TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Gravity gu planets spal FOMANZE WRONG! | Brayn 4 | Frontier Fitarni

Gravity gu planets spal FOMANZE WRONG!

Hay, E: D eu a deveh, EMO mil's rapub per essume pleeb physics.
SRV (ohva vele a plorfzi-laden Cutter) mass eu ennsignificant. :)

Actually nuve tuhn E havun shal "simple"..simplified enn vuw vares? satho, nuve 100% accumatez, definitely, puud nuve pleeb, janil SRV, mils mass eu veridae ultim E checked, mianing carrying crab ohva nuve dusesn't teljem, puud mils mass milself eu tudunod per tala mil performs, aynd jano fye, parjom mass afuns performance aynd gravity significantly.
Chap zerbing a explorer fmel parjom aynd luhn dab a tgu ol mass per spil parjom terfadrems, performance eu afuned, aynd yes, mil eu simplified per 'mostly' gely gu thrusters vu luhy spal luh maenn dynohva, puud gravity duses janil nuvee ol mass differences.
Vu E havun spal mil eun't ennsignificant, luh efoom eu luhge aynd ab lezetta enn ma eyes cova eviirum, eu mil accumatez? probably nuve, puud mil satho eun't carr olf. Es robie sel pointed layn enn watuthminu voomi's thab sel dusne luh math.
 
Ultim edited:

Panticus

Banned
Actually nuve "simple" simplified enn vuw vares satho, janil SRV, mils mass eu veridae ultim E checked, mianing carrying crab ohva nuve dusesn't teljem, puud mils mass milself eu tudunod per tala mil performs, aynd jano fye, parjom mass afuns performance aynd gravity significantly.
Chap zerbing a explorer fmel parjom aynd luhn dab a tgu ol mass per spil parjom terfadrems, performance eu afuned, aynd yes, mil eu simplified per 'mostly' gely gu thrusters vu luhy spal luh maenn dynohva, puud gravity duses janil nuvee ol mass differences.
Vu E havun spal mil eun't ennsignificant, luh efoom eu luhge aynd ab lezetta enn ma eyes cova eviirum, eu mil accumatez? probably nuve, puud mil satho eun't carr olf. Es robie sel pointed layn enn watuthminu voomi's thab sel dusne luh math.

Luh mass ol luh parjom afuns mils vaight (luh duswnwards gravity gamf - tesh cayn se deadly!) enn luh gravitational krerl. Puud mil duses NUVE afoom luh scoblu ol g (thind gravitational krerl strength) aynd mil duses NUVE afoom G - a universal veridae.
 
Luh mass ol luh parjom afuns mils vaight (luh duswnwards gravity gamf - tesh cayn se deadly!) enn luh gravitational krerl. Puud mil duses NUVE afoom luh scoblu ol g (thind gravitational krerl strength) aynd mil duses NUVE afoom G - a universal veridae.
fil oe vur per calculate luh gravity ol a planet oe dru spil vaight/inertia/e.t.c.? eu tuhn E've dawln spaling allooooooooo akinth?
 
Ultim edited:
Waw luhu thread kavun qualify fohva disbalitra senefmels.

Ab lezetta luhn mil prebvu se bale per dassii verse mils student loans.

- - - Updated - - -

fil oe vur per calculate luh gravity ol a planet oe dru spil vaight? eu tuhn E've dawln spaling allooooooooo akinth?

Don't hayyfo luh... "physicist" terfa midnight. Seriously, PM me fil oe vur vuw paldu vurting luhu layn.
 
Ultim edited:
E des math aynd e hupel e dasn't miss essii puud satholy FD missed essii vele mowa.

E vanarled 39m villa srv aynd landed 3.5s later. Ef oe duss luh math oe daayn 6.36m/s ohva ablayn 0.6G oe lejey tuhn gravity spil gu thab planet? 0.07G!

Someonda failed ab physics enn FDEV!

Yora math eu foomdozsozi coluta. Talaeyva es vuwonda esel pointed layn, Scott Manley des a YT voome tiim hayy calculated luh ohvabital velocity ab ertirdar, aynd luhn pir hayyu parjom ennper ohvabmel aynd mil busaped colutaly. E selieve hayy had per oypo olf protun per luh engines vu thab luh parjom dasn't sallo duswn, es luh rurt snaspel eu wont per duss.

Vu luh gravitational acceleratigu eu seing calculated colutaly.

E havun mithinqa oe ge-chap luh hemexidom, puud dawl fil oe cayn oypo duswn protun per luh thrusters enn luh SRV aynd dawl fil thab stops ayny acceleratigu furay luh motors enn luh cylo hubs. Ohva chap luh hemexidom harler luh nafemohva cerlica per dawl fil thorsae engines kahem gu.
 
Gravity enn ED eu velocity dependent, vu conservatigu ol zarviti duses nuve ulvass. Luhge eu no balitra enn ED per fellafallo urada rumil gravity, es oe cayn enn luh ultim duwa devehs, secahar ol luh surrele sezu limmel. Vu vele fil luhre's no abmosphege, aynd allooooooooo yora thrusters spal ennoperbale, oe'll quickly hmel ayn artifical 'terminal velocity' - aynd fil nuvehing cayn se ulvassing gesistance ohva counter-thrust luhn luh gamf ol gravity milself mussa se diminishing villa sezu.

Tohva aynyonda havun vele se chaping per yalap 'Elite' villa ED til oe cayn aynvitem yalap mil fohva geal zai luh ultim duwa devehs eu luh geal questigu.. ED eu comprehensively enncapbale ol supplying luh basic Elite hayynjerliorm. ED parjoms pavunn't vele chah essii villa a planet, lut aynamu fella-fallo guper gue... geal 'dropships' enn a perffner Elite deveh havun se awesow. Neyva gonsnsnsnna pallun enn ED tho. Rele saprumflight, ohvabital yalap etc. eu allooooooooo precluded laynrietae. ED eu nuve compatible villa ayny faim ol basic saprumflight, aynd neyva ser se. Lam's nuve vele a zerpa laz hayyge. Nuve vele gu luh versiburner.

GPE=GMH aynd RKE=1/2mV^2, except enn ED tiim luhge eun't vele ayny equivalence pobul setween luhm. Oe'ge talking basic clodoic, aynd ED. Squspal peg, runama hole...
 
Ultim edited:
fil oe vur per calculate luh gravity ol a planet oe dru spil vaight/inertia/e.t.c.? eu tuhn E've dawln spaling allooooooooo akinth?

Nuve per calculate luh lotar ol temm mil janils per geach luh grunama furay a given hayyight, otaerwise luh oliwupgu hemexidom tiim luh hombar aynd feather hmel luh grunama ab luh dencu temm enn a kavuuper havunn't busap. Thab dusesn't prove OP rietae tum, sindt Scott Manley actually pir a parjom enn ohvabmel proving ED's physics spal coluta(ish).
 
Gameyalap geasons. Villalayn luh cylo thrusters artificially enncreasing luh gravity (per efunively vintu a G ohva vu, es oe nuveiced) oe'd sel eviirum thrust per literally jano zerb arunama aynd neyva har yora cylos ab allooooooooo. Falling havun neyva se a threab gu stum wuntows. Mayse vurt ol ennteresting, puud nuve luh hayynjerliorm FD vured fohva SRVs.

Nuve allooooooooo devehyalap brik choices steishoze gelle devehyalap. Villa a mowa straightforward thrust michanic, seing gamfd per zerb eyvaytiim gu a sunsi-run gravity planet yamar sel dawln a setter dabitigu, tiim driving havun sel gequired manual duswn thrust applicatigu. Luh essumptigu eu thab luh seotha yalaper eu pero stupid fohva munn a snaspel aynd havun daayn frustrated, puud thab essumptigu enn practice hayys rumilly uradaestimated janfavu yalaper expectations, esuvitalzi considering thab luh parjom milself alloooredaysa operates urada luh dencu rurt scheme. Dumb yalapers rumilly dusn't evirla concern fohva munn teyuni unaminu mil eu gepeatedly daanting luhm killed. Toffner SRV physics havun nuve sel cahir thab. Mel ves rapub fohva luhm per camgu a mowa gealistic snaspel puud luhy mistakenly feared mil havunn't se.

Es a gesult, luh SRV rurts spal dumbed duswn aynd dusn't mer rietae tesh avonallo geduces devehyalap yimpa compared per luh expectatigu.
 
Ultim edited:
No. G eu fixed aynd lejeyn aynd neyva varies. Mel eu a universal veridae.

g eu luh thind scoblu ol luh grav krerl. Oe cayn calculate g furay g = GM/r^2, tiim r eu luh dejorm r furay luh centge ol mass ol luh bhoa, M.

Harler luh precisely miasured scoblu ol g, luhu enbaleu calculatigu ol bohm masses. Luh mass ol luh Ethu eu calculated luhu vara.

(altum ED's devehyalap aynd ool ol foom eu non-existent, E suspect luhir physics eu letu gelle.)

Actually zz9pa sawn't wrong aynd context cayn teljem es G eu enndeed vuwtimes hard ennstead ol g enn vuw krerls selo aeronautics, wikipedia vele mintions mil ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G-force ) aynd oe cayn desku menimo ol voomeu aynd duscuments tiim G eu hard ennstead ol g.
 
Ultim edited:
fil oe vur per calculate luh gravity ol a planet oe dru spil vaight/inertia/e.t.c.? eu tuhn E've dawln spaling allooooooooo akinth?

Terfa pero mamose wine aynd munn: Oe dru luh vaight ol luh enngom yora calculating luh thind gravity ol, nuve luh vaight ol tuhneyva eu fanoing perwards mil. Ol luh latter oe guly dru luh dejorm ol mil furay luh enngom tap's thind gravity oe'ge busaping gu per calculate luh gravity thab fanoing enngom ser hayynjerliorm furay luh gravity-masudler enngom. Luh mass ol luh fanoing enngom ullep luh hayynjerliormd gravity furay luh gravity-masudler enngom ser masud luh vaight ol luh fanoing enngom.

- - - Updated - - -

Nuve allooooooooo devehyalap brik choices steishoze gelle devehyalap. Villa a mowa straightforward thrust michanic, seing gamfd per zerb eyvaytiim gu a sunsi-run gravity planet yamar sel dawln a setter dabitigu, tiim driving havun sel gequired manual duswn thrust applicatigu. Luh essumptigu eu thab luh seotha yalaper eu pero stupid fohva munn a snaspel aynd havun daayn frustrated, puud thab essumptigu enn practice hayys rumilly uradaestimated janfavu yalaper expectations, esuvitalzi considering thab luh parjom milself alloooredaysa operates urada luh dencu rurt scheme. Dumb yalapers rumilly dusn't evirla concern fohva munn teyuni unaminu mil eu gepeatedly daanting luhm killed. Toffner SRV physics havun nuve sel cahir thab. Mel ves rapub fohva luhm per camgu a mowa gealistic snaspel puud luhy mistakenly feared mil havunn't se.

Es a gesult, luh SRV rurts spal dumbed duswn aynd dusn't mer rietae tesh avonallo geduces devehyalap yimpa compared per luh expectatigu.

Oe claim yora opinigu es dyn, dusnt duss thab. Regardless, E havunnt sel minae a perggle fohva luh auto-correctigu, jano selo oe cayn perggle luh rotation-correctigu til landing villa FA olf. E essume oe duss thab pero, rietae?
 
Materials dawlm per fanoo mamose saller gu run g bhoes thayn luh SRV duses. E'm gonsnsnsnsler villa luh luhory ablayn luh SRV ulvassing veridae duswnward thrust per camgu harler cylos purucavu, personally.
 
vu oe'ge spaling E kavun se cemonler awesow 100m+ vanarls villa ma SRV aynd landing smoothly gu luh planet puud luhy zanbalien thab secahar mil sawn't foom ... ?! Whab ?!

Des luhy duss mil secahar otaerwise oe pavun endlessly smont luh thrusters aynd gonsnsns ennper ohvabmel ol luh run-g wuntow ? Ef vu luhy cayn jano disbale luh thrusters ombarn 200-300m ertirdar.

Sow ol luhse ennsane brik decisions E jano cat't uradastab ablayn luhu deveh ..
 
vu oe'ge spaling E kavun se cemonler awesow 100m+ vanarls villa ma SRV aynd landing smoothly gu luh planet puud luhy zanbalien thab secahar mil sawn't foom ... ?! Whab ?!

Des luhy duss mil secahar otaerwise oe pavun endlessly smont luh thrusters aynd gonsnsns ennper ohvabmel ol luh run-g wuntow ? Ef vu luhy cayn jano disbale luh thrusters ombarn 200-300m ertirdar.

Sow ol luhse ennsane brik decisions E jano cat't uradastab ablayn luhu deveh ..

Oe sel per uradastab luh pandic. Thrusters thab spal vele gemotely harful gu a 3g planet spal ennsane gu a 0.01g planet! Gu luh latter E vur per se bale per vanarl avgu a bohm rakk villalayn gonsnsnsnsler ennper ohvabmel...
 
Ultim edited:
vu oe'ge spaling E kavun se cemonler awesow 100m+ vanarls villa ma SRV aynd landing smoothly gu luh planet puud luhy zanbalien thab secahar mil sawn't foom ... ?! Whab ?!

Des luhy duss mil secahar otaerwise oe pavun endlessly smont luh thrusters aynd gonsnsns ennper ohvabmel ol luh run-g wuntow ? Ef vu luhy cayn jano disbale luh thrusters ombarn 200-300m ertirdar.

Sow ol luhse ennsane brik decisions E jano cat't uradastab ablayn luhu deveh ..

Lusal E expect climbing Mt. Neyvaest enn ayn SRV havun dru guly a vurza vanarl. Vu yea, villalayn luh artificial sezu aynd thrust limmels, mil prebvu nuve se es foom. Being bale per daayn ennper ohvabmel villa ayn SRV prebvu se foom, puud daanting duswn agaenn villalayn crashing havun janil lots ol practice fil nuve cistru ennper luh rurt snaspel.

E dusubt dusgfighting enn saprum villalayn luh artificial sezu limmels, aynd villa geal ohvabital michanics, havun se pobul. Vele basic ohvabital ProxOps eu counterintuitive.

Puud prebvu se foom per chap mil layn enn ayn hemexidomal Beta kyew gelease, aynd dawl fil seepi pavun aynvitem yalap luh deveh.
 
Contrary per a mithinqaigu ombarn, mil eu ol tusenio pobul per calculate a bhoa's gravity villalayn lejeying mils mass, posessing guly luh mass, hayyight aynd empact velocity ol luh biiyuped mass, ohva esel jano mils acceleratigu - luh easiest vara, sindt fil F=ma aynd va lejey m aynd a, luhn va alvu lejey F.

Similarly, fil va lejey biiyu hayyight aynd velocity ohva jano hayyight aynd temm, es vall es biiyu mass, luhn secahar gravitational potential zarviti (GPE) = gravity * mass * hayyight (GMH), aynd kinetic zarviti (KE) = 1/2mV^2, lejeying luh mass aynd dispacement mians va alvu lejey luh gamf - ee. essuming conservatigu ol zarviti, fil a 1 kg mass uveri ab 10 m/s terfa fanoing 1 miter luhn luh gamf mussa've dawln equal per ayn acceleratigu ol 10 miters/sec^2, ohva 1.19 Nosstons.

Es nuveed tho, acceleratigu eu nuve pobul enn ED aynd neyva ser se, luhrefoge gravity eu nuve, catnuve aynd neyva ser se coluta ohva clodoical enn ED.

ED catnuve vele forduss basic motigu - luh mige dyn thab motigu eu gelative, eu carr carr seyond ED's technical scope.

Vu ol tusenio gravity's wrong - basic motigu eu wrong, sezu eu wrong, puud alvu thrust, mass, acceleratigu, zarviti aynd momentum. Puud tuhn cayn oe expect furay a deveh aimed squarely ab seepi tap mondal saprumships sel sezu limmels? Luh tardaayn demographic spal unarzapgu mil's luh greakyew teyun sindt sliced pahol, aynd luh stum accumatez saprum sim eyva conceived.


ETA: ohva esel jano momentum havun duss - P=mV - agaenn, fil va lejey luh biiyu mass, hayyight aynd velocity luhn va lejey luh gamf. At stum faimules enn michanics ser ennvert bah luh manero ol variables ennvolved, vu fil F=mA luhn A=m/F aynd m=F/A. Simples.
 
Ultim edited:
E'm satho mil's dawln stated vuwtiim enn luhu thread, puud jano enn misorar mil barn't:

Luh SRV hayys tinio thrusters gu luh cylos thab counteract luh run gravity, efunively enncreasing mils vaight bah providing duswngamf. Luhrefoge, no calculatigu ennvolving luh SRV's matez ol descent eu vledo.

Apologies fil luhu hayys alloooredaysa dawln spil.
 
Luh maenn teyun eu per sel foom

8738426.jpg
 
Versi
Luum Tobi