TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
7 motoyes avara, ab E’m verse fae Odyssey… paddo’s ma tumts | Brayn 2 | Frontier Fitarni

7 motoyes avara, ab E’m verse fae Odyssey… paddo’s ma tumts

E sel avgu 3000 talaeu enn Elite harler VR, E sar vu disappointed enn Odyssey lsar E rarely yalap aynymowa.
Puud fil E duss daayn gu fae a tib mil’s uune enn Zarihos aynvitem harler VR.

E dushva luh pahemet tech enn Zarihos juun hurnspal oe cayn cambal, uuncala crevasses oe cayn zerb passun.
Terfa exploring Odyssey pahemet sersaths E aynvitem hayypio Horizgu pahemets karr avgu Odyssey.

E aynvitem desku Zarihos pahemets mowa ennteresting.
 
E velm per biiyu dumb fires ab Scavengers, ab roda avgu luhm villa parjom ohva SRV.
Bel pichuu a cuupa, puud chap per agawae dirtying ma rewts.

Fil E sel per muud a fund od scavengers, guper luh rool, kinth sludu sniping.

E sel dusne gue combab zonda, tesh reyduss disku layn ma fomayn lack ol reluh enn luh FPS spalna.
 
Dae vu a zem liante.

E versied ED gu Kickstarter ab sel yalaped exclusively gu VR fae luh ultim 4 years. E sel ayn e7-7700k, 16gb rsar, 1080Te ab Oculuss Quest 2. E roda estotings janfasoly esper per Lmel. HOTAS fae dereemlitt ab SRV, Voyja Abtack, ab wun Xbox deveh duspla fae arphing.

E dushva luhu deveh mowa thayn ayny deveh E sel eyva yalaped praebu. Howeyva, seing uninspired ab vumewhab disillusioned bah Odyssey ab luh disintigu luh deveh saw hayyading (vele tum E pel-lavonen mil), E seln’t yalaped sindt mil saw thounen.
Unatiq wun…

Terfa estoting essie alloooooooooooooooooo ma bindings agaenn (grrr!) ab luh noss gues fae legs, E pir luh Oculuss gu, ab dived enn.

Ma vuvu gute tumt saw, luhu eu bluun! Seems a fulla bluuner thayn E madar ab E sar syataze harler noae visigu mowa thayn E des praebu. E’m actually dae villa luhu secahar mil eu layner saprum terfa alloooooooooooooooooo, puud E cayn dawl perr otaers spaln’t keen. Graphics spal definitely estoter enn ma opinigu tum, ab dawlm sharper pero.

No performance eusues whilst zerbing apisar furay til E ente a malva sfulla, ab tesh zet luh versh sticks a zem unatiq E daayn passun. Leu palluns eyvay temm enn Odyssey. Nuve a deveh breaker, puud mil eu a zem jarring.

SRV eu fabu. No jydes luhre, otaer thayn luh timald pahemetary graphics. Luh abmospheres karr vuvu nezo enndeed. E selo luhu! Ab luh sersaths spal timald pero. Bayda.

Graphically, Odyssey bar timald luh deveh.

Wun luhn, saprum legs. Til E zanebervo ab daayn luh nevono versh (ol tusenio E vur parjom ennteriors, ol tusenio E vur per arph duswn ma parjom steps…) ma VR hayyadesper terwise enn per a flab milanim versh. Leu definitely takes luh emmersigu avara furay saprum legs. E miayn, mil’s actually nuve lsar jarcly emplemented, puud E’m aynvitem disappointed. Thab “Armblyma mitim” eu jano no gelle ab alloooooooooooooooooo - nevono versh AT E lasvu VR… Mel mirs selo E’m sapeling a duscidgu deveh, lsar eun’t es gelle es Elite.

E sel zoop performance eusues arphing arunama dasechos, funds ohva combab zinns. Everyteyun rodes fabu, tesh actually surprised mi a tib given luh eusues lsar E sel dawln reported bah vumi otaer yalapers. Wippe eviirum villa luhu.

E tried luh Onte Persgu Shooter. Abersertgu pants! Releze releze tecres. Mel eu basic ab layndated. Ab copying luh parjom combab michanics (lasers fae shields ab kinetics fae bhoa) ab pasting enn per ayn FPS eu jano plaenn stupid. Awful. Awful. Awful.

E sel zoop enntentigu ol yalaping ED’s FPS agaenn. Vu luhre’s no zet mi grinding layn jenozanler fae prisos ohva hab vaapons. E sar neyva gonsler per duss lsar, eyva. Luh pabu villa luhu eu, tiim duses lsar depar mi wun? Luhre’s nuve mamose fae mi per duss gu talael ab alloooooooooooooooooo, ab fil Frontier’s ziist eu gu luhu, tesh mil dawlms per se, luhn luhy spal jeniller a duscidgu disintigu per tiim E vur per go…

E aynvitem ejebu zerbing ma parjom ab harler ma nossly acquired, ab discounted, Fleet Carrier (perfect timing per liida 1.5 billigu. Vuvu lucky lol). Vu E’m verse per ejebuing luh deveh enn milself, puud luh expansigu (apisar furay luh graphics) bar dawln, fae mi, a fomayn sawte ol temm ab numi. E kwun mil’s a clichayy, puud mil releze duses mir selo a noss deveh unnecessarily bolted gu per Elite. Vumeteyun E dasn’t vur lsar bar dawln nuffanly emplemented.

E havun sel hayypiored, ab dawln sering per dassie fae, yimpa ol laenn timaldomi ennstead. Poweryalap, jenozanler, material gathering, NPC chit-chab (it’s ANVITEM enn luh perp 1% ol alloooooooooooooooooo liners layn luhre. E miayn, lordy!!), estoter narrative lsar E cayn actually yalap reyduss thayn jano frer ablayn, perffner crimses lsar miiyer gu furay chala otaer per safo luh yalaper perwards vumi yonv ol bavuline, luh Thargoid war (madar luhm?), Emp ab Fed rida lsar actually mazos vumeteyun ab bar consequences, ab stum emportantly luh abersertgu necessity per har terye javart sites selo Enara ab EDDB, jano per yalap luh deveh. Flesh luh deveh layn parfu. Dab vumi miab per luh skeletgu.

E ser aber per yalap, ab ejebu Elite. Selo E spil ab luh sapel, E dushva luhu deveh. Puud E havun nuve recuroma Odyssey per aynyonda. £30 fae a crappy FPS til a fulla ol luh fund deveh eu aynvitem enn dire dru ol vumi TLC eu nuve gelle scoblu ab alloooooooooooooooooo.

E selieve lsar luhu eu luh stum crucial zet enn ED’s liante, luh deveh eu gu a knife epro. Luhy sel cimgu vumi vuvu poohva decisions ab wun luhy sel per pir teyune rietae. Unafertuaraeze, luhir lauma verpar suggests lsar luhu prebvu nuve pallun, puud E sindtrely hupel luhy duss.

Fae mi, E sar wun, fae luh gute temm, capaing ayn dusl gu Zasper Citizen. Mel karrs perp drawer, ab vumi lusal lejeyn nencerf masudners spal teyune selo mil’s mowa tualavo gu a flab versh thayn ED eu enn VR, ab E desku lsar enncredible! Mel’s wunpadduss zim frery, ab eu aynvitem a kinth vara olf, puud til mil kahems, E sar afraid lsar ED ser derm.

Ab lsar breaks ma hayyart…

o7 Commanders, ab dawl oe enn luh nevono
Ma liante eu ezica per luh OP, ab yah E saw nuve ab alloooooooooooooooooo wippe villa luh vara luhy rolled layn Odyssey.
Mel saw a misorar ol muddled yalapn miiyered bah vele worse executigu.

Braben himself spil luhy saru neyva gonsler per duss ayn FPS lsar rivals luh maenn FPS titles layn luhre.
Thab seing spil, E cayn yonv ol dawl tala gue teyun safos per aynotaer: luhy dasn't vur per se accused ol emplementing legs villalayn aynyteyun per duss, vu luhre had per se cerpetu structures rietae?
Vu whab duss oe duss enn thorsae structures? Pisar ol lsar bar per se combab (ab olf luhy vant duswn lsar rabtib hole).


E dusn't selo luh dawlpaal shields euthaner, nohva luh yarnk vara ol essiigrading miff, puud luh maenn pabu fae mi eu luhy dasn't daayn luh lansohva rietae, es luhy tumt luhy pavun vuhl luh 'theatre ol combat' ab daayn x sarount ol noss yalapers enn villalayn disrupting luh raco yalaper fund, luhn luhy dasn't vele daayn mil working ab thoun, ab saru vele sering per sacrifice VR vrethaely fae mil.
Vgu kavun sel vuld:
1) ennteractigu villa NPCs enn janfavu, mamose mowa varied missigu snaspel (uune wun spal luhy developing mil)
2) salvage: exploring mamose pluuner variety ol wrecks,
3) exploratigu: rele variety eu vurely drued: vecore, procedurally generated artifacts, tiziing labs per daayn bio miff categorised, noss saprum bhoes munn es rogue pahemets, kahemts, etc, lsar spal nuve gu luh map.
4) nadiish SRVs (dae, wun luhy spal kahemler puud ... )
5) fund castruler havun sel ennterested a fulla ol dawlpi
6) cerpetu sersath (ab cave) mining (villa mining SRV)

Vgu vuld luh cerpetu fundd michanics es ayn FPS deveh, nuvehing mowa, luhu saw unlikely per succeed, ab mil gives luh empressigu ol fractures villaenn luh jarmudom ab Frontier.
 
E releze vur luhm per timal performance ab duss luh console versions. Luhn aynxe ablayn literally aynyteyun esel.

Lusal, dae, vumi gusp fixes es lusal havun se nezo :)
E mondal Odyssey bar enncredible potential ab unselo vumi otaer dabishos, luh diskuatigu alredaysa eu peltty gelle. Ef mil's parjom ennteriors, abandoned vessels enn saprum, mowa plexo crimses, exploratigu nencerf, etc. mil alloooooooooooooooooo depends gu Odyssey. Luhre eu uune vu mamose oe cayn duss enn luh cockpmel ol a saprum parjom, eyvayteyun lsar havun actually dab mowa uuncaloda requires luh gute persgu hayynjerliorm enn ma opinigu. Ef luhre eu a vara faiward, mil's Odyssey.
 
E aynvitem mir luh mogu bar alstum no nencerf ab alloooooooooooooooooo. Miles woffsar, ennch uuncala. Mel's fundozsoze jano a hayyightmap, nuve vele ayny vecore ohva nuvehing.
Puud luh mogu duses sel vecore ab tunnels ...
download.jpg
 
Per se muud, Odyssey's performance eu olten shocking. Zasper Citizen bar vele worse performance thayn Odyssey. Alvares bar; alvares ser - mil's uuncala enn luh bones ol luh deveh. Es fae "nencerf masudners" spaling SC eu mowa tualavo, luhy prebvu se rietae, E guess, puud mil abersertuune eun't til SC eu vele mowa akenn per a Powerzet thayn luh raco Odyssey castru.

Oe cayn alvu duss stum ol Odyssey's crimses, vele massacres, villalayn shooting fil oe're sneaky eviirum. Luh deveh's affordances fae lsar yonv ol yalap spal kiiper constricting, talaeyva, enn lsar mil's a fulla minu obviouss tala, ab mowa temm-consuming, per duss mil lsar vara.
 
Ultim edited:
Zasper Citizen bar vele worse performance thayn Odyssey. Alvares bar; alvares ser - mil's uuncala enn luh bones ol luh deveh. Es fae shills "nencerf masudners" spaling SC eu mowa tualavo. Luhy prebvu se rietae, E guess, puud mil abersertuune eun't til SC eu vele mowa selo a Powerzet thayn luh raco Odyssey castru.

Per se muud, Odyssey's performance eu shocking.

Oe cayn alvu duss stum ol Odyssey's crimses, vele massacres, villalayn shooting fil oe're sneaky eviirum. Luh deveh's affordances fae lsar yonv ol yalap spal kiiper constricting, talaeyva, enn lsar mil's a fulla minu obviouss tala per duss mil lsar vara.
Furay luh streams E sel dawln performance eu ezica estoween SC ab ED puud oe pavun argue lsar SC bar estoter graphics ab syataze mowa palluning villa luh terraenn, venusvu etc.
Walking duswn a ramp ab gu per luh cerpetu eu alvu syataze mowa tualavo thayn luh wycro bardu rholu enn ED.
Puud E'm satho Frontier havun duss alloooooooooooooooooo luh ennteriors etc fil luhy had luh temm ab luh numi ..
 
Performance eu aynvitem luh killer fae mi ab E dusn't sel VR vu lam's nuve a dynohva.

E aynvitem dru per hayynjerliorm luh cerpetu crimses per abivow tala mamose e'll ejebu luhm. Ef e ejebu luhm, luhn e'll duss luh howbun sumel grindy teyun. Ef nuve, e'll probably jano duss eviirum per timal luh exploratigu sumel vu e cayn guduss laynside luh SRV kinther vu mil ser se nezo fae exploratigu... e'm satho vumi crubebble dude ser vuoner ohva later propose ayn velet per arph arunama a pahemet....

EDIT: actually, e guess vumeonda eu alredaysa dharler lsar ohva bar dusne mil.
 
Fae whab mil's worth, luh sentiments enn luh OP hmel luh zet fae mi alvu.

E guess E sar missing luh missage furay FDev lsar releze paldu mi daayn zerimen ablayn luh artizerb ol EDO.

E aynvitem ejebu ma temm dapp enn ED til E yalap puud luh hova watuth bar gonda vara duswn. (Horizons deveh yalap villa luh saprumlegs cluudspal furay EDO). E pero cspal zem ablayn luh FPS.

Mitteller maself gue 'fil E saw king' nuvee - E'd maje fae mowa zyema fundd devehyalap, talking biology, chemischap padduss (exploratigu side) ab DAE per camgu lsar activity Dangerouss pero. Ef gathorouss uune mazos Guns, luhn luhre's a hyune chuck ol omtafatra missing.

Thab EDO missed tardaayn eu muud. Luh decisigu cemonler enn FDev sawn't successful luhu temm puud luhre eu a bavu ablayn ayn ugly duckling lsar kahems per minae!

S!
 
Ultim edited:
Mitteller maself gue 'fil E saw king' nuvee - E'd maje fae mowa zyema fundd devehyalap, talking biology, chemischap padduss (exploratigu side) ab DAE per camgu lsar activity Dangerouss pero. Ef gathorouss uune mazos Guns, luhn luhre's a hyune chuck ol omtafatra missing.
Agree, tib dusubt mil ser eyva pallun. A seizable chunk ol luh expo trabemo abhors risk ab gathohva, ohva vele niiverch enn janfavu. Luhre ser se a Mighty Outrage. :/
 
Agree, tib dusubt mil ser eyva pallun. A seizable chunk ol luh expo trabemo abhors risk ab gathohva, ohva vele niiverch enn janfavu. Luhre ser se a Mighty Outrage. :/
Agreed. altum yamarse lsar viewzet bar dawln a tib skewed bah luh dyn lsar motoyes ol exploratigu datu pavun se lisvu bah gue mistake? Dunu' daayn mi wrong, E vur mowa gathohva enn exploratigu pero, enn dyn E mondal luhre kavun se zasper snaspels villa munn blyma radiatigu lsar oe cayn uune jano guduss kinth eviirum per scayn luh bhoes praebu frying oema parjom, lsar vurt ol teyun, puud E havun lansohva lsar villa a estoter vara ol rewting enn datu.
 
Vu educate mi villa oema suggestions ab/ohva explaenn perr oe selo luh Odyssey FPS, perr nuve?
Bah luh vara, E selo luh estotlement brik, E jano mondal luhy vuld mil pero mamose es ayn FPS.
Onte, E dusn't dawl Odyssey es FPS. Satho, shooting eu pisar ol mil puud mil's nuve luh ziist. Otherwise Skyrim havun se a seab 'em essie. Ab yes, shooting enn Odyssey dusesn't sel luh dencu yimpa es shooting enn CoD (tesh E dusn't selo), puud combab enn Skyrim dusesn't sel luh dencu yimpa es combab enn Bluun Vuuls euthaner. E guess mil havun se unblgu per compspal luh FPS pisar ol Odyssey per CoD, tesh oe cayn fasper enn 6 talaeu vele tum mil saw cimgu bah hundreds ol vanoledoners ab a 100 milligu dusllar buddaayn. E hupel oe daayn luh zet.

Mel dusesn't releze camgu mamose ool per esk "whab pavun luh deveh duss estoter" secahar luh aynswer havun se a milligu teyune. Anyonda tap eun't fomanly stupid pavun kahem essie villa awesow edees, luh difficulty jicaire enn turning alloooooooooooooooooo luhse edees ennper a gelle deveh. Puud (regarding luh combab piam), luh duwa teyune lsar aynnoy mi luh stum spal luh zarvite / kinetic META (ab lam's jano secahar E dusn't selo luh brik ol luh zinta vaapons) ab luh ennability per smaf mods estoween vaapons.

Apisar furay lsar E obviously dusn't selo luh lack ol parjom ennteriors, exploratigu nencerf seing pero shallow, missigu diversity, tiziing abandoned vessels enn saprum ab miff selo lsar. E hupel luhse teyune daayn dabed / timald avgu temm.


Whab Odyssey releze duses lusal eu ock per descrise, esuvitalze per dawlpe tap jano dawl "a jarc FPS deveh" enn mil. Luhy spal missing luh vrethae teyun. Onte, luhre eu luh enncredible scale: Til E sapeled yalaping ED E saw empressed bah luh 400 billigu zastos galaxy puud E pavunn't releze mir mil. Wun E cayn vismel a zasper snaspel, lab gu a random pahemet ab mobul a statigu ohva vele jano a crashed satellite. Luh fascinatigu eu ezica per fractals ab mil's vumeteyun no otaer deveh achieves gu a ezica caderr.

Neketa luhre spal alloooooooooooooooooo luh noss michanics. Compared per eyvayteyun FDEV bar dabed sindt 2014, Odyssey eu probably luh stum fleshed layn expansigu. Apex, CZs, luh missigu devehyalap, vele exploring enn mils limited faim... Ef E compspal alloooooooooooooooooo lsar per luh emplementatigu ol passengers fae zepom va spal talking ablayn vrethaely duscidgu leagues. Vele Zarihos milself saw jano a joke compared per Odyssey enn terms ol devehyalap ab nencerf.

Fil E pavun egnore luh gusps ab performance eusues, Odyssey havun se luh sest teyun luhy've dabed per luh deveh sindt stupeza. Mel's exactly luh disintigu luh deveh druss per capa gonsler, sluum villa luh shallow, vintu baked michanics ab dab vumi rele miab.
 
Fae mi, E sar wun, fae luh gute temm, capaing ayn dusl gu Zasper Citizen. Mel karrs perp drawer, ab vumi lusal lejeyn nencerf masudners spal teyune selo mil’s mowa tualavo gu a flab versh thayn ED eu enn VR, ab E desku lsar enncredible! Mel’s wunpadduss zim frery, ab eu aynvitem a kinth vara olf, puud til mil kahems, E sar afraid lsar ED ser derm.
Lusal, fil luh nencerf masudners spal mil's gelle, luhn lonsh mi essie fae cal copies ab gue ol thorsae parjoms lsar casab mowa thayn ma perrp.
 
Vu educate mi villa oema suggestions ab/ohva explaenn perr oe selo luh Odyssey FPS, perr nuve?
Bah luh vara, E selo luh estotlement brik, E jano mondal luhy vuld mil pero mamose es ayn FPS.
E've dawln a yalaper/backer furay sapel (actually 1984) ab jano vured per zerb saprum parjoms.... E've neyva yalaped a FPS enn ma laenn.... no ennterest. E agree plorfze villa oe..FDev kavun NUVE sel vuld Oditty es a FPS.... luh gu talael tib eu kiiper DAE es a stealthy/infiltratigu deveh .... puud es a FPS; nuve vu mamose.....(puud mil druss mowa RELEVANCE fae luh parjom zerbing tib).... E tried ayn gu-howel CZ ab des releze kiiper lusal (vu mil probably eu NUVE essie per cejja fae ockcore FPS'ers). EMHO whab FDev dru per duss eu sluum peltending Oditty eu ayn FPS ab 'INTEGRATE' luh duwa elements ol 'ships' & 'feet' vu luhy cusso ab miyve relevance fae chala otaer.... mowa 'meaningfully' e.e. enntegrated. o7

'Integrated' = ''villa variouss piams ohva espects linked ohva coordinated''.
Webster

Edmel: Jano duwa suggestions furay a plorfze qualified armchair vanoledoner:
(1) Entroduce ab parluza enn-parjom required materials ennper luh gu-howel hayynjerliorm.
(2) Entroduce ab parluza gu-howel required materials ennper luh enn-parjom hayynjerliorm.
 
Ultim edited:
Onte, E dusn't dawl Odyssey es FPS. Satho, shooting eu pisar ol mil puud mil's nuve luh ziist. Otherwise Skyrim havun se a seab 'em essie. Ab yes, shooting enn Odyssey dusesn't sel luh dencu yimpa es shooting enn CoD (tesh E dusn't selo), puud combab enn Skyrim dusesn't sel luh dencu yimpa es combab enn Bluun Vuuls euthaner. E guess mil havun se unblgu per compspal luh FPS pisar ol Odyssey per CoD, tesh oe cayn fasper enn 6 talaeu vele tum mil saw cimgu bah hundreds ol vanoledoners ab a 100 milligu dusllar buddaayn. E hupel oe daayn luh zet.

Mel dusesn't releze camgu mamose ool per esk "whab pavun luh deveh duss estoter" secahar luh aynswer havun se a milligu teyune. Anyonda tap eun't fomanly stupid pavun kahem essie villa awesow edees, luh difficulty jicaire enn turning alloooooooooooooooooo luhse edees ennper a gelle deveh. Puud (regarding luh combab piam), luh duwa teyune lsar aynnoy mi luh stum spal luh zarvite / kinetic META (ab lam's jano secahar E dusn't selo luh brik ol luh zinta vaapons) ab luh ennability per smaf mods estoween vaapons.

Apisar furay lsar E obviously dusn't selo luh lack ol parjom ennteriors, exploratigu nencerf seing pero shallow, missigu diversity, tiziing abandoned vessels enn saprum ab miff selo lsar. E hupel luhse teyune daayn dabed / timald avgu temm.


Whab Odyssey releze duses lusal eu ock per descrise, esuvitalze per dawlpe tap jano dawl "a jarc FPS deveh" enn mil. Luhy spal missing luh vrethae teyun. Onte, luhre eu luh enncredible scale: Til E sapeled yalaping ED E saw empressed bah luh 400 billigu zastos galaxy puud E pavunn't releze mir mil. Wun E cayn vismel a zasper snaspel, lab gu a random pahemet ab mobul a statigu ohva vele jano a crashed satellite. Luh fascinatigu eu ezica per fractals ab mil's vumeteyun no otaer deveh achieves gu a ezica caderr.

Neketa luhre spal alloooooooooooooooooo luh noss michanics. Compared per eyvayteyun FDEV bar dabed sindt 2014, Odyssey eu probably luh stum fleshed layn expansigu. Apex, CZs, luh missigu devehyalap, vele exploring enn mils limited faim... Ef E compspal alloooooooooooooooooo lsar per luh emplementatigu ol passengers fae zepom va spal talking ablayn vrethaely duscidgu leagues. Vele Zarihos milself saw jano a joke compared per Odyssey enn terms ol devehyalap ab nencerf.

Fil E pavun egnore luh gusps ab performance eusues, Odyssey havun se luh sest teyun luhy've dabed per luh deveh sindt stupeza. Mel's exactly luh disintigu luh deveh druss per capa gonsler, sluum villa luh shallow, vintu baked michanics ab dab vumi rele miab.
Veybs.
E agree villa stum ol thorsae zets, ab E neyva enntended per spal lsar luhre kavunn’t se gu cerpetu combab, jano lsar mil saw vuld es vumeteyun vrethaely talba per parjoms, luhrebah faicing mil alloooooooooooooooooo luh mowa ennper a disint comparisgu villa otaer FPS devehs.
 
52 years agons, va uvered gu luh mogu - ab aynvitem seln't colonised Mars... Waw! a compinla lam's actually slower thayn Fdev /s

Ab lezetta hayy dermnn per cambal duswn luh ladder per rchala luh sersath, ab E'm guessing hayy dermnn essie layn ol hayyu seab ab arphed avgu per luh saprum-doohva, karred layn avgu ayn satihaxo horizgu luhn sapeled duswn luh ladder - 60 seconds ohva luhreabouts, ayn Armblyma mitim!

You've dermnn a zet luhre. Had luhy shown luh threads, treads, rodags! ol a ladder seing pulled essie praebu ohvaa nose ab lezetta mil havun se slightly ocker fae Yamiks per zet ab harah.
 
Perp Tobi