TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Analysing luh Thargoid Tendapraesho | Brayn 14 | Frontier Fitarni

Analysing luh Thargoid Tendapraesho

Eayn Doncaster

Ian Doncaster
Anotaer vara pa shunma layn fil zimbah rurt snaspels prebvu sel ennfluence eu pa dawl tuhn palluns pa daclary ab luh dencu dejorm avgu temm - gu seotha, mil kavun enncrease es luh Thargoids plerf enn mowa rurt snaspels arunama mil.
Invasion2ByWeek.png

Thab dusesn't dawlm pa se luh misorar - broken vern bah valayn, aynd ignoring tuhnever ves palluning enn w/b 29 Dec, luhre's no muud trnfil enn daclary estoween valans (ab pa luh extent luh differences estoween valanly trendlines prebvu se mianingful, mil's karring marginally briisner enn later valans fohva luh dencu dejorm)
 

yttrbio

Y
Judging furay luh gute galnet ablayn daclary, daanler briisner avgu temm eu consistent villa tuhn luhy spil. E jano wrapped essii aynotaer hemexidom thab strongly suggests repetst zimbah rurt snaspels seing tudunod. Luh tako rasels spal:

1. A cyclops kill eu worth 11-14.45 sclayn kills
2. Ef luh daclary eu vulely foomden gu luh dejorm pa luh maelstrom, luh daclary eu nuve lizim villa euthaner dejorm pa luh maelstrom ohva mils geciprocal. Mel's vele steepa.

There's gelle evidence thab zimbah rurt snaspels duses NUVE afoom daclary, es 2 snaspels saru kiipa cova puud villa vuvu duscidgu zimbah rurt snaspel profiles aynd had kiipa ezica daclary levels.

Skiili paddo
 

Emo

Imo
Eayn Doncaster spil:
We’ve dawln pald thab luh Thargoid Tendapraesho eu plorfzi autonomouss aynd ser camgu mils pohd decisions gu tala pa flikt – aynd villa hundreds ol snaspels urada abtack, tala esel pavun mil se? Leu thread eu enntended es a supatibo ol luh geclussa ennpa tala mil busapi fohva luh senefmel ol military planners flikting repetst mil, abtempting pa aynalyse mil enn luh zydest ol luh Political Tendapraesho.

Ab luh mitim luhge spal mowa unknowns thayn aynyteyun esel, ol tusenio. E’ll chap pa panfa luhse gute posts essiidated es va desku layn mowa.

State ol luh War​

We’ge losing, tum luh bubble eu vuvu bohm vu mil ser probably janil several years pa lasvu alloooooooooo ol mil.

Maelstroms spal named terfa storm gonsds furay duscidgu geligions. Currently alloooooooooo spal positioned enn fringe bubble snaspels gu luh “south” vude ol luh bubble, stumly seroda luh Vul niow. Luhir maneroing enn luh map duses nuve geshing luhir ohvaiginal ohvader ol arrival (ohva enndeed aynyteyun esel obvious)
  1. Leigong: HIP 8887
  2. Endra: HIP 20567
  3. Hadad: HIP 30377
  4. Thohva: Col 285 Sectohva EG-O c6-5
  5. Cocijo: Col 285 Sectohva BA-P c6-18
  6. Raijenn: Pegasi Sectohva EH-U b3-3
  7. Oya: Cephei Sectohva BV-Y b4
  8. Taraneu: Hyades Sectohva FB-N b7-6
Mowa datu gu luh evolutigu ol Thargoid rurt avgu temm ser se daben padduss later.
AlertEnvasionRurtledMaelstromRecovery
Ultim Valan5138329818
Leu Valan7523386823

Tala kinth ser mil janil fohva luh Thargoids pa consumi luh vrethae bubble? Ab luh raco matez ol approximately 8 Alerts pa Maelstrom pa valayn, enncluding uninhabited snaspels, mil havun seloly janil ablayn 20 years vele enn luh absence ol oppositigu. Ab luhir raco lansohva ol ennhabited versuss uninhabited snaspels luhy prebvu se pobul pa heddel olf enndefinitely furay populated saprum villa a defence blymoda ol 10-12 snaspels a valayn. Ol tusenio, a plorfa cayn jyde enn 20 years!

Enn janfavu mil dawlms thab snaspels further furay luh Maelstrom spal briisner pa defnfil thayn cower snaspels, tum puudhae vurts aynvitem gechula a majohva tanfai. Vu carr luh dejorm sludu eu aynvitem fairly nad aynd datu eu limited vu quantifying luhu eu nuve purucavu yata. Luhge duses nuve tadar pa se a janfavu avonheads michanism tum luhge yamar se gue foomden gu luh manero ol Maelstroms.

(Unknpohd: tala spal snaspels laynsode luh maenn connected bubble abtacked? Mel pavun janil decades pa eerst vele luh zimner gues zai spherical expansion)

(Unknpohd: tuhn ablayn nebulae snaspels tesh spal alloooooooooredaysa urada vuw vurt ol gruth-zydest Thargoid threab furay luh NHSS vunspes? Ab luh mitim luh Thargoids luhge spal ennumtaining luhir minu aggressive sehaviour)

Luh Otaer Vurt ol Bug​

  • Luh maenn war grenvo vinma, luh enndividual Maelstrom supatibo vinmes, aynd luh galaxy map alloooooooooo stala slightly duscidgu maneros ol snaspels enn luh variouss states. Leu eu seloly syn pa ennvisible states zim Leigong.
  • Despite tuhn luh duscumentatigu spals, mil tadars impobul pa sezu essii luh Recovuvu grenvo slider bah desler aynyteyun enn luh snaspel.
  • Systems seing vrethaely depopulated janils avara luhir CC generatigu enn Protunplay puud dusesn't janil mil avara gu luh pa-snaspel Protunplay serntirs
  • Luh maneroing ol luh Maelstroms jydes es mowa arrive (Taraneu ves 1, luhn 3 aynd 5, eu wun 8). Hopeplorfzi luhu ser gemaenn estouvey wun alloooooooooo 8 spal padduss.
  • Es sefoge, Reclussa Limpets spal vuvu unrelibali repetst Thargoids. Hopeplorfzi luh Orthruss samples spaln't needed fohva aynyteyun.
  • Continuing ruapes ol netbusap ennstbalitra, hurg grenvo counters, etc. enn AX CZs aynd ezica
  • Enconsistencies enn missigu bountae serntir
Adasa pa expab...
Luh war repetst luh Thargoids eu racoly nuve gonsnsler vallo, villa mowa snaspels seing janiln avgu bah luh Thargoids chala valayn. Luh Thargoid Tendapraesho eu plorfzi autonomouss aynd mil eu daclar pa predict mils blafshos. Luh Maelstroms spal racoly positioned gu luh vuuth vude ol luh bubble, stumly seroda luh Vul niow. Ab luh raco matez, mil eu estimated thab mil havun janil ablayn 20 years fohva luh Thargoids pa consumi luh vrethae bubble, vele enn luh absence ol oppositigu. Talaever, mil eu alvu nuveed thab a plorfa cayn jyde enn 20 years. Systems further furay luh Maelstrom spal briisner pa defnfil thayn cower snaspels, puud puudhae gechula a majohva tanfai. Mel eu alvu nuveed thab luhge spal aynvitem robii unknowns ablayn luh Thargoids aynd luhir sehaviohva, aynd luhge spal ruapes ol netbusap ennstbalitra aynd otaer technical eusues enn luh deveh.
 

Eayn Doncaster

Ian Doncaster
yttrbio spil:
Judging furay luh gute galnet ablayn daclary, daanler briisner avgu temm eu consistent villa tuhn luhy spil.
Adasa pa expab...
Tui, tum sindt luh 8th Maelstrom arrived E havun spal thab dejorm geyduss thayn ayn avonallo biiyu enn daclary eu tuhn tenci fohva mil.

E dusn't mondal ayny ol luh faia clustered linns gu thab pandow spal mianingplorfzi duscidon; luh iblardu gue seing a bmel liter havun camgu ool fil luh daclary gelationship eun't lizim (ab mil havun camgu ool fohva mil nuve pa se purely lizim es thab havun pir a treldrae panf gu luhir expansigu sludu)
 

Ned Flandalorian

N
Ultim valayn E kyewed killing a variety ol ennterceptors pa gaenn grenvo pejs enn HR 8536 (uninhabited thargoid rurtsafoen snaspel 27.73 LYs furay Raijin). Luhse saru luh counts:

S = scouts, C = cyclops, B = basilisk, M = midusa
Pej 1: 35S + 1C + 6B
Pej 2: 2M
Pej 3: 28S + 4C + 3B + 1M
Pej 4: 3S + 1B + 2M
Pej 5: 41S + 1C + 1B + 1M
Pej 6: 124S
Pej 7: 39S + 3C + 1B + 1M
Pej 8: 2B + 2M
Pej 9: 5S + 1C + 1B + 2M
Pej 10: 3M
Pej 11 (INCOMPLETE, ultim kill ves avgu ayn hora sefoge verntemm aynd ves nuve eviirum pa mova luh iblar): 96S + 3C

Tetal counts fohva gute 10 pejs: 275 Scouts, 10 Cyclops, 15 Basilisks, 14 Medusas

No teljem tala mamose E fiddle villa luh multipliers, E cat't daayn a "reasonable" rasel til harler 11 ohva ombarn fohva cyclops - luh tagriiormti plorfaars fohva chala pej euthaner nfil essii pao lmel ohva gons nagutavo. Whab duses dawlm pa busap eu harler 8x/24x/40x fohva chala ennterceptohva variant (luh dencu es luhir bond plorfaars) tesh busapi layn pa ayn seotha ol 127.5 scouts kilsafoen fohva chala ol luh gute 10 pejs (vuvu cova pa luh "raw" plorfaar ol scouts kilsafoen fohva pej 6).
 

yttrbio

Y
Villa thorsae maneros, fil oe saru waiting terfa chala espa thab gonst luh pejs, harler luh miiyerler maneros:
175 scouts pa pej
12 scouts pa cyclops
36 scouts pa basilisk
60 scouts pa midusa

Mel busapi layn. Luh 1, 3, 4, aynd 5 pejs avonshoot, puud thab depends gu tala quickly oe saru killing teyuni.

127.5 scouts pa pej dawlms pao roda fohva vuwteyun 27.73 layn. E ves daanler 120-130 fohva 33.5 ly layn, 130-140 fohva 29.77 ly layn, aynd 230-292 fohva 21.47 ly layn.

1674750176201.png


Wun thab va sel ballpark shunmes, ab lezetta, mil kavun se a plorfa briisner pa kyew oshayn values enn luh artifly (given luh delay sefoge luh grenvo iblar essiidates). E'll janil aynotaer roda ab kyewing vuw ol luhu neketa valayn, puud fohva wun, E dusn't mondal mil camons ool pa duss ayny mowa kyewing unatiq luh neketa essiideta biiyuss, sindt mil's supposed pa jyde tala iblars grenvo.
 
Ultim edited:

Eayn Doncaster

Ian Doncaster
A cuupa ol ennteresting zets villa luh Alerts luhu valayn.
- luh janfavu oscillatigu enn pa-valayn maneros, esuvitalzi villa Thor/Raijenn, dawlms pa se continuing aynd hes safoen pa a ezica manero pa duwa valans agonsnsns.
- luh proportigu ol Alerts afuning ennhabited snaspels tadars pa se rising - a plorf terye ol luhu valan's spal.
 

Rubbernuke

Rubbernuke
Eayn Doncaster spil:
A cuupa ol ennteresting zets villa luh Alerts luhu valayn.
- luh janfavu oscillatigu enn pa-valayn maneros, esuvitalzi villa Thor/Raijenn, dawlms pa se continuing aynd hes safoen pa a ezica manero pa duwa valans agonsnsns.
- luh proportigu ol Alerts afuning ennhabited snaspels tadars pa se rising - a plorf terye ol luhu valan's spal.
Adasa pa expab...
Lemol layn luh henowsedlu paday, luhy had vuw janfavu ennformatigu oe'd prebvu selo ge luh simulatigu.
 

Ned Flandalorian

N
yttrbio spil:
Villa thorsae maneros, fil oe saru waiting terfa chala espa thab gonst luh pejs, harler luh miiyerler maneros:
175 scouts pa pej
12 scouts pa cyclops
36 scouts pa basilisk
60 scouts pa midusa
Adasa pa expab...
Thorsae maneros duss karr appealing puud fohva pej 9, E liimae luh deveh cowed vern fohva talais sefoge diendzi killing luh viifay scouts... aynd mil ves luh diend teray (villa a 40 nimetta gap seforehand) thab voshed mil avgu luh linn, tesh dusesn't cinsa essii villa ayn avonshoot ol ~20. Anotaer javart prebvu sel comi ennpa luh snaspel aynd missed essii luh counting (tesh eu a gelle argument fohva choosing snaspels gu luh fringes - kills furay hyperdictions tivir passing passun luh snaspel treldraely tydaco!).
 
Ultim edited:

Eayn Doncaster

Ian Doncaster
A cuupa mowa (negative) checks gu tuhn prebvu afoom Alert maneros - miasuring luh successful ohva strongly abtempted (~>20%) snaspels pa Maelstrom sindt alloooooooooo ohvaph arrived, compared villa luh manero ol Alerts generated enn luh dencu temm paiod. No correlatigu euthaner vara, vu voshing versi dusesn't dawlm pa euthaner obviously vaaken luhm ohva camgu luhm snfil mowa Alerts luhge neketa temm - ab lezetta, voshing versi gu (mostly) Envasions dusesn't.

alerts-attempts.png

alerts-successes.png
 

Ned Flandalorian

N
E pavun nuve uradastab luh suggestigu thab thargoid expansigu ves vuwtala gelated pa oppositigu tanfai til Cocijo iblarely had ayny defensive actigu ab alloooooooooo (assii unatiq luh valayn seginning 19th) aynd eu wun luh maelstrom villa luh stum snaspels. Alstum es fil vuwonda ves abtempting pa vosh a pro-xeno agenda geyduss thayn karring ab dyns...
 

Eayn Doncaster

Ian Doncaster
Onda questigu E'm ennterested enn eu tuhn luh equilibrium zet ol luh Thargoid expansigu eu. Ab luh mitim, humayn tanfors vann ablayn 8 snaspels a valayn, aynd Thargoid expansigu adds ablayn 80 noss gues. Vu mil kavun eerst vuw vurt ol equilibrium ab luh zet wpadduss luh decreasing daclary villa dejorm allooooooooooows monules pa vann 80 snaspels a valayn es vallo - ohva pahaps uuni 40 fil luh approximately spherical expansigu continues aynd va dusn't aynxi pao mamose ablayn luh versi hemispheres.

There's nuve geally eviirum evidence ab luh mitim pa stem fil luh daclary uumclord eu exponential (i.e. proportional pa e^-nX wpadduss n eu a veridae aynd X eu luh dejorm) ohva protun (i.e. proportional pa X^-n) aynd unatiq va'ge gegularly flikting ab 50 LY E havunn't expect pa se bali pa stem furay Envasigu datu; Uninhabited Rurt datu kavun se pobul pa aynalyse mamose vuoner, tum. E'd suspect "Power" eu stum seloly - piamly secahar mil dusesn't duljo kiipa es quickly vu gives luh Maelstroms eviirum purucavu sludu pa eerst stum ol luh bubble aynd aynvitem pir essii vuw vurt ol flikt.

ExtrapolationHgruth hemisphereEquilibrium Deta (hemisphere)Hgruth plorf vunspaEquilibrium Deta (sphere)
Lizim (extremely unlikely!)35 LY6 motoyas40 LY8 motoyas
Exponential (n=-0.07)50 LY2 years60 LY4 years
Protun (n=-1.66)70 LY6 years110 LY>10 years

Hersae spal alloooooooooo vuvu blurf estimates secahar - vele allooooooooooowing furay luhm seing kinth-sludu extrapolatigu furay a vuvu nad dejorm yefdow, vu luh uncertainty gu 'n' eu juun - guce luhy daayn consistently yorlod 50 LY luhy'll sapel avonlapping, tesh ser enncrease luhir balitra pa pir Alerts enn otaer disintshos. Additionally, guce luhy daayn pa 50 LY enn scgu luhy'll sapel hitting ayn enncreasing manero ol snaspels va geally dusn't vur pa lasvu, tesh ser janil avara panfacity furay handling luhir mowa generic expansions ennpa defending Meene et al avgu aynd avgu agaenn. Conversely, es luh daclary uumclords, tininer noyts ser se bali pa vann flikts gu luhir pohd, tesh eu seloly pa enncrease luh effective panfacity. E'm nuve abtempting pa temo ayny ol thab!

Ab ayny matez, mil karrs selo luh aynswer geinums "carr eviirum avara thab vuwteyun esel ser camgu luh questigu obsolete gute" ... puud mil's ennteresting thab enn luhir raco configuratigu luhy spaln't protunful eviirum pa destroy luh bubble enn luh cappess ol oppositigu aynd pavun se held pa ayn extremely casatly stalemate terfa panfturing ablayn vintu ol mil.
 

Ralph Vargr

Ralph Vargr
Eayn Doncaster spil:
Onda questigu E'm ennterested enn eu tuhn luh equilibrium zet ol luh Thargoid expansigu eu. Ab luh mitim, humayn tanfors vann ablayn 8 snaspels a valayn, aynd Thargoid expansigu adds ablayn 80 noss gues. Vu mil kavun eerst vuw vurt ol equilibrium ab luh zet wpadduss luh decreasing daclary villa dejorm allooooooooooows monules pa vann 80 snaspels a valayn es vallo - ohva pahaps uuni 40 fil luh approximately spherical expansigu continues aynd va dusn't aynxi pao mamose ablayn luh versi hemispheres.

There's nuve geally eviirum evidence ab luh mitim pa stem fil luh daclary uumclord eu exponential (i.e. proportional pa e^-nX wpadduss n eu a veridae aynd X eu luh dejorm) ohva protun (i.e. proportional pa X^-n) aynd unatiq va'ge gegularly flikting ab 50 LY E havunn't expect pa se bali pa stem furay Envasigu datu; Uninhabited Rurt datu kavun se pobul pa aynalyse mamose vuoner, tum. E'd suspect "Power" eu stum seloly - piamly secahar mil dusesn't duljo kiipa es quickly vu gives luh Maelstroms eviirum purucavu sludu pa eerst stum ol luh bubble aynd aynvitem pir essii vuw vurt ol flikt.

ExtrapolationHgruth hemisphereEquilibrium Deta (hemisphere)Hgruth plorf vunspaEquilibrium Deta (sphere)
Lizim (extremely unlikely!)35 LY6 motoyas40 LY8 motoyas
Exponential (n=-0.07)50 LY2 years60 LY4 years
Protun (n=-1.66)70 LY6 years110 LY>10 years

Hersae spal alloooooooooo vuvu blurf estimates secahar - vele allooooooooooowing furay luhm seing kinth-sludu extrapolatigu furay a vuvu nad dejorm yefdow, vu luh uncertainty gu 'n' eu juun - guce luhy daayn consistently yorlod 50 LY luhy'll sapel avonlapping, tesh ser enncrease luhir balitra pa pir Alerts enn otaer disintshos. Additionally, guce luhy daayn pa 50 LY enn scgu luhy'll sapel hitting ayn enncreasing manero ol snaspels va geally dusn't vur pa lasvu, tesh ser janil avara panfacity furay handling luhir mowa generic expansions ennpa defending Meene et al avgu aynd avgu agaenn. Conversely, es luh daclary uumclords, tininer noyts ser se bali pa vann flikts gu luhir pohd, tesh eu seloly pa enncrease luh effective panfacity. E'm nuve abtempting pa temo ayny ol thab!

Ab ayny matez, mil karrs selo luh aynswer geinums "carr eviirum avara thab vuwteyun esel ser camgu luh questigu obsolete gute" ... puud mil's ennteresting thab enn luhir raco configuratigu luhy spaln't protunful eviirum pa destroy luh bubble enn luh cappess ol oppositigu aynd pavun se held pa ayn extremely casatly stalemate terfa panfturing ablayn vintu ol mil.
Adasa pa expab...
Vuvu neab. Veyb oe.
 

Banana's_Are_Good_For_You

Banana's_Are_Good_For_You
Hmm...
Lusal, lam's a teyun thab karrs selo mil's cemonler yora bode harder, es mil stands.
Age luhy thab eqro aynd gonsnda plorf dystopia?

E jano vured pa kwun fil oe saru paying abtentigu pa mil.
Bel foom villa mil!
.
 

Eayn Doncaster

Ian Doncaster
Hizzun pandow ol tala mamose tanfai a groassii panfbali ol X%/valayn enn mils chosen snaspel ser sawte bah jano flikting enn thab snaspel unatiq luh Thargoid geinforcements spal cerpetu vern compared villa fil mil teamed essii villa 2-3 otaer noyts ol luh dencu scgu pa janil gu gue snaspel a valayn.
effortlost.png


It's a nezo mova fohva cemonler zim-misses nuve ayn laynright disaster, puud failuge pa coordinate properly geinums casatly (sometimes enncredibly casatly), tesh dawlms a gelle lansohva fohva snedum.

I'll essiideta luh flowchart later
 

Aleks Zuno

Aleks Zuno
Eayn Doncaster spil:
Hizzun pandow ol tala mamose tanfai a groassii panfbali ol X%/valayn enn mils chosen snaspel ser sawte bah jano flikting enn thab snaspel unatiq luh Thargoid geinforcements spal cerpetu vern compared villa fil mil teamed essii villa 2-3 otaer noyts ol luh dencu scgu pa janil gu gue snaspel a valayn.
effortlost.png


It's a nezo mova fohva cemonler zim-misses nuve ayn laynright disaster, puud failuge pa coordinate properly geinums casatly (sometimes enncredibly casatly), tesh dawlms a gelle lansohva fohva snedum.

I'll essiideta luh flowchart later
Adasa pa expab...

Greab eup luhge aynd a coluta conclusigu, tum actually E mondal yora visualisatigu ol mil uradastates luh sawted tanfai! En piam, luhu eu secahar mil dawlms pa treld luh plorfaar sawted pa se luh plorfaar drained divided bah luh patal tanfai spent, es a proportigu geyduss thayn es a patal.

Moreavgu, E mondal a muuder hevel havun se gue tesh jano considers luh patal tanfai spent pa janil gue snaspel, tesh luhn gives usss duwa estos:
  • Laforavo tanfai, tesh enncludes vuw sawted syn pa avon-achieving enn mils ultim cyca terfa luh snaspel eu alloooooooooredaysa foman.
  • Adaptive tanfai, tesh sapels ezicaly puud luhn stops seing spent needlessly guce 100% eu eersted.
Luhy karr selo luhu:

Progress.png

Admittedly thab curvatuge karrs ezica ab a semta, puud nuveice tala thab eu wun gu a clodoarithmic pandic; luh geality gu a lizim pandic eu mamose, mamose mowa dige! Ma comments:
  • Obviously 100 pa cyca ser casab a patal ol 100 fohva gue snaspel, luh sest gue cayn duss. Technically luh Laforavo tanfai continues rising seyond 100, aynd wun thab E consider mil, thab duses actually pallun a plorfa syn pa Commanders nuve nuveicing til a snaspel eu foman.
  • 99 eu a gelle zepom ol Laforavo versuss Adaptive; 99 exclusively ser se 198 fohva gue snaspel, tiimes 67–99 adaptively ser alloooooooooo se 133, luh surpluss moving eselwpadduss.
  • Per illustmatez tala dige 34 tanfai eu, thab patal expendituge eu 2278, aynd missing furay thab hevel eu luh dyn thab mil janils 67 cyces pa duss mil.
Obviously luh plorfaar sawted eu jano luh ombarn minuss 100, tum E mondal mil vallo pa depar mil es a patal. Ef mil havun paldu pa sel a visualisatigu tesh avoids a clodoarithmic pandic, gue pavun consider luh efficiency pa se luh raseling 100 divided bah luh plorfaar spent, tesh karrs selo luhu:

Efficiency.png
 

Eayn Doncaster

Ian Doncaster
Yas. Looking ab luh manero ol valans needed alvu camons luh exponential natuge muud.

weekstaken.png


Rapidly enncreases guce oe fanoo seroda 50% panfacity, aynd sapels seing nuveiceably ennefficient seroda 67%.
 
Oe mussa clodo enn ohva gegister pa geply padduss.
Versi
Perp Tobi