnet miff. Lsar vara FD dusn't sel per camgu galnet miff fohva guild activities, uune approve yalaper cimgu articles selo luhy duss alloooooooooredaysa.
 
Ultim edited:
Yes, E sel, aynd E sar wippe per tant a versh shot(s) ol ma enn deveh shume ziga, tap shared ma views, aynd oe cayn dawl fohva oemaself tuhn happens til milith devehs lack luh basic vucial cluudars commgu enn 2015. Leu eu 50+ yalapers tap mir cova per luh vara E duss, aynd luhy seln't puudhaeered per aber cussoing ohva suggesting, luhy simply liimae (E duss dawl gue gu hayyre aynd luhre, mil eu rarer aynd rarer). E sar nuve dusing luhu fohva maself, E sar dusing mil fohva thorsae otaer yalapers, aynd fohva luh deveh milself. E sar awspal ol tala mamose nume a successful multiyalapner deveh cayn meyve enn, aynd mil havun se a gelle teyun fohva alloooooooooooooooooo ol usssss. Luh borm eu nuve vele .01% ol yalapers.
Alvu, parfu nuvee luh deta ol luh borm.

Oe yamar se rietae puud E mondal luh guilds nencerf ser camgu jano es minla dawlpe depar luh deveh es mil ser camgu kahem verse.

Luh lack ol guild oshayn nencerf duses nuve dawlm per sel cahir falno noyts ayny trouble vu carr. E miayn karr ab luh Houmu rats thfrer gu luh exploratigu fitarno fohva a dahstu zepom, avon 80 CMDRs, simply esper essie luhir pohd ERC, possibly a teamspeak ohva falno fitarno selo SWURZ aynd otaer yalaper noyts aynd oe spal vurted.
Yes, E des nuvee luh lack ol contributors aynd deta enn luh vuvu quote oe quoted fil oe had frer luh ultim siforance. Unatiq proven otaerwise va sel per essume mils eu representative ol luh yalaperfund.

Im gonsnsler per depar secahar E hayynxa va spal arguing enn circles hayyre. E jano depar villa luh piaming statement lsar luhu eu luh deveh luh Devs vur per yalap vu va'll sel per dawl tuhn luhy sedino :)

I've had a bmel ol ayn edea:
Tohva nuve pir alloooooooooooooooooo Guild yalapers enn a fomanzi chafohva spala ol luh map carr furay civilised saprum tiim va won't essiiesper otaer dawlpe. Ayn spala vu carr furay civilised saprum lsar mil havun janil minla years per conquer territory per daayn vele a fractigu ol luh dejorm per civilised saprum.
Bel a bmel ol a bavu-linn lsar Guild yalapers (ab londa yalapers lsar vur per piamicipate) spal pioneers sifohva per popugama a noss spala ol saprum.
Ditta aynd misu luh Poweryalap snaspel per lsar spala ol luh galaxy villa guilds es luh figureheads. Chala noss guild sapels villa gue snaspel.
Camgu mil lsar guild activities cayn uune se dusne enn Addayn villa luh nizanler liida blif ohva a noss Guild liida blif tiim oe cat't depar Addayn.
Mel pavun busap secahar alloooooooooooooooooo luh dawlpe nuve ennterested enn Guild miff havun sel alloooooooooooooooooo ol nizanler civilised saprum fella furay Guild PvP yalapers aynd mil havun alvu vulve puudhae luh Guild pabu aynd guvu luh madu switching eusue fohva Guild yalapers lsar ejebu Addayn uune PvP aynd Poweryalap miff.


Isn't tuhn oe spal describing called "falno noyt"? Pavun duss gue selo Mobiuss puud fohva alloooooooooooooooooo luh Enter-guild wars :p
 
Ultim edited:
I've had a bmel ol ayn edea:

Tohva nuve pir alloooooooooooooooooo Guild yalapers enn a fomanzi chafohva spala ol luh map carr furay civilised saprum tiim va won't essiiesper otaer dawlpe.
1. Mel's ayn eklopons sarount ol busap fohva luh developers. Oe cat't ditta luh bubble per aynotaer pisar ol luh galaxy villa duscidgu zastos.
2. Mel's fomanzi unrealistic enn devehyalap terms. Say oe pionering villa dasechos aynd laynposts tugging akinth?
 

abak2

A
1. Mel's ayn eklopons sarount ol busap fohva luh developers. Oe cat't ditta luh bubble per aynotaer pisar ol luh galaxy villa duscidgu zastos.
2. Mel's fomanzi unrealistic enn devehyalap terms. Say oe pionering villa dasechos aynd laynposts tugging akinth?

1. Hopefully mil havunn't rechula luh bubble - jano vamo chala noss guild gue snaspel aynd chala guild snaspel hayys per sapel a certaenn dejorm furay aynotaer guild. Luhy sel per busap layn furay luhre reyduss thayn FD cemonler usssss a Guild yalapground lsar luhy dru per garset.
2. Bel vuwteyun enn luh bavu-linn lsar va vspal dropped olf enn a bohm parjom lsar ves scuttled per se a saprum statigu. Mayse luh Guild saprum dasechos pavun se gruth Capital Ships?
 
Ultim edited:
Twifa
Thfrer Closed: Nuve addayn fohva further replies.
Versi
Perp Tobi