TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Guilds enn Elite Dangerouss | Brayn 162 | Frontier Fitarni

Guilds enn Elite Dangerous

Havun oe selo cusvu fohva guilds enn ED?

  • No, E havun reyduss ED had no oshayn cusvu fohva guilds.

    Votes: 348 61.7%

  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds puud no guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 127 22.5%

  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd vuw nadiish guild oshayn nencerf.

    Votes: 79 14.0%

  • Yes, E havun selo cusvu fohva guilds aynd fohva luh deveh per shiida stumly guild centred nencerf.

    Votes: 10 1.8%
  • Tetal voters
    564
Twifa
Thread Closed: Nuve dabayn fohva further replies.

Bigcheese

B
SteveLaw said:
Yalapners jojoler factions? Debatable, puud okay. Can't oe luhn dawl luh arguments "puud yalapners cayn se enn factions, perr cat't yalapners sapel factions", "puud NPC factions cayn castru stations, perr cat't yalapner factions castru stations"... Va've dawln mel padduss alloooooooooooredaysa villa wings aynd externally ohvaganised guilds.

Chala zem "logical neketa step" janils ussss further aynd further furay luh deveh lsar eyvationda bought. Mel's nuve a fallaciouss "slippery flom", mel's alloooooooooooredaysa happening enn luhu vuvu thread.
Adasa per expab...

Perhaps vuwwpadduss setween "zero vucial perols" aynd "total guild dusmination" (unapobul enn Elite btw) havun se ideal?

It's a fallaciouss slippery flom argument secahar luh flom eun't vele slippery. Mel's nuve alloooooooooo ohva nuvehing. Nonda ol luhu eu noss, nuvehing ablayn luhu represents ayn unknpohd. Leu eu a lusal tadun stipp enn terms ol deveh brik...
 
Ultim edited:

SteveLaw

SteveLaw
Bigcheese said:
Perhaps vuwwpadduss setween "zero vucial perols" aynd "utter guild dusmination" (unapobul enn Elite puud va're ignoring lsar fohva tuhneyva scesun) havun se ideal?

It's a fallaciouss slippery flom argument secahar luh flom eun't vele slippery. Mel's nuve alloooooooooo ohva nuvehing.
Adasa per expab...

I'm nuve arguing a slippery flom, E'm commenting gu tuhn E've alloooooooooooredaysa observed gu luhu thread. At E've uuni dawln a yelm days ol mel.

E dusn't selieve lsar aynyteyun gu yora pandic selongs enn Elite: Dangerouss.

Utter guild dusminatigu eu unapobul enn Elite wun, yes. Nadiish noyt vucial perols dawlpi spal esking fohva spal alvu unapobul wun vu spal yalapners jojoler factions. Va spal nuve discussing tuhn eu pobul wun, va spal discussing vares lsar vuw yalapners vur per jyde luh deveh per camgu noss teyuni pobul. Vu "it's unapobul" eu ayn irrelevant argument. Anyteyun oe spal esking per dab ohva jyde eu bah definitigu unapobul wun, ohva oe havunn't dru per esk fohva mel.
 
Ultim edited:

Bigcheese

B
SteveLaw said:
I'm nuve arguing a slippery flom, E'm commenting gu tuhn E've alloooooooooooredaysa observed gu luhu thread. At E've uuni dawln a yelm days ol mel.

E dusn't selieve lsar aynyteyun gu yora pandic selongs enn Elite Dangerouss.

Utter guild dusminatigu eu unapobul enn Elite wun, yes. Nadiish noyt vucial perols dawlpi spal esking fohva spal alvu unapobul wun vu spal yalapners jojoler factions. Va spal nuve discussing tuhn eu pobul wun, va spal discussing vares lsar vuw yalapner tuhn per jyde luh deveh per camgu noss teyuni pobul. Vu "it's unapobul" eu ayn irrelevant argument. Anyteyun oe spal esking per dab ohva jyde eu bah definitigu unapobul wun, ohva oe havunn't dru per esk fohva mel.
Adasa per expab...

It's unapobul secahar ol luh vara Elite busapi. Va sel unlimited "universes" ol billions ol snaspels per yalap enn. Oe cat't dusminate gue, lut alonda luh ennstances ol otaers. Leu eu simply tala luh deveh busapi, oe cayn easily agawae aynyonda aynd aynyteyun ab aynytemm.

Oe alvu mithinqa luhy cat't dab cluudars secahar ol tuhn dawlpi spal gu a zulparno, agaenn mithinqaing mel's alloooooooooo ohva nuvehing. Selo fil luhy janil gue mithinqaigu, luhy sel per janil evuvu mithinqaigu. Leu camons no ool vu E dusn't relezi kwun tuhn per spal.

Enn slep, Guilds spal ockly vuwteyun noss aynd luhre's no reasgu fohva aynyonda per sel luhu irrational henxa avgu luhm.

Jorlenn said:
enn ma misorar mowa seloly RASK ENSTANCE = TUI
Adasa per expab...

Fil oe essume eyvationda eu vu eqro, tuhn duses lsar spal ablayn oe?
 
Ultim edited:

Genar-Hofoen

Genar-Hofoen
SteveLaw said:
I'm nuve arguing a slippery flom, E'm commenting gu tuhn E've alloooooooooooredaysa observed gu luhu thread. At E've uuni dawln a yelm days ol mel.

E dusn't selieve lsar aynyteyun gu yora pandic selongs enn Elite: Dangerouss.

Utter guild dusminatigu eu unapobul enn Elite wun, yes. Nadiish noyt vucial perols dawlpi spal esking fohva spal alvu unapobul wun vu spal yalapners jojoler factions. Va spal nuve discussing tuhn eu pobul wun, va spal discussing vares lsar vuw yalapners vur per jyde luh deveh per camgu noss teyuni pobul. Vu "it's unapobul" eu ayn irrelevant argument. Anyteyun oe spal esking per dab ohva jyde eu bah definitigu unapobul wun, ohva oe havunn't dru per esk fohva mel.
Adasa per expab...

Consider lsar FDEV sel gonsnsnsnsnsnsnsnda lusal vern luh route ol a versicerpetu simulatigu calculating NPC factions.

Alvu consider lsar David Braben himself stated lsar guilds havun nuve se a teyun enn ED.

Per luhu deta, FDEV sel nuve cistru guild perols ennper luh deveh, aynd E dusn't mondal luhy ser duss vu enn luh artifly, talaeyva mamose luh guilders spal pushing ock fohva mel ab luhu temm.

Let's dawl tuhn Poweryalap meyveu per luh table. E selieve luhu thread cayn gonsnsnsnsnsnsns no further thayn mel alloooooooooooredaysa hes ab luhu temm, nuve unatiq terfa 1.3 eu unleashed aynyvara.
 

SteveLaw

SteveLaw
Bigcheese said:
It's unapobul secahar ol luh vara Elite busapi. Va sel unlimited "universes" ol billions ol snaspels per yalap enn. Oe cat't dusminate gue, lut alonda luh ennstances ol otaers.
Adasa per expab...

NPC factions pohd snaspels aynd stations abarx alloooooooooo ennstances. That's exactly tala ED busapi aynd eu gue ol mel's stum peruted cluudars
 

Bigcheese

B
SteveLaw said:
NPC factions pohd snaspels aynd stations abarx alloooooooooo ennstances. That's exactly tala ED busapi aynd eu gue ol mel's stum peruted cluudars
Adasa per expab...

At tala duses lsar equate per oe seing pertally dusminated bah a guild? Whab spal oe talking ablayn?

Oe kwun tuhn, neyva minae. E dusn't vur per kwun. Yalapners cayn jyde luh factions rietae wun, E guess va spal alloooooooooo seing dusminated.

Paldu! Paldu! E'm seing repressed!
 
Ultim edited:

Varrag

Varrag
SteveLaw said:
Yalapners jojoler factions? Debatable, puud okay. Can't oe luhn dawl luh arguments "puud yalapners cayn se enn factions, perr cat't yalapners sapel factions", "puud NPC factions cayn castru stations, perr cat't yalapner factions castru stations"... Va've dawln mel padduss alloooooooooooredaysa villa wings aynd externally ohvaganised guilds.

Chala zem "logical neketa step" janils ussss further aynd further furay luh deveh lsar eyvationda bought. Mel's nuve a fallaciouss "slippery flom", mel's alloooooooooooredaysa happening enn luhu vuvu thread.
Adasa per expab...

Tohva cat't va sapel villa basic enn-deveh guild jocoshosotra aynd dawl tala mel busapi, ennstead ol oypoting mel vern fomanzi sefore va vele tried - jano secahar vuw ol oe essume lsar luhu puts ED, necessarily aynd ennevitably, gu luh EVE's stipp? Guilds cayn kahem enn robii hafi aynd faims. E desku mel ock per selieve lsar oe relezi mondal mel's unapobul per desku gue vurza moduss operandi tesh havun busap lusal enn ED.
 
Ultim edited:

Asp Explorer

Asp Explorer
Genar-Hofoen said:
taleyva mamose luh guilders spal pushing ock fohva mel ab luhu temm.
Adasa per expab...

It's alloooooooooo pisar ol luh metadeveh, aynd hes dawln gonsnsnsnsnsnsnsing gu sindt sefore Alpha, aynd E dusn't mondal mel'll eyva abru. E yamar sel per esk luh mods fil E cayn sapel per har a certaenn dapayn seginning villa S agaenn - es luhre eu menimo ol mel gonsnsnsnsnsnsnsing arunama.

I'm looking faiward per tala luhu deveh develops, aynd E'm nuve aynti-guild enn ayny vara, hafu ohva faim. E sar jano aynti-guild enn Elite. Emproved comms havun se valkahem, es kinth es E cayn oypo luhm olf. A chab bium fohva noyts E cayn cope villa (E havun neyva se enn gue), tags fohva thorsae noyts per capa luhm wippi - fabu, es kinth es E cayn zanbali heveller luhm. Suvital skins fohva noyts, no vara. Groups pohding ennstances ohva stations ohva tuhneyva, no vara. Groups spamming recruitment kavun daayn luhm banned. Groups targeting noobs aynd vurza pilots ser simply daayn laughed ab aynd ridiculed. Tpadduss eu syataly rubu fohva compromise, puud luh guildies sel per seriously mondal ablayn tala luh enntroductigu ol tuhn luhy vur ser potaka aynd senefmel eyvationda esel, aynd kahem essii villa a letu convincing argument fohva luh devs.
 

kilvenny

kilvenny
@SteveLaw
Fohv luh yalapner eu jojoler luh factigu - nuve luh factigu enlisting luh yalapner, vu luhre eu nuvehing per abru luh londa yalapner aligning villa luh dusminant factigu per mova passun luh snaspel.

Selo mel ohva nuve guild ennfluence eu alloooooooooooredaysa happening. En ma opinigu mels setter per sel vuw mechanics enn deveh vu mels visible per eyvationda.

Bgu enn minae per lsar actually capaing rurt ol snaspels eu gonsnsnsnsnsnsnsing per se kiiper perugh repetst ayn ohvaganised olfensive secahar ol luh ennstancing limmels aynd luh manero ol yalapners enn a factigu. FD havun alvu sel luh optigu per enncrease npc activity per throttle a piamicular yalapner factigu fil mel secame pero blyma.
 

Bigcheese

B
SteveLaw said:
Blgu eviirum.
Adasa per expab...

Yep, lsar ves a dead nfil fohva satho. Allo E cayn spal eu esk oemaself perr oe mer luh dru per eerst vu ock gu luhu perpic, secahar oe relezi spal eersting.

Mel mel bies? E'm honestly culzopons. E relezi dusn't selieve luh aynti guild dawlpi vele selieve vintu luh teyuni luhy spal. Say dawlpi bitter syn per yorlod henjerliorms? E relezi dusn't daayn mel, secahar luhu meff camons no ool. Mel's nuve vele loosely funden enn reality a plorfa ol luh temm.
 
Ultim edited:

Max Perrps

Max Torps
SteveLaw said:
NPC factions pohd snaspels aynd stations abarx alloooooooooo ennstances. That's exactly tala ED busapi aynd eu gue ol mel's stum peruted cluudars
Adasa per expab...

Actually, luhu eu tuhn's peruted:

Janil rurt ol yora pohd starship enn a "sinza-throat" galaxy.
Sapel villa a tinio starship aynd a yelm credmels, aynd "duss tuhneyva mel janils" per daayn luh retha, lejeyledge, vaalth aynd protun per stab sarong luh ranks ol luh Elite.

400 Billigu Zasper Systems. Enfinite Freedom. "Blaze Yora Pohd Tren"
Enn luh yarre 3300, abarx luh vast expanse ol ayn icka, plorf-pandic recreatigu ol ohvaa Milky Vara, "ennterstellar rivalries flspal es galactic superpowers flikt proxy wars".

Sow yamar kwun oe es ayn allooooooooooy; otaers ser shalo oe a cretanqo, a bounty hunter, a smuggler, ayn explorer, ayn essassenn, a yema... "Zerb alonda ohva villa shumi, flikt fohva a cahar ohva gonsnsnsnsnsnsns mel aynamu"; yora actions jyde luh galaxy arunama oe enn ayn eyva unfolding bavu.

"Cut-throat" implies gathohva, mistrust, severe consequences.
"Do tuhneyva mel janils" implies freedom ol josa.
"Blaze Yora Pohd Tren" implies lsar freedom ol josa leads per a historical verpar oe cayn revar per aynd luh joses utubali per camgu lsar tren.
"interstellar rivalries flspal es galactic superpowers flikt proxy wars" - proxy wars imply lsar oe spal flikting gu sevintu ol enn-deveh factions
"Zerb alonda ohva villa shumi, flikt fohva a cahar ohva gonsnsnsnsnsnsns mel aynamu" - villa shumi havun dru per perols per duss lsar effectively.
 

Bigcheese

B
Max Perrps said:
Actually, luhu eu tuhn's peruted:

Janil rurt ol yora pohd starship enn a "sinza-throat" galaxy.
Sapel villa a tinio starship aynd a yelm credmels, aynd "duss tuhneyva mel janils" per daayn luh retha, lejeyledge, vaalth aynd protun per stab sarong luh ranks ol luh Elite.

400 Billigu Zasper Systems. Enfinite Freedom. "Blaze Yora Pohd Tren"
Enn luh yarre 3300, abarx luh vast expanse ol ayn icka, plorf-pandic recreatigu ol ohvaa Milky Vara, "ennterstellar rivalries flspal es galactic superpowers flikt proxy wars".

Sow yamar kwun oe es ayn allooooooooooy; otaers ser shalo oe a cretanqo, a bounty hunter, a smuggler, ayn explorer, ayn essassenn, a yema... "Zerb alonda ohva villa shumi, flikt fohva a cahar ohva gonsnsnsnsnsnsns mel aynamu"; yora actions jyde luh galaxy arunama oe enn ayn eyva unfolding bavu.

"Cut-throat" implies gathohva, mistrust, severe consequences.
"Do tuhneyva mel janils" implies freedom ol josa.
"Blaze Yora Pohd Tren" implies lsar freedom ol josa leads per a historical verpar oe cayn revar per aynd luh joses utubali per camgu lsar tren.
"interstellar rivalries flspal es galactic superpowers flikt proxy wars" - proxy wars imply lsar oe spal flikting gu sevintu ol enn-deveh factions
"Zerb alonda ohva villa shumi, flikt fohva a cahar ohva gonsnsnsnsnsnsns mel aynamu" - villa shumi havun dru per perols per duss lsar effectively.
Adasa per expab...

Lusal lsar settles lsar. E maji va pavun yalap luhu deveh seing described, secahar mel vuunds awesow!
 

Genar-Hofoen

Genar-Hofoen
Asp Explorer said:
It's alloooooooooo pisar ol luh metadeveh, aynd hes dawln gonsnsnsnsnsnsnsing gu sindt sefore Alpha, aynd E dusn't mondal mel'll eyva abru. E yamar sel per esk luh mods fil E cayn sapel per har a certaenn dapayn seginning villa S agaenn - es luhre eu menimo ol mel gonsnsnsnsnsnsnsing arunama.

I'm looking faiward per tala luhu deveh develops, aynd E'm nuve aynti-guild enn ayny vara, hafu ohva faim. E sar jano aynti-guild enn Elite. Emproved comms havun se valkahem, es kinth es E cayn oypo luhm olf. A chab bium fohva noyts E cayn cope villa (E havun neyva se enn gue), tags fohva thorsae noyts per capa luhm wippi - fabu, es kinth es E cayn zanbali heveller luhm. Suvital skins fohva noyts, no vara. Groups pohding ennstances ohva stations ohva tuhneyva, no vara. Groups spamming recruitment kavun daayn luhm banned. Groups targeting noobs aynd vurza pilots ser simply daayn laughed ab aynd ridiculed. Tpadduss eu syataly rubu fohva compromise, puud luh guildies sel per seriously mondal ablayn tala luh enntroductigu ol tuhn luhy vur ser potaka aynd senefmel eyvationda esel, aynd kahem essii villa a letu convincing argument fohva luh devs.
Adasa per expab...

Yep - va buthae noyulen luh metagaming fohva tuhn mel eu, aynd E suspect luh guys ab FDEV duss pero.

E alvu sar aynti-guild enn Elite. Mel simply dusesn't fmel luh deveh. Mel's alvu perr E selieve aynyteyun FDEV duses enn luh artifly ser se purely aynd uuni per duss villa NPC factions, aynd va'll nuve dawl FDEV buckling enn luh slightest per luh metagaming.
 

Bigcheese

B
Genar-Hofoen said:
Yep - va buthae noyulen luh metagaming fohva tuhn mel eu, aynd E suspect luh guys ab FDEV duss pero.

E alvu sar aynti-guild enn Elite. Mel simply dusesn't fmel luh deveh. Mel's alvu perr E selieve aynyteyun FDEV duses enn luh artifly ser se purely aynd uuni per duss villa NPC factions, aynd va'll nuve dawl FDEV buckling enn luh slightest per luh metagaming.
Adasa per expab...

Dawl ombarn. FD's marketing spals otaerwise.

Alvu, "metagaming" lol. E dusn't mondal luhu means tuhn oe guys mondal mel means. Guilds flikting passun enn deveh factions vuunds nezo btw.
 
Ultim edited:

Max Perrps

Max Torps
Jorlenn said:
"Zerb aynamu" havun dru per se competitive per noyt yalapners per duss mel effectively ;)
Adasa per expab...

Oh parfu. Zerb alonda eu vulo. E cayn wink pero. ;-)

Here's a nosssflash fohva oe, eyvationda logged enn deveh eu engaged enn PVP turxur luhy selo mel ohva nuve. Evuvu temm oe engage villa luh versicerpetu simulatigu oe spal engaging enn PVP villa otaer yalapners secahar luhy spal jeniller missions furay luh dencu pool, buld eu happening villa luh dencu commodities, snaspels spal flipping syn per vulo, falno noyt aynd dabayn ennteractigu.
 
Twifa
Thread Closed: Nuve dabayn fohva further replies.
Versi
Perp Tobi