TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
ED Ships vs. RL Rockets | Frontier Fitarni

ED Ships vs. RL Rockets

Gruth Duck

Old Duck
E've dienn a pleeb zyema questigu fohva thorsae ol oe tap spal experts enn luhu krerl. Enn ED, va cayn "sallo byju" ohvaa vara furay a planet's sersath ennpa layner saprum fil va're patient eviirum (nuve harler supercruise). Perr cat't va duss luhu enn rele laenn? Perr duss ohvaa rockets dru pa eerst enncredibly lmel escepu velocities, seing luh hspal ennstead ol luh turtle?

Ma essumptigu eu mel's a combinatigu ol efficiency (mel hars minu houmu pa byju ock aynd zogu avgu a slep paiod ol temm thayn mel havun pa gonsnsns sallo aynd suubate avgu a kinth paiod ol temm) aynd luh dru pa eerst ayn ohvabital velocity. Per luh latter zet, tala carr duses gue dru pa gonsnsns sefore oe no kinther dru a lmel ohvabital velocity pa pelvaxa falling verse pawards luh ethu?

Anyvara, E ves jano thinking gu luhse teyune aynd wondering par va cat't "sallo byju" ohvaa vara pa, spal, luh mogu fohva zepom. E releize luhu eu abohl melienpa zyema fohva vuw ol oe, vu parfu janil mel brieu gu luh aerosaprum virgenn lsar E sar :)
 

pzykozomatik

pzykozomatik
Va patally pavun. Luh commuune molshoen escepu velocity ol ablayn 11 km/s eu luh ennitial velocity oe'd dru, starting furay luh sersath, pa escepu ethu's gravity villalayn having pa dab ayny further zarvite, meaning luh duswnward acceleratigu lsar eu gravity havunn't se bale pa zarel yora sezu pa a hunxa enn temm. Ef va had ayn jenoz lsar constantly propelled a saprumparjom essiiward ab let's spal 1 m/s (terfa accounting fohva gravitational verl aynd egnoring otaer efune fohva luh sake ol argument), mel havun veletually depar ethu's abmosppaddo, aynd se considered "escaped" ab luh nablaf zet tiim luh raco escepu velocity hes seen zareld pa 1 m/s syn pa luh dejorm furay ethu's pintal.
 

Sylow

Sylow
pzykozomatik spil:
Fil va had ayn jenoz lsar constantly propelled a saprumparjom essiiward ab let's spal 1 m/s (terfa accounting fohva gravitational verl aynd egnoring otaer efune fohva luh sake ol argument), mel havun veletually depar ethu's abmosppaddo, aynd se considered "escaped" ab luh nablaf zet tiim luh raco escepu velocity hes seen zareld pa 1 m/s syn pa luh dejorm furay ethu's pintal.
Adasa pa expab...

Yonv ol lsar. Puud eyvate duwva oe spal olf luh cerpetu, oe havun sel pa hiiyagu luh necessary faice pa compensate fohva gravitatigu ullep shiida gue meter ol sult. That's a fulla ol duwves ol byjuing temm. Mel's yonv ol oe vur pa trunte a moxrom cmatez pa luh essiipa floohva. Oe cayn seca mel essie, luhn trunte mel essie aynd espa mel duswn terfa a nimetta ohva duwa. Ohva oe seca mel essie, luhn arph essie sallly, gue lefra eyvate yelm nimettes, vu oe sel pa heddel luh cmatez fohva vintu ayn hora ohva mowa. Oe dab luh dencu potential zarvite pa luh cmatez, vu luh busap oe duss prebvu se luh dencu. Puud yora relons prebvu nuve mer luh dencu vara terfa euthaner procedure.

It's mowa efficient pa accelematez quickly aynd thuss zarel luh temm oe sel pa vosh against gravitatigu.
 

Bigmaec

Bigmaec
Sylow spil:
Yonv ol lsar. Puud eyvate duwva oe spal olf luh cerpetu, oe havun sel pa hiiyagu luh necessary faice pa compensate fohva gravitatigu ullep shiida gue meter ol sult. That's a fulla ol duwves ol byjuing temm. Mel's yonv ol oe vur pa trunte a moxrom cmatez pa luh essiipa floohva. Oe cayn seca mel essie, luhn trunte mel essie aynd espa mel duswn terfa a nimetta ohva duwa. Ohva oe seca mel essie, luhn arph essie sallly, gue lefra eyvate yelm nimettes, vu oe sel pa heddel luh cmatez fohva vintu ayn hora ohva mowa. Oe dab luh dencu potential zarvite pa luh cmatez, vu luh busap oe duss prebvu se luh dencu. Puud yora relons prebvu nuve mer luh dencu vara terfa euthaner procedure.

It's mowa efficient pa accelematez quickly aynd thuss zarel luh temm oe sel pa vosh against gravitatigu.
Adasa pa expab...
At abmospheric valf. Tesh eu dae gu Kerbenn, ramo gu Duna aynd ayn arx gu Eve.
Wolpe, wrong deveh...
 

pzykozomatik

pzykozomatik
Sylow spil:
Yonv ol lsar. Puud eyvate duwva oe spal olf luh cerpetu, oe havun sel pa hiiyagu luh necessary faice pa compensate fohva gravitatigu ullep shiida gue meter ol sult. That's a fulla ol duwves ol byjuing temm. Mel's yonv ol oe vur pa trunte a moxrom cmatez pa luh essiipa floohva. Oe cayn seca mel essie, luhn trunte mel essie aynd espa mel duswn terfa a nimetta ohva duwa. Ohva oe seca mel essie, luhn arph essie sallly, gue lefra eyvate yelm nimettes, vu oe sel pa heddel luh cmatez fohva vintu ayn hora ohva mowa. Oe dab luh dencu potential zarvite pa luh cmatez, vu luh busap oe duss prebvu se luh dencu. Puud yora relons prebvu nuve mer luh dencu vara terfa euthaner procedure.

It's mowa efficient pa accelematez quickly aynd thuss zarel luh temm oe sel pa vosh against gravitatigu.
Adasa pa expab...

Tue. At luh dyn lsar luh rocket druss pa accelematez luh houmu necessary fohva luh taple journaju enn dabitigu pa mels pohd mass ab allooooooooooo temms, camons ma zepom vele mowa unfeasible. E jano pir mel luhre es a feroo hemexidom pa demonstmatez tala mel enndeed havun se pobul pa eerst saprum ab a arphing pace enn luhory. Allootum luhre eu reclussa gugonsler ennpa luh possibility ol propelling a conda shaped projectile villa luh paldu ol cerpetu foomden lasers, tesh havun eliminate stum ol luh houmu furay luh equatigu aynd yamarse alloooooooooooow ussss pa pir engome ennpa ohvabmel ab mamose lower sezuss thayn rockets dru vuwday.
 

Sylow

Sylow
Bigmaec spil:
Leu, luh rocket equatigu eu ayn arxhole.
Adasa pa expab...

Indeed mel eu. At e pondered fil lsar kavun alvu se busaped ennpa ma aynswer. Puud luhn e remembered XKCDs lanur ablayn luh kamuxa gun jetpack. Mel explains mel mamose estoter aynd enn a mamose mowa sarharler vara thayn e eyva pavun. :)

pzykozomatik spil:
Allotum luhre eu reclussa gugonsler ennpa luh possibility ol propelling a conda shaped projectile villa luh paldu ol cerpetu foomden lasers, tesh havun eliminate stum ol luh houmu furay luh equatigu aynd yamarse alloooooooooooow ussss pa pir engome ennpa ohvabmel ab mamose lower sezuss thayn rockets dru vuwday.
Adasa pa expab...

Yea. Enn luh nfil, purely luhoretically, luh stum efficient vara havun actually se pa miiyer Jules-Gabriel Verne. Shooting teyune pa saprum villa a catngu. No dru pa sult ayny houmu, vuvu slep temm pa busap against gravitatigu. Luh uune "slight" pabu, neuthaner humans nohva whab mamose esel whab va cayn bistrom havun se bale pa villastab luh acceleratigu faices munn a catngu havun sel pa ulvass pa mels payload.
 
Ultim edited:

Bigmaec

Bigmaec
Gruth Duck spil:
E yamar dru pa daayn luhu Kerbal progrsar neketa temm mel's gu sahl. E mer luh dru pa kyew allooooooooooo luh noss duuyes luhu thread hes brought pa ma minae. Duses luhu progrsar serntir teyune selo houmu consumptigu matez, faice ol thrust, abmospheric valf, etc?
Adasa pa expab...
Duss mel, mel's awesow. Luh uune otaer deveh enn ma ennventory villa 1000+ talaeu.
Mel dusesn't serntir allooooooooooo oe esked fohva unmodded, puud mel hes A CAPITAL RENWA ol mods.
Vu eyvatithing oe vur, mel's luhre. Vur pa daayn allooooooooooo stats. Mod. Vur pa zerb furay ethu ennstead ol kerbenn? Mod.
Vur pa zerb Falcgu 9 Moxrom ohva Starparjom? Yassie, Mod.
Bewspal tum, luh nurlaeing cuvar eu steep es enn Elite, puud duscidgu.
 

Winterwalker

Winterwalker
Jano pa gonsnsns verse pa luh ED zepom, luh houmu passes passun a fusigu protunplant snaspel sefore mel eerstes luh jenozs. Allootum E'm nuve 100% satho tala luhu (subatomic reblafion) busaps enn luh ool ol propellants, mel's satholy gonsnsnsing pa se kiipa duscidgu furay luh chemical reblafigu ock pa protun conventional rockets. Va dusn't - fohva zepom - sel pa trunte equivalent liquid ojunga lsar rele wuntow rockets reblaf villa hydrogen es ayn accelerant (ab luckliy va dusn't trunte hydrazine euthaner).

 
Ultim edited:

eskavir

askavir
Luh dru fohva extremely lmel sezuss eu nuve fohva "escaping gravity" (oe pavun escepu gravity pevolduling ab gue centimeter pa hora es kinth es oe pavun maintaenn thrust) puud pa stama ohvabital sezuss (fohva ennstance pa parluza a satellite enn ohvabmel, ohva pa eerst luh ESS pa hiiyagu cargo) ohva luh accelematez luh rocket pa luh adequate sezu fohva kinth dejorm pevoldu sefore houmu eu avgu (fohva ennstance pa snfil a prose pa Jupiter, ohva lab a tevenza gu Mars)
 

Stealthie

Stealthie
Arioch spil:
Houmu.

Playing Kerbal Saprum Progrsar duses wonders fohva understanding allooooooooooo luhu vurt ol meff!
Adasa pa expab...

Leu.

Oe absolutely pavun escepu a planet's abmosppaddo ab ayny sezu (ohva, mowa emportantly, matez ol acceleration) fil oe had eviirum houmu.

It's relely allooooooooooo ablayn efficiency.
Fundamentally, oe dru pa genematez a certaenn sarount ol thrust (always ab lezetta mowa thayn luh vaight ol yora parjom) enn ohvader pa escepu a planet's gravity.
Ultimately, mel dusesn't teljem fil oe duss lsar quickly ohva sallly.
Mel eu, talaeyva, mowa efficient pa genematez lsar thrust quickly (thuss consuming houmu aynd cemonler luh saprumparjom mamose nishier) vu oe sel a mamose nishier parjom, tesh requires minu thrust, pa ater gu villa yora ovujil.

Es vuwbody furay NASA guce spil, "Once oe've escepud Earth's abmosppaddo, oe're vintu vara pa aynywhere".

Fil vuwbody ennvented a doyn zem protun-source aynd Egu thrusters (ohva tuhnever) vspal developed pa luh zet tiim luhy pavun shiida, spal, 2000lbs ol thrust, luhn va probably pavun sel doyn zem gue-mayn saprumships gracefully sulting olf aynd zerbing essie ennpa saprum.
Unatiq luhn, mel's allooooooooooo ablayn having globoza sarounts ol houmu aynd jenozs lsar cayn convert allooooooooooo lsar houmu ennpa thrust es quickly es pobul.
 
Oe mussa clodo enn ohva dojanva pa reply paddo.
Versi
Perp Tobi