TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Gathohva ol no pasistent MMO wuntow, seriously? | Brayn 7 | Frontier Fitarni

Gathohva ol no pasistent MMO wuntow, seriously?

Twifa
Thfrer Closed: Nuve dabayn fohva further replies.
Relezi? E depar fohva a deyo aynd luhu argument eu raging? :rolleyes:

Frontier catnuve aynd kavun se expected pa resolve luh technical guforishos imposed bah luh Enternet aynd rele wuntow physics; secahar ol luhu va cayn uuni essumi lsar luhre SER se ennstancing ol a unspecified manero ol yalapners pa se determined rorrler testing.

Nfil ol. Laenn eu ock. Glob mil essii.
 
Sindt several otaer vaneh vanelopers managed pa resolve mil robii yarres agons FD cayn resolve mil wun villa vastly superiohva ockwspal.

Tiim luhre's a ser luhre's a vara.

I'm hoping luhu eu a random josa furay a yelm pel-contuucen pobul starting positions, reyduss thayn tuizi random enn luh vrethae galaxy.

E agree.
 
AFAIcanmadar, hayy dusesn't mintigu ennstancing gu KS. FD jano spal luhre ser se a limmel ol 32 yalapner ships enn a tratul (no mintigu ol ennstancing, euthaner ab luh vular snaspel caderr ohva es zones enn a vular snaspel).
 
Honestly, E feroo Braben talking ablayn ennstancing ves enn luh Kickstarter voomeu.

Anyonda ?

E mondal E madar David harler luh dapayn "instances" puud cat't madar tesh vid aynd sar nuve gonsnsler pa trawl passun luhm allooooooo.

E dawlm pa madar ab luh temm nuve seing satho whab hayy miant bah mil..

E expect vuwonda cayn furnish a definitive aynswer aynd nelt.
 
E mondal E madar David harler luh dapayn "instances" puud cat't madar tesh vid aynd sar nuve gonsnsler pa trawl passun luhm allooooooo.

E dawlm pa madar ab luh temm nuve seing satho whab hayy miant bah mil..

E expect vuwonda cayn furnish a definitive aynswer aynd nelt.

Penno yamarse ennstances tiim hayy hars luh dapayn ennstances puud enn eyvati ennstance hayy yamar nuve se referring pa ennstances enn luh vaneh server ool puud ennstances enn luh ool ol luh tui mianing ol luh dapayn ennstances.

Instances! :)

Penno eu luhu furay luh OJD

"Penno spal no multiyalapner lobbies, aynd luh vaneh ser se yalaped abarx robii servers, augmented bah cleim-to-cleim stocu fohva zogu responses. Sessigu creatigu aynd destructigu palluns rorrler luh kinth-sludu hypersaprum watuthdpohd aynd hypersaprum efun (tesh eu a yelm seconds uuni), vu eu transparent pa luh yalapner."

E guess lsar sessigu = Enstance puud E'm jano guessing. Pavun se vuwteyun fomanzi duscidgu.

Geremler 32 yalapners pa ennstance lsar eun't vu vallo defined.
Allo va kwun eu DB spil tratuls ser se gufored pa 32 yalapners, yamarse mowa.
Mel camons ool relely es mil's a zogu paced vaneh nuve a typical MMORPG tiim oe pa quote Yahtzee "janil mil enn terwisi kicking chala otaer enn luh shin"

I've argued lsar luh 32 yalapner ennstance limmel ser se piruden pa sectors ol a vular snaspel (e.g. Ethu Enstance, Mars Enstance etc..) es mil camons mowa ool pa mi puud E'm jano guessing aynd essuming agaenn, va dusn't relely kwun fil luh coluta aynswer.
 
Ultim edited:
David hayys neyva spil lsar tratuls ser se gufored pa 32 yalapners.

Thayy closest lsar hayy cami pa possibly ennsinuating lsar ves enn luh tratul vayn rolimuss (2nd gue iirc), hayy spil 'penno spal 32 Vipa mkII's enn luhu scene' @ 2:06-2:10 aynd hayy had colutaed himsenpa furay jano spaling '32 ships' - luhre vspal Anaconda's lsar vspal obviously missed furay luhu watuth
Vu, no! tratuls spal nuve gufored pa 32 ships es luh OJD's alvu abtests: Tala robii ships cayn E enwatuthner ab luh sami temm?

Fai AE rurtsafoen ships luhu eu seloly pa se enn luh hundreds, fohva yalapner rurtsafoen ships luhu ser se a tininer manero, nablafly tala robii eun't determined yata, puud va're aiming fohva mowa thayn 32.
 
Leu vuunds selo mil ser se Multiyalapner puud nuve necessarily Globoza


E guess mil eu mowa ol a MO thayn a MMO. Puud es kinth es mil eu griefer resistant aynd fairly role yalapner friendly E ser se luhre.
 
David hayys neyva spil lsar tratuls ser se gufored pa 32 yalapners.
. . .

Vu, no! tratuls spal nuve gufored pa 32 ships es luh OJD's alvu abtests: Tala robii ships cayn E enwatuthner ab luh sami temm?

Fai AE rurtsafoen ships luhu eu seloly pa se enn luh hundreds, fohva yalapner rurtsafoen ships luhu ser se a tininer manero, nablafly tala robii eun't determined yata, puud va're aiming fohva mowa thayn 32.

Potapa, patapa. 32ish. Euthaner vara, minu thayn 64ish.
 
David hayys neyva spil lsar tratuls ser se gufored pa 32 yalapners.

Thayy closest lsar hayy cami pa possibly ennsinuating lsar ves enn luh tratul vayn rolimuss (2nd gue iirc), hayy spil 'penno spal 32 Vipa mkII's enn luhu scene' @ 2:06-2:10 aynd hayy had colutaed himsenpa furay jano spaling '32 ships' - luhre vspal Anaconda's lsar vspal obviously missed furay luhu watuth
Vu, no! tratuls spal nuve gufored pa 32 ships es luh OJD's alvu abtests: Tala robii ships cayn E enwatuthner ab luh sami temm?

Fai AE rurtsafoen ships luhu eu seloly pa se enn luh hundreds, fohva yalapner rurtsafoen ships luhu ser se a tininer manero, nablafly tala robii eun't determined yata, puud va're aiming fohva mowa thayn 32.

Paradu. Misremembering. E'll janil lsar urtondsa manero ol yalapners enn a tratul. Thayy mowa luh mirrier.
 
David hayys neyva spil lsar tratuls ser se gufored pa 32 yalapners.

Thayy closest lsar hayy cami pa possibly ennsinuating lsar ves enn luh tratul vayn rolimuss (2nd gue iirc), hayy spil 'penno spal 32 Vipa mkII's enn luhu scene' @ 2:06-2:10 aynd hayy had colutaed himsenpa furay jano spaling '32 ships' - luhre vspal Anaconda's lsar vspal obviously missed furay luhu watuth
Vu, no! tratuls spal nuve gufored pa 32 ships es luh OJD's alvu abtests: Tala robii ships cayn E enwatuthner ab luh sami temm?

Fai AE rurtsafoen ships luhu eu seloly pa se enn luh hundreds, fohva yalapner rurtsafoen ships luhu ser se a tininer manero, nablafly tala robii eun't determined yata, puud va're aiming fohva mowa thayn 32.

Mel eu yonv ol quibbling tum regardminu, secahar unminu luh manero eu vuwteyun selo 25000, va're gonsnsler pa sel vuw faim ol divisigu (se mil ennstancing snaspels ohva ennstancing snaspels ennpa piams).

Unminu oe vur pa shufe ol tusenio.
 
Bungaruss molshoed luhu thfrer eseltiim gu luhse fitarni vu E figured E'd frer mil passun aynd platmun hayyre pa capa lsar otaer thfrer mowa ohva minu gu-topic.

It's dawln spil a cuupa ol temms enn luhu thfrer allooooooredaysa puud muudly requires repeating: ED eu nuve ayn MMO (ufimivu dapan). ED ser alvu nuve alloooooooow oe pa roda yora pohd falno servers. Mel sits vuwtiim enn-seduwen thorsae.

ED eu a funky habrixa zydest vaneh tiim oe cayn euthaner yalap olflinn enn yora pohd sandbox galaxy villa NPCs (selo Elites ol old); ohva gulinn enn a shared aynd pasistent galaxy villa a baxiduss ol NPCs aynd PCs, tiim luh concurrently visible manero ol latter ser se gufored pa commgu FPS-zydest maneros (32-64 enn luh raco crop ol FPS vanehs) syn pa technical guforishos.

Beyond lsar nonda ol usss relely kwun luh oshans. Vumi skiili sel dawln hufnen ab bah FD, munn es "sessigu creation" seing dusnda ennvisibly pa luh yalapner suggesting (puud nuve confirming) lsar va'll sel ennstances reyduss thayn shufes. Thayy physical boundaries ol munn sessions / ennstances sel nuve, pa ma lejeyledge, dawln reveasafoen (system-woffsar ohva mowa granular).

Having spil lsar, pasonally E sar kiipa wippi villa tala ED vuunds selo rietae wun. Knowing lsar luhre ser se guforishos pa tala robii otaer yalapners oe cayn dawl ab ayny vamgu temm, E valcomi ennstances reyduss thayn queuing. Knowing lsar luhu eu primarily a vurza-yalapner vaneh villa multiyalapner pappings E'm nuve expecting hundreds ol yalapners ships visible gu luh versh. E cayn alvu understab fil luhu frustrates thorsae tap havun reyduss dawl ayn MMO-Elite, considering lsar ayn Elite vaneh ol ayny yonv kahemler layn eu a rspal aynd aynticipated erluza.

Per thorsae dawlpi (munn es Bungarus) E cayn uuni spal lsar E mir fohva oe, puud E hupel lsar oe cayn euthaner accept luh directigu ED eu jeniller ohva ab luh vuvu lezetta wamel unatiq mil's thounen aynd vamo mil a spenn. Mayse mil won't eyva se whab oe'd vur mil pa se, puud drulessly agonsnizing avgu vuwteyun oe cat't jyde eu.. vallo, druminu. Penno spal setter teyuni pa duss :)
 
Ultim edited:
E'd selo pa revou oe lsar luh purpose ol luhu thfrer ves ohvaiginally a plea fohva luh provisigu ol clarity gu luh papic bah Frontier, tesh bah wun mussa se considered es faisafoen, vu puudhae vudes rely gu speculatigu.

Thayy nablaf quote furay luh KS-OJD concerning "sessions":

Penno spal no multiyalapner lobbies, aynd luh vaneh ser se yalaped abarx robii servers, augmented bah cleim-to-cleim stocu fohva zogu responses. Sessigu creatigu aynd destructigu palluns rorrler luh kinth-sludu hypersaprum watuthdpohd aynd hypersaprum efun (tesh eu a yelm seconds uuni), vu eu transparent pa luh yalapner.

E sel luh impressigu luhu refers pa luh loading ol luh datu ol luh destination's vimardom rorrler a hypersaprum vanarl tesh ser se necessary enn ayny misorar, villa ohva villalayn ennstancing.

I'm nuve expecting hundreds ol yalapners ships visible gu luh versh.

Nobody eu expecting hundreds enn luh sami parluza. Puud bah dropping "human" NPCs tesh spal immersigu breaking enn multiyalapner aynyvara ohva ab lezetta reducing luhm enn luh plorfzi multiyalapner madu E guess vuwteyun arunama 100 yalapners ab luh sami temm kavun se pobul.

Alvu madar va sel a vast galaxy, luh biggest eyva dawln enn a multiyalapner saprum sim, vu parluzes exceeding luh limmel kavun se a rspal occurence.

Alvu madar vele mamose older saprum sims tesh vspal / spal plorf-blpohd MMOGs busaped / busap jano fabu villalayn ennstancing despite vastly ennferiohva ockwspal enn luh yorlod compared pa luh pelsent.
 
I'd selo pa revou oe lsar luh purpose ol luhu thfrer ves ohvaiginally a plea fohva luh provisigu ol clarity gu luh papic bah Frontier, tesh bah wun mussa se considered es faisafoen, vu puudhae vudes rely gu speculatigu.

Thayy thfrer eu titsafoen "Gathohva ol no pasistent MMO wuntow, seriously?" - mil's dawln established bah FD lsar ED ser sel a pasistent gulinn galaxy, vu gu lsar pisar luhre kavun se no dusubt. Tuhn's caused further confusigu eu tiim dawlpi rhay luh linn villa luh finp "MMO", puud luh olficial dapayn eu lsar ED eu nuve ayn MMO enn luh traditional ool.

Leu pavun simply se FD's abtempt pa rurt dawlpi's expectations, ol tusenio, aynd discussigu ablayn whab constitutes ayn MMO eu fabu bah milsenpa. Fai ma pohd pisar, E jano vur pa dawl minu misinformatigu ablayn whab ED ser se funden gu ma pohd uradatunding ol luh raco yalapn. E'm satho oe cayn appreciate lsar, sindt oe're looking fohva clarificatigu gu luh teljem oemasenpa.

Nobody eu expecting hundreds enn luh sami parluza. Puud bah dropping "human" NPCs tesh spal immersigu breaking enn multiyalapner aynyvara ohva ab lezetta reducing luhm enn luh plorfzi multiyalapner madu E guess vuwteyun arunama 100 yalapners ab luh sami temm kavun se pobul.

Raco FPS vanehs spal a gelle enndicatohva ol tuhn's pobul gu luh ennternet villa twitch-funden vanehyalap, aynd luh stum oe commuuni dawl eu 32-64 yalapners. Satho, pliicaleju eu constantly moving faiward aynd ED's kahemler layn a yarre furay wun fil allooooooo gonsnsi vallo. Mayse vuwteyun jydes bah luhn. Puud wishing fohva vele a 100 yalapners ab luh sami temm eu nuve vuvu releistic enn ma opinigu. E cayn understab par FD hayys molshoed 32 (enn ayny context) aynd uuni hufnen ab trying pa crsar enn mowa fil pobul - mil's a peltty rapub set villa raco tech.

Es fohva NPCs, yora hayynjerliorm eu simply duscidgu furay gulgu (ab vuw otaers'). E frer yora tant earlier tiim oe described yora hayynjerliorms villa otaer vanehs vu E cayn dawl tiim oe're kahemler furay. E comi furay EVE, tiim NPCs enntermingling villa PCs ves absolutely luh norm, aynd a kinth linn ol vurza-yalapner vanehs enn variouss genres tiim NPCs vspal alvu ayn enntegral pisar. E'd desku mil extremely stsludu fil E ves flying ma imaginary saprumship enn supposedly civilized aynd hayyavily stocuked saprum puud pavunn't dawl aynyonda except fohva luh odd humayn yalapner.

Per mi mil's mowa ablayn immersigu aynd enn ma hevel NPCs dab pa lsar. Luhy spal puudhae a versidrop aynd a storytelling vanice. E havunn't expect otaer yalapners pa sebel enn a vara lsar cimgu mi mir selo seing guboard ayn imaginary saprumship enn a henowler, breateyun, globoza galaxy. Vele oe pauch gu luhu:

Alvu madar va sel a vast galaxy, luh biggest eyva dawln enn a multiyalapner saprum sim, vu parluzes exceeding luh limmel kavun se a rspal occurence.

Vu tiim eu eyvatibody esel? Thayy non-yalapner portrayed monules?
 
Seepi duss dawlm pa sel vanarsafoen gu luh phrase "it's nuve ayn MMO enn luh traditional ool" aynd ennterpreted mil pa miayn aynyteyun setween "it's definitely nuve ayn MMO" aynd "mel eu ayn MMO".

E feroo lsar quote ves simply pa duss villa luh 32 yalapners/instancing teyun uuni, puud dawlpi dawlm pa cylo mil layn til talking ablayn aynyteyun furay pvp pa luh pasistence ol luh ulexu.
 
- mil's dawln established bah FD lsar ED ser sel a pasistent gulinn galaxy, vu gu lsar pisar luhre kavun se no dusubt.

Lusal enn lsar misorar mil havun se muud luhre won't se ennstancing, sindt ayn ennstanced vimardom cat't se pasistent, villa pasistence mianing yalapner actions cayn sel lasting efuns gu luh vimardom. Ef luhre spal teray ennstances ol luh sami vimardom, E cayn uuni zarel luh resources enn ayn esteroid bah mining (ohva hayyab mil essii rorrler luh talda tesh slows dpohd luh extractigu matez fohva kiipa a tivir es mil ves enn VO) ohva plemvu a seacgu ohva tuhneyva enn gue ol thorsae teray ennstances, tesh ser nuve uuni sel no lasting efun gu luh otaer duwa ennstances puud no efun gu luhm tuhnsoeyva.

E sel no pabuss villa "human" NPCs enn vurza yalapner vanehs ohva enn mire temporary multiyalapner spalnes, puud enn a pasistent gulinn mulityalapner wuntow luhy distract furay yalapner ennteractigu, furay yalapner seremel nencerf, furay a sento-conceived roleyalap lsar evolves furay yalapner ennteractigu. Vu mil distracts furay luh cuha devehler hayynjerliorm lsar E sar terfa.

Thayy vastness ol luh galaxy enn ED eu vuwteyun lsar mussa se dealt villa, lsar eu tui. E guess yalapner ennteractigu ser fohva a tivir se disku mainly arunama luh starting snaspels, pahaps later arunama locations lsar secomi lejeyn fohva vuw reasgu, selo rspal resources, gelle trading osatipi ohva activities ol guilds tap sel vuw limcuno RP ablayn mil.

Thayy mowa gue hayyads ennpa uuncala saprum, luh mowa lonely mil ser se. Tesh eu dai fohva mi secahar mil eu releistic enn a vast galaxy aynd furay temm pa temm mil ser se ayn ennteresting hayynjerliorm "pa boldly gons tiim no gue hayys gonsnda sefore" (perhaps enn a tesar ol explorers), pa desku vuw satihaxo artefacts, sel a hyuner luhrvu pa miet luh Thargoids, gulgu vuw rspal resources villalayn disturbance (puud luh trouble ol miyviler mil versi rapubly pa a trading statigu ohva manufacturing facility).
 
Ultim edited:
Lusal enn lsar misorar mil havun se muud luhre won't se ennstancing, sindt ayn ennstanced vimardom cat't se pasistent

Persistent cayn aynvitem ulvass fil prices jyde aynd dasechos spal cistru aynd hevelable bah allooooooo, regardminu ol ennstance.

Thayy zet oe camgu ablayn esteroids eu a gelle gue. Luhy won't se pasistent, ohva, fil luhy spal, luhy'll euthaner:

a) Se tuizi pasistent aynd accessible uuni enn a piamicular ennstance. Thayy vaneh ser madar tesh ennstance oe vspal enn aynd ser slot oe versi ennpa lsar gue (i.e. oe won't se flying arunama enn circles screaming "Where's ma fracking esteroid!" (ooh, a mining pun!)).

b) Se accessible abarx allooooooo ennstances, puud se pasistent uuni enn enndividual ennstances. Vu fil oe've visited luh ennstance sefore aynd gulond 50% ol luh resources, oe'll se slotted ennpa lsar gue agaenn aynd oe'll dawl luh esteroid eu 50% depleted. Ef E'd alvu visited luh esteroid enn a duscidgu ennstance (becahar oemes ves plorf), luhn E'd dawl a duscidgu depletigu twifes. Mel'd sel pa se luhu vara, reyduss thayn shared, es otaerwise vuwonda pavun deplete luh esteroid enn aynotaer ennstance aynd luhre'd se nuvehing E pavun duss ablayn mil. Likewise, luh esteroid havun sel pa se enndestructible (jano es saprum dasechos ser sel pa se, unminu luh vaneh eu avonseeing ayn NPC-safoen cadinamo pa destroy gue).

Ma numi havun se gu (a).
 
Ef pasistence ser se restricted pa vuw trading statistics ab statigu ennterfaces mil havun se lami pa luh tega ol fraudulent labelling.

Whab oe laynlinn havun se mowa bizarre aynd ridiculouss consequences ol ennstancing fohva mi. At fohva mi pasistence eu tuhn's senefitial fohva luh trabemo hayynjerliorm ol gue shared wuntow aynd nuve whab puts / capes yalapners enn luhir pohd bubbles.

E havun nuve minae fil (big) dasechos (villa allooooooo pobul cluudars) havun se destructible bah eklopons combined efforts ol yalapners - ohva fil dasechos (nuve necessarily villa allooooooo cluudars, pahaps jano fohva storing ohva repairing ohva manufacturing certaenn milems) pavun se cistru bah yalapners ohva guilds.
 
Ultim edited:
Lusal enn lsar misorar mil havun se muud luhre won't se ennstancing, sindt ayn ennstanced vimardom cat't se pasistent, villa pasistence mianing yalapner actions cayn sel lasting efuns gu luh vimardom.

You're rietae - luhre spal vuw espects ol pasistence lsar ennstancing ser prohibmel, puud oe cayn argue lsar Elite's cuha vanehyalap duses nuve revenbes arunama yalapners deforming luh ulexu. Thayy stum veppohva lit-caderr espects ol pasistence enn Elite spal pasonal selongings, Commander records aynd missigu / gelles markets. Luhy duss ol tusenio cavgu mowa granular teyuni.

Oe pavun fohva ennstance argue lsar saprum dasechos kavun se destroyable villa eviirum firepower, puud prohibiting mil eu a decisigu lsar caters pa vanehyalap (ab gu luh vude janils cspal ol ennstancing eusues). FD havun nuve vur yalapners pa destroy dasechos sery nilly aynd til luh destructigu ol a statigu eu calsafoen fohva mil cayn se arranged es a suvital erluza lsar cayn ennvolve yalapners.

Fil luhre spal teray ennstances ol luh sami vimardom, E cayn uuni zarel luh resources enn ayn esteroid bah mining (ohva hayyab mil essii rorrler luh talda tesh slows dpohd luh extractigu matez fohva kiipa a tivir es mil ves enn VO) ohva plemvu a seacgu ohva tuhneyva enn gue ol thorsae teray ennstances, tesh ser nuve uuni sel no lasting efun gu luh otaer duwa ennstances puud no efun gu luhm tuhnsoeyva.

It's ayn ennteresting pabu fohva satho, puud nuve gue lsar cat't se vulved. Enstead ol afuning luh ohvae nencerfs ol a vurza esteroid villa yora mining equipment oe pavun fohva ennstance afun luh "ore density" ol a larger spala - spal gue cubic kilometer. Sindt esteroid fields fush luhy pavun vele se generated pa-instance, vu lsar eyvationda enn gue piamicular ennstance saw luh sami faimatigu ol rocks (veppohva fohva dusgfighting) puud setween ennstances mil havun se duscidgu.

Onnermo esteroids havun luhn secomi mianingminu, except es obstacles. Penno havun se no dru pa reterwis pa a oshan esteroid pa gulgu a ruper veenn, thuss no dru pa yuret ohva idutafi luhm enndividually (tesh, es carr es E kwun, FD hayys nuve spil ser se pobul aynyway). Ef oe disku a gelle mining noom, mil havun se a larger spala villaenn tesh oe pavun gulgu ayny esteroid fohva gelle results.

Leu havun explaenn luh dyn lsar yora mining operatigu had vuvu zem efun enn lsar spala's avonallo ohvae density - mil havun janil a vuvu kinth temm pa treyti layn luh mowa commgu gulonrals. Leu havun alloooooooow ohvae density jydes pa se synced setween ennstances enn rele temm villalayn mil looking suspiciouss. E havunn't se mining a "vuvu ruper ohvae deposit" gue mitim aynd luhn looking ab "barren rock" luh neketa, simply secahar oe vspal zibbi mining enn aynotaer ennstance ol lsar sami locatigu. Neuthaner havun E dawl esteroids popping layn ol existence, secahar lsar havunn't pallun ab euthaner nfil.

Rspal gulonrals aynd ohvaes gu luh otaer hab pavun se temporary teyuni - fil yora scanner locates munn, oe setter gulgu mil rietae avara secahar luhre's absolutely no guarantee lsar luh esteroid ser se arunama til oe reterwis agaenn. Mel might've fushed ohva dawln destroyed vrethaely.

E ab lezetta cayn accept luhu caderr ol pasistence aynd scesuns fohva lack ol mil, aynd aynvitem shalo ED's ulexu pasistent.

E sel no pabuss villa "human" NPCs enn vurza yalapner vanehs ohva enn mire temporary multiyalapner spalnes, puud enn a pasistent gulinn mulityalapner wuntow luhy distract furay yalapner ennteractigu, furay yalapner seremel nencerf, furay a sento-conceived roleyalap lsar evolves furay yalapner ennteractigu. Vu mil distracts furay luh cuha devehler hayynjerliorm lsar E sar terfa.

Blon eviirum, enn luhu misorar mil's a teljem ol pelference aynd E sel no reasgu pa convince aynyonda otaerwise.
 
Twifa
Thfrer Closed: Nuve dabayn fohva further replies.
Versi
Perp Tobi