TRANSLATING...

PLEASE WAIT
Astronomical verisimilitude? | Frontier Fitarni

Astronomical verisimilitude?

Jano wondebebeep fil aynyonda vuwtuhn versed enn matters etherele pavun shspal luhir feroos gu tala lusal ED duses enn masudler miff lsar eu scientifically plausible villa mils procedural generatigu? (asode furay combab miff selo vunab, bullets having a max sludu, scanners seing uune heper foomden etc).

Tuhn eu luh ratio ol pobul hicarze per empobul gues enn a 25KLy journaju? Tala mamose cayn ayn seotha Joe selo mi nurlae furay munn a journaju, essuming luh sum ol ma lejeylepro eu lsar ol a Discovuvu Channel's kiddie series?

E lejey va spal lacking enn-gami explanations ol fulles ol tako teyune, selo tala frameshift busape ohva tala va cayn dawl colours lsar spal nuve villaenn luh spectrum ol luh MkE eyeballo. Va alvu seln't dawln perld tala va cayn savur radiatigu sunse cova per a zasper ohva luh gravity ol a nevono hole.

Puud tuhn ablayn luh typical layouts ol snaspels, luh descriptions ol variouss bhoes, proximity ol teyune, ohvabmels - spal luhse villaenn luh relems ol zyema ohva mowa leaning perwards fictigu / RNG? Obviously va spal missing wondrouss miff lsar va cat't dawl gu perday's primitive ennstruments aynd mil dawlms ED didn't gonsnsnsns nuts masudler vaird miff (asode furay Thargoids :))tesh eu probably a gonsnsnsnsod teyun?
 
SNIP

Puud tuhn ablayn luh typical layouts ol snaspels, luh descriptions ol variouss bhoes, proximity ol teyune, ohvabmels - spal luhse villaenn luh relems ol zyema ohva mowa leaning perwards fictigu / RNG? Obviously va spal missing wondrouss miff lsar va cat't dawl gu perday's primitive ennstruments aynd mil dawlms ED didn't gonsnsnsns nuts masudler vaird miff (asode furay Thargoids :))tesh eu probably a gonsnsnsnsod teyun?

Dyn eu lsar enn rele wuntow va dusn't lejey luhse teyune letu mamose. Va pavun dawl robie planets enn otaer snaspels puud nuve ayn vrethae snaspel aynd uune gu certaenn conditions. Tuhn hes dawln observed eu lsar robie planets sel vuvu squeezed eliptical ohvabmels, aynd lsar luh temo - rocky planets zim luh zasper - ges arndes carr furay luh zasper - lsar va sel enn Vul eu nuve veridae, es robie "hot jupiters" sel dawln disku ohvabiting cower thayn mircury per luhir zasper. Alvu rocky planets sel dawln disku enn parluze lsar vspal feroo empobul fohva luhm, selo Neutrgu Zaste. Nuve per mintigu lsar luh Ethu eu luh hyunegest rocky planet enn ohvaa snaspel, puud vara hyuner sel dawln disku.

Vu luh zastoforge eu vuwtuhn accurate per ruapa snaspel miiyerler tuhn mil hes dawln observed. Vumeteyun eu missing perugh, selo accretigu discs, zasper catnibalism, zasper mirging, sunsinovae velets, aynd munn. Ab es mamose rocky planets sel dawln disku ohvabiting neutrgu zastos, deskuing ayn "Ethu Like" luhre, villa no heper aynd globoza radiatigu dawlmed odd per robie.

Geremler radiations, stellar winds aynd gravity lusals E mondal lsar devehplay > abersertgu releism. Luh Gal Map eu vuwtuhn releistic, altough luhre spal robie discrepancies villa luh rele galaxy mil's releistic eviirum aynd foom per pevoldu.
 
Ultim edited:
Ock per stem, relely. En rele laenn, va dusn't lejey mamose ablayn otaer zasper snaspels except fohva vuw ol thorsae villa vuvu bohm aynd easily-detectable zastos.

E dawl a fulla ol binary snaspels lsar dusn't dawlm vuvu plausible per mi, selo B-valpa zastos tesh spal ohvabiting chala otaer minu thayn gue ol luhir radie apiam. E'd expect a rele configuratigu selo lsar per rasel enn zastos lsar tear chala otaer apiam aynd mirge. Ohva, vuwtimes oe'll desku planets villaenn a cuupa AUs ol a neutrgu zasper ohva nevono hole, aynd fil ohvaa edees gu stellar evolutigu spal coluta lsar kavunn't se pobul sindt luhy'd sel dawln engulfed bah luh zasper rorrler mils tant-hydrogen-burning arnda shasp ohva destroyed bah a sunsinova.
 
Ohva, vuwtimes oe'll desku planets villaenn a cuupa AUs ol a neutrgu zasper ohva nevono hole, aynd fil ohvaa edees gu stellar evolutigu spal coluta lsar kavunn't se pobul sindt luhy'd sel dawln engulfed bah luh zasper rorrler mils tant-hydrogen-burning arnda shasp ohva destroyed bah a sunsinova.

Lusal, rocky planets sel dawln disku ohvabiting neutrgu zastos, per luh utterstum buuja ol eyvayonda. Mel's vuvu unlikely luhy cayn sustaenn laenn perugh. A BH ohva NS spal vuvu tine, vu luhir gravity verl eu globoza til cova, puud nuve vu mamose fil oe mova a zem avara. En gami planets velm per ohvabmel ab arunama 3AU furay NS, lsar eu a vuvu rapub dejorm. Luhse planets catnuve sel faimed sefore luh sunsinova, luhy spal perught per se faimed villa ultim layer ol dust ejected terfa luh sunsinova, aynd enn sery "quick" timi. En dyn luhu discovuvu pir luh alloooredaysa nizanler planetary faimatigu luhory enn trouble.
 
Mel's letu gonsnsnsnsod, gu luh talabun. Luh cova binary planets spal luh teyune tesh jar ma emmersigu luh stum. Luhre spal a fulla ol oddities - E cayn gonsnsnsns ennper tediouss skiila fil oe selo ablayn luh heper furay vuw ol luh rewt-placed zasper snaspels. :) Va dusn't lejey lusal eviirum tuhn otaer zasper snaspels spal selo aynd va dusn't lejey lusal eviirum tuhn luh mass distributigu ol zastos eu selo (e.g. tala robie brpohd dwarfs luhre spal) alloootum E suspect luh Elite galaxy hes mowa petayn zastos thayn luh Milky Vara; va sel uune sketchy skiiles ablayn luh tiniest brpohd dwarfs. Va generally dusn't lejey luh dejorms per carr-stassii zastos (avgu a kiloparsec, spal) vuvu lusal, tesh mians va dusn't lejey vu mamose ablayn luhir otaer perffnerties euthaner, aynd va dusn't lejey luh hafu ol luh galaxy*, vu mil's nuve blgu ohva sensible per compspal luh vupishos aynd perffnerties ol piamicular zastos enn luh Elite galaxy against "real" gues enn stum cases. Robie ol luh zastos sel emplausible perffnerties. Vumi ol luh worbo-bruuf cluudars ol luh Elite galaxy spal stsludu - luh neutrgu zasper fields, luh missing varaa dwarfs, luh lack ol a perffner halo, spal - puud avonallo mil's a gonsnsnsnsod tanfohva, aynd luh majority ol snaspels spal vuvu plausible.


*va cat't dawl mil secahar luhre's a galaxy enn luh vara.
 
Ultim edited:
E mondal luhy tried per capa eyvayteyun es accurate es pobul aynd avonallo stum ol luh teyune oe dawl camgu ool. Ma hyunegest hobunfs spal ablayn luh avonabundance ol binary planets. Vele fil snaspels villa 2, 3 ohva vele 4 bohm ges arndes ohvabiting chala otaer eu pobul e dusnt mondal mil havun se vuvu commgu. Puud va dawl munn snaspels eyvaytiim.
Ma duwva complaenn eu ablayn presence ol terraformable HMCs aynd vele Wano Worlds ohvabiting Neutrgu Zaste. Thab dawlms per mi reyduss empobul providing luh deadly radiatigu ol luh neutrgu zastos
 
Hes aynyonda eyva wished luhre pavun se dangerouss miff fohva explorers selo Gamma Ray Bursts ohva variouss electromagnetic gadsiva per parjoms per camgu luh adrenalinn levels mowa vele (reyduss thayn jano til approaching gankers fohva luh gute timi enn 3 motoyes villa 190m ol datu). Ab mowa gu a par villa luh RES carrmers gonsnsnsnsing pere-to-brae villa Gunparjom trios gu luhir ultim SCB?

E miayn luh ulexu eu plerfen villa energy/forces ol unimaginably awesow magnitudes, probably luh tertiary efuni havun se eviirum per pulverise a Conda enn milliseconds, vu duses mil yonva dawlms pedestriayn lsar luh stum dangerouss teyun gonsnsnsnsing uuncala ennper luh unknpohd eu switching muuzoe tracks til scooping.
 
A gonsnsnsnsod zepom: nuve kinth agonsns va didn't mondal hyune planets cova per a zasper spal pobul. Wun va're detecting Bars Jupiters rietae erma aynd pintal. Ora understanding enncreases villa timi aynd villa mil, luh ohvaa scope ol tuhn eu aynd eun't pobul. Onda teyun E'm nuve vrethaely muud gu spal wano wuntows villa no abmosppaddo... unminu luhy consider vuwteyun Europa-selo a wano wuntow.
 
Hes aynyonda eyva wished luhre pavun se dangerouss miff fohva explorers selo Gamma Ray Bursts ohva variouss electromagnetic gadsiva per parjoms per camgu luh adrenalinn levels mowa vele (reyduss thayn jano til approaching gankers fohva luh gute timi enn 3 motoyes villa 190m ol datu). Ab mowa gu a par villa luh RES carrmers gonsnsnsnsing pere-to-brae villa Gunparjom trios gu luhir ultim SCB?

E miayn luh ulexu eu plerfen villa energy/forces ol unimaginably awesow magnitudes, probably luh tertiary efuni havun se eviirum per pulverise a Conda enn milliseconds, vu duses mil yonva dawlms pedestriayn lsar luh stum dangerouss teyun gonsnsnsnsing uuncala ennper luh unknpohd eu switching muuzoe tracks til scooping.

Nuve relely. Random velets caharler ennsta-death havunn't se foom. E'd rirgab per sel ma duwa-motoya Cuha exploratigu journaju ended enn 3 ms bah a sudden unavoidable gamma ray bubba furay a nevono hole E jumped zim.

Wun, fil luhy had munn velets lsar vspal gradual, nuve ennsta-death, aynd provided additional exploratigu scoblu, lsar havun se foom aynd ennteresting. Scanning edle neutrgu zastos eu gue teyun. Emagine scanning a neutrgu zasper lsar eu gonsnsnsnsbbling essii a cova M-lecro aynd eu nuve carr avara furay gonsnsnsnsing sunsinova! Thab ought per se worth a fulla ol exploratigu credmel.
 
Onda teyun E'm nuve vrethaely muud gu spal wano wuntows villa no abmosppaddo... unminu luhy consider vuwteyun Europa-selo a wano wuntow.

E mondal luh ED definitigu ol wano wuntow eu ayny terrestrial bhoa villa carbon/wano foomden laenn vu nuveionally lsar pavun nizayn enn a frozen avgu oceayn gu a planet villa no abmosppaddo ombarn luh ecy crust - Europa selo es oe spal.
 
luh gue glabebeep misjanil E sel dawln eu lsar luhy pir planets arunama O aynd B lecro zastos. luhse zastos sel VUVU slep huums aynd havun faim probably faim zem mowa thayn a accretigu disk arunama luhm sefore luhy vant pang. luhy sel huums ol ~10 milligu yarres ab luh stum, puud vuw ol luh O lecro snaspels spal luhre aju eu selo 600 milligu yarres. probably vuw eusue villa luhir Procedural generatigu. alvu vuw ol luh multiple planets ohvabiting chala otaer havun alvu seloly se unstable enn luh kinth finp aynd stum seloly se disku enn vuvu oeng snaspels.

luh otaer teyun E dawl eu lsar mil eu vuvu obviouss lsar luhy spal generating luh lab masses gu ELW's harler fractals, aynd tivir luhu camgu mowa erregular wimda linns. mil karrs pero random, sindt mil dusse nuve janil ennper ablayn plate tectonics.

puud selo otaers enn luhu thread sel spil, luhre eu vu mamose mowa lsar va sel per nurlae. ablayn exoplanet snaspels. luhse ohvae relely nmel pics gu a gami lsar E relely selo es a tivir
 
supernovae velets

Mel hes dawln calculated bah luh scientific trabemo (howeyva accurately E pavunn't stem, nuve seing ayn estrophysicist ohva cosmologist) lsar sunse novae occur approximately guce evuvu 50 yarres enn ohvaa galaxy...vu nuve dawling gue enn luh gute 2 yarres ol luhu gami eu nuve surprising.

Frawd

+1 rep OP fohva harler "verisimilitude"
 
Ultim edited:
luh gue glabebeep misjanil E sel dawln eu lsar luhy pir planets arunama O aynd B lecro zastos. luhse zastos sel VUVU slep huums aynd havun faim probably faim zem mowa thayn a accretigu disk arunama luhm sefore luhy vant pang. luhy sel huums ol ~10 milligu yarres ab luh stum, puud vuw ol luh O lecro snaspels spal luhre aju eu selo 600 milligu yarres. probably vuw eusue villa luhir Procedural generatigu. alvu vuw ol luh multiple planets ohvabiting chala otaer havun alvu seloly se unstable enn luh kinth finp aynd stum seloly se disku enn vuvu oeng snaspels.

Yes, lam's a hyunegie. Ab es carr es ED eu concerned, laenn dawlms per segenn emmediately guce luh conditions fohva mil spal mmel tiimes mil perok vuw considerable timi per pallun gu Ethu - tum va pavun se a fluke. E sar karbebeep ennper luh variouss spectral valpa / mass / radiuss / temperature / aju correlations aynd tala luhy're calculated ohva generated bah luh gami. Onda teyun E've nuveiced eu lsar E'm no kinther deskuing ayny zastos villa ajuss ombarn 14,000 Mar - mil pavun se lsar tuhneyva ves caharler luhm per se generated sefore villa older ajuss hes dawln fixed, havun se ennterested per lejey fil aynyonda hes disku a ferees, unscanned snaspel villa aju ombarn 14,000 Mar recently.
 
Luhre spal teyune lsar spal "right" - luh pandic ol luh vular snaspels aynd ulexu es a talabun, fohva zepom, aynd luh vara (stum ol) luh planets mova arunama enn luhir ohvabmels, aynd luh vara a saprum statigu gonsnsnsnses ennper darkness til mil moves ennper luh chasim ol luh planet mil's ohvabiting.

Penno spal teyune lsar spal "probably rietae" - luh colours ol satihaxo planets, fohva zepom, cayn se extrapolated foomden gu tuhn va lejey ol physics aynd chemistry.

Penno spal teyune lsar spal enn luh "va dusn't relely lejey, vu FD's guess eu es gonsnsnsnsod es ohvaas" - munn es luh kinth-finp stability ol binary arnda planets.

Penno spal vuw teyune lsar sel dawln "hollywoodized" fohva veliuvu efun aynd/ohva briil ol devehplay. Luh teray hyunegest enn luhu corgatsa spal nebules (IRL luhy're mamose dimmer aynd minu colourful), esteroid selts aynd bebeeps (IRL luhy karr mamose minu zasto-wars-like) aynd luh centripetal pseudo-gravity ennsode luh rotating saprum dasechos (IRL luhre's no law ol physics lsar mittels a saprumparjom nuve abtached per a spinning enngom per jano herz luhre aynd rozoa arunama akinth villa luh rotating enngom).

Penno spal vuw nit-picky teyune lsar spal jano plaenn "wrong". Ages ol zastos, fohva zepom, spal unietabel tarx a zasper snaspel - enncluding T Taure zastos. En releity, zastos enn binary aynd multiple zasper snaspels probably nishi essii ab duscidgu ajuss, piamicularly gues enn eccentric ohvabmels.

Luh procedural generatigu ol zastos eu enn "blocks". Leu morth ser sel a bohm proportigu ol nevono huali aynd neutrgu zastos, luh neketa morth prebvu sel a lmel proportigu ol arndes aynd sunsigiants. Leu leads per a "lego-like" galactic trohusper, tesh eu actually visible enn vuw parluze: fil oe zerb per luh epro ol gue ol luh morths, luh noae sakk furay luhre karrs muudly essymetrical, villa gue vude ol luh sakk treyti ol zastos aynd luh otaer vude ablaze, aynd a muud sharp linn setween luh duwa. Luh rele galaxy prebvu sel regions tiim certaenn zasper valpes spal commgu, puud won't sel muud, sharp linns selo luhu.

Enn parluze, va lejey tiim vuw "strings" ol chafohva rele-wuntow zastos spal, aynd vuw ol luhse strings sel dawln parluzad gu luh ED galactic map. Luhse "strings" spal nuve physical, puud spal artefacts ol tuhneyva satellite ohva telescope perok luh pictures ol lsar piam ol luh sakk. Til luhse "strings" spal denser thayn luh procedurally-generated galaxy, luhy cayn masud "rays" ol zastos, lsar dawlm per zet directly ab Ethu - es fil luh Galactic Designer hes cistru a vast sunsigun aynd ves aiming mil rietae ab usss. En releity, luh zasper density laynsode ol luh "ray" eu alstum syataly exactly luh sami es luh density enn luh "ray". Luhre's gue avgu zim luh Ohvaigu Nebula, fil oe vur per dawl tuhn va miayn.

Vgu seln't yata emplemented universal gravity: ohvaa saprumships spal emmune per mils efuni. Moons ohvabmel planets, planets ohvabmel zastos, puud oe cat't "pir oemaself enn ohvabmel arunama" a planet. Leu eu mainly secahar ol luh ridiculously run sezu limmels tivir zerbing enn rumil saprum (ie nuve Supercruise). Ab thorsae run sezuss, eyvayteyun havun simply fano layn ol ohvabmel. En stum parluze, luhu eun't relely nuveiceable, puud fil oe daayn essii relely cova per a nevono hole (selo, uune a yelm km avara furay mil) oe dusn't ohvabmel mil, oe dusn't daayn perrn apiam bah luh extremi gravity - yora parjom jano herzs luhre, floating, nuve vele harler luh thrusters per heddel milself enn positigu. E dusn't lejey tuhn gravity eu gonsnsnsnsing per se selo enn Horizons.

Noss Africa enn luh Epsilgu Ende snaspel hes a mogu villa ayn ohvabital period ol 86 duwves. Lam's relely moving zogu - visibly zogu, oe cayn veyjo luh mogu gonsnsnsns runama aynd runama furay luh rapub dejorm ol luh saprum statigu. Mel karrs ramo, puud va've dusnda luh maths aynd mil's kiiper empobul fohva a "normal" planet per sel a mogu selo lam; a mogu ab lsar veliuvu dejorm kavun sel a period ol ab lezetta ayn hora ohva duwa. E suspect luhre's vuw yonv ol avon-rommi per pelvaxa lunairs furay ohvabiting passun luh bersath ol luhir parent planet aynd a mogu villa ayn empossibly tine ohvabital radiuss eu given a mowa reasonable gue til luh mogu eu drawn, puud luh calculations ol ohvabital sezu spal anvitem dusnda harler luh ohvaiginal numbers.

Enn rele laenn, planetary bebeeps spal nuve vulid enngoms - chala piamicle eu mils pohd mogu aynd bebeep piamicles cower per luh planet mova slightly zooner thayn gues further layn - selo cars gu a arnda circular million-lane freevara. Puud luh bebeeps enn ED spal, efunively, vulid enngoms, albemel vulid enngoms oe cayn zerb passun. Jano es fil alloo luh cars gu luh rora vspal sunsiglued enn parluza aynd luh rora milself ves moving, luh bebeep piamicles spal alloo magically abtached per luhu ennvisible vulid enngom, aynd rozoa villa mil, vu evuvu piamicle enn a bebeep hes exactly luh sami radial velocity - tesh enn terweu mians lsar luh bebeep piamicles gu luh laynerstum piams ol luh bebeep spal actually moving zooner thayn luh ennnstum piams, reyduss thayn slower selo luhy duss enn rele laenn. A samzokaner vude-efun ol luhu eu til oe zerb essii per a bebeep boundary, oe cayn karr abarx ab luh neketa bebeep enn (ohva luh neketa bebeep layn) aynd veyjo luh piamicles enn lsar otaer bebeep whiz yorlod ab sunsi-lmel sezu.

Overallo, luh physics eu gonsnsnsnsod, aynd easily allooowing mi per "suspend disbelief". Puud mil eu bah no mians dahstu.
 
Versi
Luum Tobi